Manhattan Pizzeria

My brother in law loves this place! I thought it was pretty good - we ordered a LOT of pizza and all of it was pretty simple, not too sophisticated, but fine for a group dinner.

The pizza is delicious! The service is super fast and friendly. I love the bench seating. I really just love this place. The crust is amazing

Yum yum yum yum . This NYC girl has missed pizza . When really good pizza is available on almost every corner you don't realize how much it's become a part of your life . Late getting home ?grab a slice for dinner . Quick lunch ?grab a slice . Want to sit after a day of shopping ? grab a slice. Well this is the slice . It's as close to NYC pizza as you're going to find AND you can get a slice . A slice not a whole pie and not little squares. A slice . For most women and I assume some men a slice is all you want and that leaves most pizza here in Indiana off the "grab a bite " menu since you have to get a whole pie . If you find yourself anywhere near this place you should go in take a seat and grab a slice trust me it's great . They have wings and bread sticks etc but who cares they have real PIZZA!

One of my FAV Pizza spots! Whenever I am in the area I stop and grab it because it's on the other side of town. It's a small place but there's still a nice dinning room. They are always quick and actually satisfies my appetite!

Very good pizza. Was it the best pizza I've ever had? No but really good. Friendly service on the phone when I placed my order. I was told about 20 min. Took me about 20 min from my house and pizza was ready. They have signs up to "please wear a mask" as a private business they have the right to enforce it. So just wear the damn thing. They were offering eat in dining. I took mine home. Friendly service inside and the place looked very clean. They have one picnic table out front. Pizza had plenty of toppings and sauce and a good amount of cheese. I think I would have liked it baked just a tad longer to crisp the bottom crust. It was foldable like NY pizza should be. The edge crust was chewy and went great with the nacho cheese I already had at home. They have one size pizza. It's a good 20inches. Two pieces each were enough for us, so leftovers for midnight snack.

Manhattan Pizzeria lives up to its name - you get a great slice of NY style pie. The prices are fair, the atmosphere is casual and comfortable. They always have a fresh selection of by-the-slice flavors ready to throw in the hot oven for that perfect crispy-but-chewy crust you can only get from re-heating in a proper pizza oven.Garlic knots are great. Desserts are good too. This place is a perfect workday lunch spot with 2 or 3 coworkers.

Pizza is far above average. Not the best I've ever had, but better than chain pizza. Workers are friendly and they have a great lunch special, 2 slices and a drink for 8 bucks. Awesome little spot that doesn't get enough attention.

nice small business atmosphere. pizza made fresh daily. lots of different options and flavors. they have a nice lunch special, 2 slices and a bevies for like $6 or something. pleasant customer service. definitely worth trying!

So naturally, every few weeks it seems I get a new craving for pizza and instead of going to the same places I try to switch it up every now and then so when I found Manhattan I decided to give it a shot! They don't seem to be doing any in person dining but i was able to do carry out. We got wings, garlic knots, and the grandma pie. Garlic knots: these were probs my favorite thing. This dipped in the cheese sauce was hella good. Really nice flavor to it without it being overwhelming. Def recommend!Wings: so I love my wings with ranch. Unfortunately I forgot to get some so having the wings just like that, they tasted solid, but they had a stronger vinegar flavor than I'd prefer. I think if I had ranch I would've enjoyed them a little bit more. Pie: so this is my own fault. I assumed the pie would be just a whole pizza, but to me it was more like a focaccia bread which was still good! It's just not what I was expecting so I definitely want to go back and try the actual pizza. I'm going 4 stars because part of the reason I wasn't the happiest with the meal was mainly my own faults and everything was still good. I enjoyed the meal overall it was just very different from what i was expecting. Overall it was a solid experience and I do want to try it again some point down the line!

Pizza was great and only took 10 minutes to make a large pepperoni. Staff was also great and helpful as far as different varieties