Juicy Seafood Indy - Castleton

Babe and I decided to have date night at this location and I have no complaints! We walked in and got sat right away, our server John was very helpful explaining the menu and how it worked with ordering. He was also very attentive and a great server! We ordered strawberry margaritas which were so delicious! We then proceeded to order 2 of The Red Bomb which was also delicious!!! We do not get to get out a lot since we have a newborn, But I am so glad we chose to eat here at this location because it was delicious and was worth every penny! We are going back this Saturday Nov.2 for my birthday dinner!

My wife has been craving seafood, so today we went to Juicy Seafood Indy Castleton-5899 E 86th St and it was absolutely delicious. Our waitress was a whole vibe, her personality was outstanding and we really enjoyed ourselves with her. It was like we have known her for years, the customer service that she gave us was definitely top notch. Ayenna is a great asset to the business and we will definitely be back to request her again. Thank you for being so kind and helpful. I highly recommend Juicy Seafood for if you are looking for some delicious seafood and good vibes. Tell them that Breezie sent you‼#goodreviews #goodreviewsmatter #ourlovestory #seafood #seafoodboil

3 stars. Customer service was really great here. I wish the seafood could've matched the service. I found my boil to be under seasoned. I ordered it mild Cajun and lemon pepper. It tasted like I ordered it plain.The value on the clam strips is just there. $9 is simply overpriced for what I received. And they didn't come with fries - I had to order those separately. But they were delish!We were given a complementary cheesecake since we were celebrating a birthday. And a nice sign to make it a worthy photo opp. Plus, we got a gift card for our next visit. Kudos! I'm not sure if that's something they always do or if you have to signup online. Nice touch, either way.My cocktail was tasty, but light on the alcohol. It was one of the monthly specials. Can't remember the name. Overall a decent spot, but I'm not sure I'll be a frequent diner.

This was my first time here! The hush puppies were so good! And I loved the snow crab legs! They really prepare for you to make a mess here. I was confused with the bib at first but then I had so much flavorful juicy dripping down my chest that I needed it! I got to choose the flavor and spicy level of what my crab legs were tossed in. My waitress reccommended garlic with lemon so I got that and got "hot" spicy which wasn't too bad, I could have done very hot honestly! Definitely will be back!

We just dined with a party of 10 celebrating 2 birthdays. Ayenna was so so so amazing!! She took her time with our table and made everyone feel special!! She seriously is an amazing server!

Atmosphere on point. All employees were exceptionally awesome. Food was stellar to say the least. Highly recommended.

Excellent seafood establishment! The food taste fresh and flavorful! The sides (potatoes, corn, eggs,) are fresh also and taste very good. This is a nice place to come alone, a date, or as a family. I have ordered this through food delivery apps, but it tastes best when you eat it fresh out of the kitchen, but it still tastes good delivered. The service was good and I will definitely return to eat here again.

We had Taylor as our server. She was wonderful. Food was awesome. What a great night.

We came in one evening for dinner. The atmosphere is rustic with dark wood tones and loud RnB music.We were greeted promptly and sat, we waited for a while before our waitress come over to greet up and take our drink order. While she was speaking to us she was looking around the room making it hard to hear her over the loud music.We ordered a cup of the New England clam chowder for a starter and a combination seafood boil with the juicy special (all of their sauce flavors).We waited for quite a bit and a man headed to our table with a steaming hot metal tray of seafood, our waitress called over to him that we had ordered the chowder for a starter. He turned around and a few minutes later we had our chowder. It was served steaming hot and tasty.Unfortunately, after we finished our chowder, they brought out the same seafood that they had tried to serve us before just no longer hot.The pan of seafood arrived and it contained mussels, petite crab legs, shrimp, lobster tail, corn, and potatoes. There was at least an inch or more deep of a butter liquid in the bottom of the pan which made everything quite messy.The overall flavor was good, but the quality and the size of the seafood made it just okay. The best part of the boil were the potatoes and the corn if which there were only a few pieces.It's a good start, maybe just an off night. I would have preferred our dinner served steaming hot, with no liquid in the bottom of the tray.

Got the black and red for two added crawfish. Wanted to try the calamari, however never received my order of it. It was ok still hungry for the price. Service wasn't the best. Food was lukewarm. Had to really work it in the sauce they poured over it instead of cooking it in the sauces.