Milktooth

This is one of the best brunches I've ever had. I'm thankful to have found Milktooth via a Conde Nast article prior to a trip to Indianapolis because it was definitely a highlight for me. The wait can get a bit long but they sat us within a reasonable time at a few bar seats. The environment was electric and once inside you just know you are about to have an enjoyable experience and meal.I started with the banana milk iced coffee and I can't believe I've never had anything like this before, it was delicious! Not too sweet and the perfect compliment to all the savory goodies in our meal. My friend and I split the burger, sourdough waffle, and side of cheddar grits. The burger had crispy edges to the patty and an amazing relish. The waffle had some crazy cool flavor combinations with honeycomb, beats and Parmesan cheese. And you can never got wrong with grits. It was an amazing meal in a super trendy, not pretentious environment and I loved every bit of it!

The quality of Food that comes out of Milktooth's tiny kitchen is just astonishing. I mean the audacity of Jonathan Brooks and his chefs to put out locally sourced, creative, delicious food consistently - how dare they. Honestly though because it really makes it hard to brunch elsewhere and not be just a little eh.The Service is wonderful but be prepared to wait 10 min at least up 2 hrs on a nice Saturday morning. Good news is you can always order from their coffee bar and pastry bar to tide you over. The ambiance is electric, hipster, thrifty vibes. The tables are sat community style so if your coming with a smaller party you might be sat with another couple at opposite ends but just a heads up. Honestly I love it though, I always make new friends. We prefer the patio just over here praying for sunny better days.

Milktooth was always one of my favorite brunch locations in Indy for its variety and seemingly endless menu changes. Coming back 3 years after my last visit, Milktooth is still the same great restaurant. Always packed, great coffee, and an equally enjoyable vibe. Milktooth doesn't miss.One noted change since we left the city a few years ago was that the portion sizes had notable changed in terms of the Dutch baby which stinks a little.

Met with a couple people here Saturday morning, it was pretty busy as we finally got some decent weather in Indy. We weren't a fan of the menu and it took a while to narrow down our options. Our server, Emily, was amazing, just the sweetest! We ordered Croque Monsieur waffle, potato latke, and sweet Dutch pancakes. It's definitely an acquired taste and I can't say I'd go back. 4 stars is for Emily and the nice couple that paid our bill.

Milktooth is a true gem, where every bite is an experience to savor. The food is absolutely mouthwatering - fresh, vibrant, and packed with flavor in every dish. While the menu is intentionally simple, it showcases a perfect balance of ingredients that lets the flavors shine through, leaving you craving more with each bite.The vibe at Milktooth is just as impressive as the food. The aesthetics are spot-on, with a laid-back yet stylish atmosphere that makes it the perfect spot for a relaxed meal. Whether you're there for a casual brunch or a special occasion, the space creates the ideal backdrop for enjoying delicious food and good company.The customer service is another highlight - friendly, attentive, and genuinely eager to make your experience as enjoyable as possible. It's clear that the team at Milktooth cares about their guests and takes pride in what they do.Overall, Milktooth offers a perfect combination of amazing food, great ambiance, and top-notch service. If you haven't been, you're missing out. Highly recommended for anyone looking for a memorable dining experience!

Milktooth was so good! This was my first stop in Indianapolis; as I'd heard many great things about this place. The rumors are true, it's worth the hype!I got the oysters to start, which were so fresh and delicious. Then I got the savory Dutch baby pancake - WOW. Unlike anything I've ever had before. I usually go sweet for brunch so I was a little nervous, but I absolutely made the right choice! Have to give credit to my server for the suggestion and for overall being so helpful and kind!The inside is super cute as well. It reminds me of an Australian coffee shop - somehow quaint and retro at the same time. Highly recommend!

We finally made it to MilkTooth & our beautiful, out of town, guest came with us to experience the magic! Pro Tip, visit on a weekday for minimal wait and more intimate setting! We visited on a Monday afternoon at about 1230 and were seated right away. To our surprise the inside dining area was mostly empty and we received plenty of attention from the serving staff. Also delighted to find a happy hour menu on our table! $25 pitcher of mimosas and $1 raw oysters... Yes, Please, and Thank you. You'll enjoy the culinary experience provided by MilkTooth if you have a taste for unique and bold flavors throughout your meal. We loved everything from the iced coffee to the raw oysters.08-19-2024

Milktooth was recommended online and by a couple locals. Showed up at 9:50 am on a Sunday and waited in a disorganized clump with a couple dozen others until the employees came out to open the doors and gently chastise the folks for not forming a proper line. Chose to sit inside as the patio tables filled up first. At this point, there were only two other groups indoors, mind you. Hostess first attempted to sit my party of two at the far end of the counter near the access to the kitchen/coffee bar, clearly one of the worst seats in the house. I requested a table instead, seeing as there were multiple two-tops still available. Felt like this annoyed the hostess, and she seated us at what I would judge as an inferior table near the highest traffic area of the restaurant. After this hiccup, the rest of the experience was positive. Our server was prompt and polite. Items were brought out as they were ready, not timed for our mains to arrive at the same time. I had the squash latke with cotija and radish, which was hearty but the latke desperately needed seasoning. There were no condiments or S&P on the table. The grits with cheddar, green onions, and bacon were delicious. Specialty iced brown butter latte was average and served inexplicably in a stemless wine glass.Decent stop for brunch, but not a place I would line up or wait more than 15 minutes for. More expensive than expected and automatic gratuity added.

This was another cool place to grab food while out of town. The ambiance was super nice, the food was delicious and the service was great!

Great coffee is the only good point. Came here for lunch in a big group....Four years later, ate here again. Service was good, not great, and not bad. Ordered the candy bacon, which is always great. Also the crock monsieur waffle was perfect.