My Sugar Pie

This review is for pies that have been shipped and delivered -- and inevitable devoured! The process to order and have a pie delivered couldn't be easier. The cost is on the higher side, but for a freshly made pie to be delivered to the door of someone you love? It's completely worth it! Recently I ordered a Dutch apple pie for my best friends birthday. I ordered it a few weeks in advance, during the busy holiday season. The pie was delivered on time and was delicious (so my friend reported!) I have also had these pies delivered to me for my birthday (in Washington, DC !) and couldn't recommend them more highly. The selection of pies available is extensive - something for everyone. The pies themselves are fantastic. Fresh ingredients and easy to warm up in the oven. Also, each pie comes delivered in a glass pie dish that you can keep. Highly recommend these pies and their shipping/delivery service!

This charming pie shop offered a delightful selection. The s'mores pie was a particular favorite.

Oh My Goodness... which pie(s) to go with? They all look sooooo good and actually they all are soooo good. Since they had a special of 3 slices of pie for $16, I felt the need to narrow it down to three. I chose :Peach & Blueberry... what a delicious combination. First time for me, but I would definitely eat that again. Sweet but not overly sweet. The flaky pie crust calms down the sweetness and it's a perfect match in my mind. Rhubarb... I love the slight tartness and as above, the buttery flaky crust goes perfect with it. Sugar Cream Pie... that is my go to in Indiana, I mean it is the state pie, isn't it? I do judge bakeries by this simple yet delicious pie. This one is awesome. I loved the creamy filling again perfectly matched with the crumbly flaky crust.They do know how to make a perfect crust. It's a buttery flaky mess. But that's what makes it good. If your pie crust doesn't flake every which way and crumble into a thousand pieces when you're trying to spear it with a fork, then it's not worth your time. I'm in love with the pie crust here. Best part: they have real whip cream already whipped for you for sale. I highly recommend it. Three pieces of pie and one container of whipped cream together made for an awesome experience. You could probably stretch the whip cream over 4-5 pieaces of pie, but I like to heap it on.

I love everything about My Sugar Pie! The website is super easy to navigate and I have never had less than a stellar experience, regardless of flavor I chose! Once the order is placed, pick up is a breeze. It's located on a cute little side street in Zionsville, so lots of fun to be had from the car to pie shop! I think the packaging is sweet, a little polka dotted gross grain ribbon tied in a bow, which is great if you're going straight to somewhere you need a darling hostess gift! Also dont forget to grab a tub of the homemade whipped topping available in their little on-store refrigerator! Staff is helpful and patient and pie by the slice is available when you pop in randomly, too!

Cute little shop in Zionsville.Went up get truffles from another shop and saw this across the street.Bought a peach blueberry strudel pie. Very good! Filling is nice and firm not runny all. Crust is good and flaky. The strusel topping is a bit sweet for me but my husband loves it, even eating pie for breakfast.The pies come in glass pie plates, which you can get $1 off next pie but we don't live in Zionsville. Next time near there will get more pie.

This was the cutest little shop in Zionsville! The staff was really nice and respectful. When they say they have the best sugar pie they aren't bluffing!!I loved the outdoor seating and the small town scenery. It was very affordable, tasty, and I will definitely be going back asap!

Me oh my, I love pie. Care for a slice of scrumptious delight with a full measure of love and lots of butter? ...then you should make the trek to the Village of Zion and order up a slice of pie. It was fantastic, and the taste? ....only my mother and grandmother could do better. I had Sugar Cream and my wife had Cherry. There are no bad choices here, but if you bring a friend then be prepared to share and also be prepared for buyer's remorse because every slice is special so you'll be doubting yourself and planning the next visit before the last bite....or you could just do the smart thing and take a whole pie (or 2) home with you. You're welcome.

The best pie I've ever tried in my life! Compared to all other bakeries with pies, this place beats them all. You can order pies ahead of time with tons of options to choose from and they're always good and fresh. My favorite is the blueberry with Dutch topping!

Great wonderful pies!!!!Worth the drive!!Highly recommended!!Have eaten pies from here since they opened!Order early on line for Thanksgiving.Check them out!!

The best pie's in the state Try the cherry Dutch crumb I wish it was closer to Carmel