Marsha's Specialty Desserts & Tierney's Catering

Second time trying Marsha's and definitely not disappointed! The first time I had her wonderful Strawberry Shortcake at the Avon Farmers Market! Second time was this past Friday at the Foodways Juneteenth Festival! Marsha had a variety of dessert shooters! I tried the Peach Cobbler and it was so good! The layers were perfectly balanced and the peaches had that very distinct and delicious cinnamon and nutmeg flavor! I tried not to eat it all in one sitting, but couldn't stop! Can't wait to stop by her store and try some other delicious treats!

Was referred to Masha's by my sister and her best friend. I'm always open to support small businesses so even though this location isn't close to me, I wanted to ensure I support. I emailed the information that was provided to me and received a response right away. I really had no vision for the cake I wanted to order so asked her to provide me with an idea. She did and it was an excellent suggestion. In order to reserve you must pay half down which is done electronically and you pay the other portion a couple days before pick up. When I arrived to pick up the cake you simply pull up and she brings it out to your car. Quick easy and painless. The customer service is a 10/10 and I very much recommend this place. Support small business!!!

Wow!! I was at an event for my church last night, and they served assorted small desserts from Marsha's, and I was floored! Everything was so delicious. My husband is not a sweets person and went back for seconds! We will definitely be supporting Marsha's in the future!

I first met owner Marsha a few months ago and was instantly smitten with the delicious, custom desserts she made for our event, as well as her fun and joyful personality. This is a family-run business of people who love working together and serving the community. Truly a wonderful spot to support. Love to see it! Most recently, I bought a cookie decorating kit for our Yelp's Totally Virtual Bazaar Sugar Cookie Showdown event. Marsha and her sister led all of us through a super fun class as we all decorated cookies together in our own homes. The kits were super detailed and I was SO impressed that their team truly thought of EVERYTHING. From a little heart sprinkle for the top of the tree cookie to little orange sprinkles for the snowman cookies' nose and more, there was nothing missed. You can buy much more than desserts here. Order anything from platters of bbq and wings, sides of mac & cheese, individual breakfast sandwiches, boxed lunches, finger sandwiches, cupcakes, custom cakes and more. They can fully cater any event, from appetizer to entree to dessert. Order on their website online ordering portal or give them a call!

I first had the pleasure of being introduced to this business at the Yelp Sweet 16th Birthday. They made cookies, cake pops, cupcakes and other sweet treats. They were wonderful! Marsha was such a ray of sunshine and happy to tell everyone about her business.Forward to December 2020. I ordered one of their Christmas cookie kits. It came in a nice metal tin with a lid, an assortment of sugar cookies, piping bags full of icing with some that even had different tips on them to add different textures! They were full and didn't skimp on the icing. That was a plus! They included all of the cute little touches you could add to your cookies, little carrots for Frosty's nose, shimmery sprinkles, mini M&M's for the Christmas lights cookies to name a few of the little small touches that add so much to the cookies. They even included a little spreader to spread out your icing making it easier to use than a standard knife. This is a family owned business and they love what they do! You can tell in their products and they're so nice and friendly! Not only do they sell baked goods they also cater! Go to their Instagram page and look at the spread they created for 375 airport employees who wanted a "Colts Tailgate!" It looks incredible! They can do it all! They're located not far from Indianapolis in Avon almost to the Marion - Hendricks county line. They have a store front full of their beautiful cakes they've created. Support small!

I stopped by to pick up a cookie decorating kit that I had purchased online and didn't even need to call to say I had arrived! Marsha came out to find out what I was picking up and was back with my kit so quickly! The cookie decorating kit was wonderful. The cookies were so delicious and the frosting in pre-filled decorating bags and other decorations in labelled ziplocks made it so easy for a cookie decorating novice! Marsha has baked cakes for work events for years now, and it's always worth sticking it out through a long work event when we know a slice of Marsha's cake will be our reward the end. We're often had a strawberry sheet cake which is delicious! We've also had trays of cake pops and mini cupcakes which are delicious as well. The cake pops have impressed many over the years! We've also had cheese trays and veggie trays which are excellent too! This is a great family owned and run business! Please support them particularly during these challenging times!

I participated in a Yelp event recently that involved making cookies. Marsha's was supplying the cookie kits and the expertise. I got online and placed my cookie kit order so I could pick it up a few days later. I pulled up to pick up my kit and Marsha came out to my vehicle with her mask on and a safe distance from my window to get my name for my order. She went back in and promptly came back out with my order! My kit had everything I needed and then some. I can honestly say the sugar cookies may be the best I have eaten. So soft and delicious. Give Marsha's a try. Easy to order and easy to pick up.

The best businesses have good products and good people. Marsha's has just that. I met both Marsha andMichelle through a virtual Yelp event. I was filled with joy listening to them talk about their family business. Their passion and love truly shine through their work. Plus the sugar cookie decorating kit was so well put together and tasted delicious! If I lived in Indy, I'd trust them with all of my baking needs.

I bought a sugar cookie decorating kit in order to attend a Yelp zoom event . Making the purchase to attend the event was not required, but I'm very glad I did! For only $20, we got 10 large sugar cookies, piped bags of colored icing, three decorator tips, and multiple candy sprinkles/decor, all clearly labeled. I had such a fun time in this whole event. This was one of the best Yelp Zooms (and I 've been on some great ones!) I was delighted to see the kit and all the care that was clearly taken in putting them together, which set the tone for the entire experience. Clearly Chef Marsha thoroughly well thought this out, knowing which cookie we would start with and now to decorate them and perfectly timed how we would spend our hour together. Not only was this fun, but super tasty! The shop is in Avon, and it's pretty good I live a-ways away, or I would be stopping by all too often to test all her other items! Also, just in one hour, the way she decorates cookies, I would love to see her cakes; simply gorgeous!#ReviewsByRL

I bought a cookie decorating kit from Marsha's Specialty Desserts for a Yelp virtual event. This is one of those times when I am glad that I make the effort to do these kinds of things, because I get to be introduced to amazing places like Marsha's and the hard-working, talented people who are behind them. So, thanks to Yelp for setting the stage, and thanks to Marsha's for existing so I could have an excuse to decorate and eat delicious cookies.I ordered my goodies online from their website, and then I pulled up to their shop on my designated day and time. Marsha's is tucked around the corner from a liquor store, and you might not be able to see the shop from the street, so just enter the parking lot where the liquor store is and you'll find it off to the right.Due to the ongoing pandemic, I don't believe they are allowing many people inside the store, but I didn't even have to think about that: Someone (Marsha, perhaps?) saw me arrive and came out to my car, masked and friendly, ready to help me. She asked me my name and got my cookie kit and brought it to my car. So easy!Let's just fast-forward to me eating the cookies, OK? Because that's the important part. The cookies are delicious! They are dy-no-mite. Marsha's makes the type of soft, pliable sugar cookies that you actually want to EAT, not just decorate and take a picture of for Instagram. (Although, these cookies also make for Insta-worthy photos, too.) Even the next day, the cookies were still scrumptious. Yum. Now I want sugar cookies ...I will have to order some more sweet treats from Marsha's soon, because I'd like to taste some of their other offerings!