Overloaded baked potato with brisket
Big Nasty
Bloody Mary
Twisted lemonade
Margarita
Consistently perfect brisket
Turtle cheesecake
Blu Wedge Salad
Sweet or Spicy BBQ Bottle
Blue and Buffalo Wrap
Expect this if you order The Jeff Plate for $20.
Overloaded baked potato with pulled pork
churro donut cheesecake
Menu
Mac wrap with chips
December special: loaded potato soup
Mac wrap
Mississinewa. 4 meats & 4 sides
Interior of Jefferson Street BBQ
Strawberry Margarita
interior
interior
Jeff M.
Sep 13, 2024
Good Food & good service !!Had a problem with my bill ( credit cards fault) and owner called me back right away the next day and issue was confirmed it was credit card issue. Problem solved.Would recommend eating here.
Read More
Stacy A.
Jan 25, 2025
Always an excellent experience at Jefferson Street BBQ. Service was helpful, prompt, and friendly. Relaxing family friendly vibe. Had the amazing nachos - mini pulled pork (with Broadripple Chips) sweet. The pic is of our finale - churro donut cheesecake! Wow!
Read More
J J.
Aug 11, 2024
Yes, it's safe to say I'm addicted and will be asking friends and family for gift cards, lol. I've been here now several times and will give the pitmaster his kuddos because the consistency of the food is on point every time. Speaking of consistency, every visit I've had the pleasure of being taken care of by Dezaree. Who is a star. Even though the location is a little off the grid for me, it's worth the scavenger hunt.
Read More
Brittany R.
Dec 12, 2022
I have absolutely nothing bad to say about this place!! The restaurant is so cute and the vibes are great. The service is always astounding and the food is more than worth the trip! The prices are really good for the portion sizes you get. If you don't know what to get, you could really just close your eyes and point at the menu - there's not a wrong choice here! I recommend the Mac wrap - it's large enough and you can definitely share it if you want.
Read More
Erin D.
May 23, 2024
Average bbq, friendly service. Good selection of bbq sauces. Cute spot in a small town.
Read More
Scott S.
May 11, 2024
Excellent place, little drive from Anderson but worth the drive. Turkey was moist and brisket was good. Baked beans were spot on. I liked the slaw, my wife said it had a little kick that she didn't care for. Cornbread was again spot on.
Read More
Tim E.
Jan 19, 2024
Dropped in for lunch and try new menu. Was not disappointed still great offerings. Street tacos were a home run. The smoke turkey is righteous and I have smoked my share of turkeys. Jefferson Street does it right.
Read More
Megan T.
Dec 15, 2020
We came here to eat on a Saturday afternoon for a work event. We called ahead and made reservations. I think calling ahead of time helped out a lot because our server was only helping our tables. The service was TOP NOTCH! Again, I say that because I think it helped that we told them how many people would be coming so they were able to staff appropriately for the day. My husband and I split the Mississinewa which comes with 4 meats and 4 sides. We chose the brisket, wings, pulled pork, ribs, double the mac n' cheese, baked beans, and the jalapeno cornbread. My favorite out of the meal was definitely the baked beans and the wings! Wow they were so good! My only complaint with the meal was the mac n' cheese. It was VERY watery (almost like a soup).If I was in the area again, I would come back but would order something different next time. They had a great menu with lots of variety!
Read More
Tonya P.
Aug 20, 2023
Food is delicious! Fast friendly service. Indoor decor is so cool. They host several different events that really look fun!
Read More
Elizabeth K.
Aug 17, 2024
We tried to give them a chance--multiple times. The changes made in 2023 would make you think there is a new owner or something. The identity that was once great, affordable food in the local neighborhood has come and gone.We used to love going to Jefferson, but now the prices have gone up, the quality of food has gone down, the customer service is inadequate, and the menu has been obsolete. I ordered a Jeff Plate, formerly The Jefferson Plate. It was $6 more than what it was a year ago. I received the portion that did not measure up to what I was led to believe I'd receive. After asking if the plate was truly what I should expect from this new plate (photo below), I was told yes--it measures out; how one single rib measures out is beyond me. We will NOT be returning.
Read More