Libby's Ice Cream

Yummy! We very much enjoy coming here. Parking is a little limited. There are plenty of places neat by to sit and enjoy this delicious ice cream. They have different flavors all the time. My favorite is the Blue Moon and Blackberry cheesecake. The ice cream is so creamy. The variety is so large, you're bound to find something for even the pickiest person.

Libbeys ice cream is awesome! They have an area of the store that's ice cream and coffee and then opposite is an area with gifts. The gift section has all local items which is a nice touch (candles, coffee beans, soaps, etc.). The ice cream is also great! You can to go pints which is especially nice for having people over. There's always numerous flavors to choose from and the service is always exceptional.Parking here is like anywhere in downtown fortville. If you're fortunate enough, you'll get a spot right out front, but you might have to drive around the block to find one.

Passing through the town of Greensburg for the first time I wanted to take a moment from my trip and stop and get some ice cream. I stumbled upon Libby's and decided to give it a chance instead of stopping at a largely commercialized store like DQ. Sadly I was unable to sample any of the flavors they had highlighted on their menu which in turn lead to me asking for recommendations. To which the tone of the conversation was very rushed, and that I was unworthy of their time... The ice cream was very good, however the customer service was subpar. I felt as if I was in the way of something more important at hand and an inconvenience to say the least.

We love Libby's! The flavors change every few days and we haven't had anything yet we haven't liked. I've tried a few of the themed shakes the employees think up and they have all been super fun & delicious!!! I added pictures of the Stranger Things, Unicorn and Hippie Fest 2022 inspired shakes and they are not only beautiful but have all tasted simply amazing!!! The employees are all super sweet and they really seem to enjoy making our town happy! Thank goodness it's swim season or we would be packing on the pounds My goddaughter got to pick dinner the other night after a day of swimming so we actually had Libby's for dinner She is 15 and I can't lie, it was super fun doing Libby's for dinner Such a fun addition to our town, especially with the new park The Depot!!!!!! Thanks for the memories Libby's!!! I'm embarrassed to say we have been 5 times this week but hey when you want to impress family from out of town, Libby's is a must!!!

My family and I love this place. The ice cream is always great and the people are awesome! Best place to go get a milkshake on a hot day.

Yummy even with the frigid temps outside! Cute place and they have gluten free options!

Very nice and different selection of ice cream. Pineapple upside down cake, Twinkie , almond joy were some of the flavors.

Let me start by saying, Libby's serves Sundae's Homemade Ice Cream. They're located at 79th and Fall Creek in Indianapolis. So, naturally, Libby's is serving the best ice cream in the state!! Good choice on their part! I absolutely LOVE Sundae's ice cream. Libby's does a lot of things with it! Their sundae's are elaborate and overflowing with whipped cream and a cherry on top, their shakes are creative and look delicious, they have a lot of fun with it! I haven't had a bad experience at their Greenfield location. The girls who work there are friendly and they get your order out quickly. The only negative thing I have to say about Libby's is that they don't give credit where credit is due! They should have a sign up that says "WE PROUDLY SERVE SUNDAES HOMEMADE ICE CREAM". But instead loads of people think it's Libby's original ice cream... which makes me sad for Sundae's. The owners of Sundae's are wonderful people and I wouldn't doubt it if they didn't even want the credit, just because they're so nice. But I want it for them! Anyways, Libby's is great! Go try it and think of Sundae's ice cream for me.

Libby's is a great place to get deserts. When we are out we usually go get a sweet treat from Libby's. The design and the way it works is really nice, with the graffiti style on the counters, walls, and trash cans. It's a walk-up place, so you just walk up to the counter and order what you want and they give it to you. They also have great service, even though they don't have a lot of workers. One time when we were out we decided to get Libby's, there was a church event happening where the church went to local businesses and they all bought something. This day, the church brought around 15-20 people, and we were at the end of the line. We were only waiting for around 10 minutes for them to get the church served. They then quickly made our smoothies and got us served as well. My whole family's favorite item from Libby's is their smoothies. They're sweet, and have good flavors. My personal favorite is the Strawberry Banana Smoothie. It doesn't taste like anything bad is in it even though I don't personally know the ingredients, it isn't too sweet, but not too dull either. They also give you the option of having whipped cream on your smoothie. Their ice cream is also really good. I've only ever had a small cup of chocolate ice cream from Libby's but it was worth it. Libby's also offers treats for your furry friends. They have a "Pup Cup" that is dog friendly and a good treat for them. Overall Libby's is wonderful all around, with the service, style, and best of all their great treats.-JH