Marvin's

Absolutely delicious! They do close between lunch and dinner so make sure you get there before 2pm! The garlic cheeseburger was so good! The bread was garlicky, salty and a tiny bit sweet! I will definitely be back for another! I like how you can order a small burger or large. Very reasonably priced! They have lots of options for Fries too

Marvin's is a college dive but since my husband grew up in Greencastle it's his choice whenever we visit so he can get a GCB. I decided it had been awhile since I've had a tenderloin so I ordered one and a side of fried mushrooms. I was very upset with the tenderloin as it was super thin and extremely well done so it didn't have much flavor and was hard to eat. The mushrooms in the ranch were amazing as always though! We went on a Friday night about 830 which surprisingly it was dead. Not sure if they had a football game or not but we still had quite the wait despite the vacant ness. This isn't the first time we've eaten at Marvin's but it was definitely my least impressed visit.

I lovely little hole in the wall with the best darn garlic cheeseburger you'll find. Prices are reasonable and portions are generous. The 1/2 pound GCB is actually two burgers with two buns. Enough to share...or not.The ambiance leaves a bit to be desired. However, they are a three minute drive from DePauw Nature Park. We drive there to picnic.

The greasy spoon college kids love. Must have iron stomach or be in need of an increase in your cholesterol to eat here. Everyone raves about the GCB, or Garlic Cheeseburger for those not familiar with the lingo.. it is a wonderful thing to have for dinner if you want to ward off mosquitos and vampires. Satisfaction guaranteed!!Other big hits include the fried Mac bites and gooey cheese fries. These are not to be missed if you are a lover of orange cheese. Pizzas are also popular.Unless you know where to find Marvin's it's location can be elusive. No big marquee on the outside.. just a small plaque set in The brick exterior in the front porch. To help you find your way, follow the signs to the public library. It is right next door.Crowd here will include DePauw students; construction workers and teenagers. DePauw alumni also frequent the establishment, especially on game days, to re-live the celebrated past of their youth. Small outdoor seating on the porch is nice. Indoors large booths and tables with many televisions and memorabilia dominate the space. It can be hard to find a clean table so be prepared to clear one yourself. Ordering takes place at the counter and food brought to you. Service mimics the Dick's Last Resort type but not on purpose. Asking for anything other than the usual is treated as a bother. As an example, I asked for cheese to be on the side of my fries instead of smothered. A exasperated breath was heaved by the server. Fries were brought with cheese dripping anyway. No use in complaining, it's just the way it is at Marvin's. Take it or leave it. They do plenty of business without any accommodations. LOL

I have heard about this place for a long time from a co worker and finally I get to try it out. After a long day on the pitch I stopped in and was ready to go after the garlic cheeseburger. The menu is simple and ordering at the counter was easy. The food is a little like bar food but the simplicity of it all is what I seem to like on a HOT Saturday after a long match. The seating inside is limited so if you come make sure that you plan ahead. Marvin's is also just off campus to the north and is usually busy. If you would like to try something when in Greencastle give it a shot! I think you will be pleasantly surprised. It's inexpensive and delicious.

Mehhhh. This is not the best garlic cheeseburger around...or even in Greencastle city limits! Great selection of greasy fried food! You name it, you got it. Their pizza is actually my favorite thing on their menu. They do serve beer, that's a plus. It is an easy hangout and cool place to be for High School kids and College kids. Just not somewhere I would drive to from out of town......Or eat at sober. :-) I'll give them a nice high five for being open for so long! That is a plus! (P.S. - The best Garlic Cheeseburger, in my opinion, in the area is at Mama Nunz. Best Simple Cheeseburger, Moores.)

First time to visit Greencastle to meet some family, and we decided to try Marvin's. I did in spite of several negative reviews. I'm glad that we didn't listen. We each had sandwiches. All were hot, juicy and delicious according to everyone present. Way to go, truly enjoyed our experience.

Haiku review:You have to be drunk To stomach this crappy food.No taste, generic.Ps large fries at least

Amazing food I could eat every day there device was not the best but still very goodAmazing food I could eat every day there device was not the best but still very good

The premier culinary experience of Greencastle. The perfect place to ingest a year's dose of garlic salt.