Mickey & Bills Pizza

We love Mickey & Bills pizza it's been an institution here on the Westside Mars Hill area for decades and we hope for decades more . You want great pizza with a local story and history, spend your pizza money HERE not some chain store . Shop and dine local !!! It's our people with great food ! Thank you Mickey & Bills for all the years and terrific memories with many more ahead !

2nd Time Purchasing from this pizzeria and this time "Taco Pizza" super yummy parents loved it!!!

Fantastic pizza. Ordered a delivery and got a small Mars Hill Monster since i saw it being recommended and seemed to be a local special. When i saw the size i got a little worried but wow, it was jam packed with toppings and flavor. Absolutely great, will order again next time I'm in town

We had lunch at Mickey & Bills. My wife grew up in Mars Hill in the 50's through the 60's and has patronized for years however, the pizza we had today was very seriously OVER PRICED for what amounted to a small 8" tortilla for a crust and canned Italian flavored tomato paste, frozen hamburger warmed up and 8/10 pieces of pepperoni and a bit of mozzarella cheese. In all seriousness, there wasn'tFive $5 worth of ingredients in two pizzas, an over priced Costco bottled water and bottle of tea that was a brand I've never heard of. She was disappointed because of her memories of how good it was in the 60's did not match how bad this restaurant has fallen. The website makes it look like they have a huge dining room but there was seating for 10 persons...that's it. The staff were very nice but as far as food and price, we honestly think we were screwed over. We won't be back and wouldn't suggest Mickey & Bill's to anyone. Just no good.

Really good pizza. Not NY-style or Chicago-style or Detroit-style pizza, but just dang good pie. Very nice delivery too ;)

My favorite place in town, always Delicious pizza, they never scimp on their toppings, never greasy....

Please, please do not eat here. Breadsticks, no flavor and hard as a brick. Pizza, store bought frozen pizza crust. Rubbery cheese. Disgusting. Tasted like cardboard. We spent $60 here and regret everything. I cannot believe people are recommending this place and giving them 4 and 5 stars. Frozen pizza from the grocery would surpass this. I would rather eat a little Caesars hot and ready sitting out for 8 hours before eating this. Just don't. It all went in the trash. We cried when we opened the box and saw what had arrived. When it arrived. We had to call and see if they were ever going to arrive.

While traveling along Kentucky Avenue, I saw the sign for Mickey & Bill's Pizza, so I slowed to turn and go over the railroad tracks to get to this small shop. They have a small lot along the building and the entrance is on the northeast side. As I entered into the lobby where the order counter was, I noticed a very small dining room to my left and a few chairs to sit at if I needed to wait.I was greeted and the woman behind the counter was very patient and helpful in describing the ingredients in the uniquely named pizzas. (Note that they have flyers off to the left side of the counter which I hadn't seen when entering.) The less specific menu is listed overhead behind the counter.I hadn't called ahead, but since it wasn't a busy time, they were able to make my small pizza in about 15 minutes. I got one called "The Works" which had 8 party cut pieces and is similar to Supreme pizzas elsewhere: crumbled sausage, mushroom, green pepper, onions, pepperoni, and two kinds of cheese on a thin crust.While waiting, I noticed they also have wings and breadsticks, salads, and some sandwiches to choose from.They also have an option called "Take & Bake Pizza" that you get your pizza freshly made but finish baking it at home. And I recommend grabbing a flyer since they have a list of discounts available on larger orders.And the pizza? Well, my wife and I like a crisp bottom crust so this was very enjoyable. The ingredients were also piled high with just enough sauce and cheese to balance the flavor. The firm crust allowed the ingredients to stay on the pizza without falling off. That's a plus for me. (Not so much for my dog.) I don't know if I like pizza (any pizza) enough to drive out of my way for, but if you are commuting along Kentucky Avenue or live in the area, I suggest you will enjoy your food from here.Review #3608

Best pizza on the west side, never disappoints, always plenty of toppings, never greasy...

went for nostalgic reasons from 1980...just as good as I remember. nice thin crust, sausage and onion, cooked perfectly! I will make the trip every time I want pizza!! Hendricks