Harry And Izzy's

Full transparency, we went here for the Christmas pop up bar, which is only Thursday-Sunday, and we went on Monday. So we missed that but decided to stay for some drinks and light food. We decided on the signature St Elmos spicy shrimp cocktail and meatballs for appetizers. The meatballs were delicious and a good big portions for only three meatballs. The shrimp cocktail was SPICY and I do not mean regular spicy they were spicy spicy! I had to spit my first one out because I wasn't prepared. When I got past that, they were good. You also get some DELICIOUS bread served as an appetizer. For our "main" portion we decided on broccolini and steakhouse Mac and cheese, both were delicious and a good amount food as well. My cocktails were a signature vanilla cherry mule and a signature manhattan.The mule was delicious but the manhattan tasted like a lot of bitters, so that wasn't my preference. Kevin had pours of Knobs Creek 9yr and Elijah Craig single barrel. Both were good. If you like on the rocks, ask for the sphere!

I was looking forward to enjoying my birthday here recently. My family and I gathered for the discounted three-course weekend menu. I made my reservation, confirmed that the menu still existed, then also sent screenshots to the family of what menu would also be available to choose from directly from this location's website. We were seated promptly but not waited on promptly. While our waitress was kind, our entire night was extremely slow (3.5 hour dinner - yikes - I would have never gone here had I known this). Just getting ice water took over 30 minutes. I asked for the menu I confirmed existed when I previously called in and was told it no longer existed but she would ask the manager since she was told it was my birthday. One manager said no, she asked another, they said yes (which took another 30 minutes). We placed our orders and very nicely said not to rush her or anyone but we had plans to get to after and needed to be out in 90 minutes. She said that was no problem, we'd be out well before then. After ordering, a middle aged women came out and said she was a manager. She accused me of being a liar regarding the menu. I told her when I called and also showed her the website. She accused me of not pulling up the real website then took my cell phone to try to see where I was lying. She made me go step by step over where I found this and kept making nasty comments about me trying to work one over on the restaurant, manipulating the web address (what?!). This encounter lasted about 5 minutes or so and I was absolutely mortified in front of my family. She just stood over me at this table and went on and on and on. It was disgusting. Our food took forever. Honestly everything did. Our nice, older waitress was probably doing her best, she said she was exhausted, and clearly needed help/to not be spread thin. We got our salads but it took another hour for our dinner entrees, which we had to track our waitress down to check on. The manager brought everything out and was still in a very bad mood because we were treated like we should not be there. We ate what we could but the food was so, SO bad. For example, steaks were either raw or well done when we ordered medium rare. Despite trying to eat quickly, we still couldn't get out when we needed to for our next plans. Again we didn't want to rush anyone but never expected to be there more than 2.5 hours with a reservation on an afternoon! Our waitress never checked on our food, never refilled our drinks during entrees, and after asking for our check, she took another 30 minutes to bring it. Upon returning, we were made aware that I should not expect anything free for my birthday (I didn't ask for, expect, or even want anything but yes, you do give free dessert, which is why we heard the table nearby get a birthday dessert and I've been here for birthdays before - always a free dessert). I will never come here again and honestly, this "establishment" should be ashamed for how incredibly downhill they have gone. Clearly I'm not alone in this thinking - check the Indy Foodies FB page - there's been garbage food lately so save your money and go literally anywhere else!

This place did not disappoint. The service, the food, the ambiance all were amazing! They did a great job making my daughter's birthday special. Inside the space is open with lots of seating at the main level, upstairs, and at the bar. All of our steaks were cooked perfectly, the brussel sprouts with caramelized onions were so good. They also gave my daughter a complimentary cheesecake for her birthday. I would recommend this place over and over for special occasions or a wonderful dining experience.

I love this location. Definitely has a different type of crowd and even more relaxed atmosphere. a good stuff Crown & Coke by the bartender. and of course my Filet sliders were . I want to come back on and even more crowded night.

First thing I'll say is this place is not cheap, but kinda worth it. This was another recommendation from a coworker I was visiting in Indianapolis. He said we had to try the shrimp cocktail. Apparently everyone else heard the same recommendation because almost every table had it. There is nothing special about the shrimp, but the cocktail part if super good. You'll swear it is 4 parts wasabi to one part cocktail sauce. It's very very good. Definitely try it. I don't remember the name, but I got the steak covered in Pepper. When you see it, it looks like too much pepper, but honest it isn't. The flavor was superb. I sat at the bar and our bartender / waitress was Jenn. She was awesome. Funny, smart, witty, helpful, attentive. I was impressed with her honesty about the menu as well as her knowledge of the menus ( food and drink ). I will say I felt underdressed in my jeans and T-shirt. This place was a level or two classier than I am use to. :)

I wasn't in the mood to cook and we had a gift card to use up. The food and service were really great. Salads were huge. Toasted ravioli portion was a bit small, 3 ravioli. Salmon was cooked well on my salad. Our server did an excellent job keeping tea filled. We even ran into a wonderful server that worked for another company years ago. She was always great. Only complaint or criticism would be the lights just inside hanging above the entry were covered in spider webs and a spider living his best life. Someone may want to take a swiffer duster to those and and relocate him outside. I know when you work in a building you don't notice things other people will like burnt out bulbs and spider webs. But small things can make you wonder what other things go unnoticed.

I had to get my fix... the shrimp cocktail! Other high-end steakhouses across the country claim to have "atomic" cocktail sauce, and they are posers serving bland ketchup. Harry & Izzy's and St. Elmo's is the real deal.Excellent service from the bar team of Zach and Caitlyn. Although happy hour is brief, I was able to catch the tail end with a Manhattan.I opted for the meatloaf this eve. It was good with mashed and green beans, but heavy heavy on the salt. I ended up slamming water thru the night. (You could scale back the sodium and still have worthy flavor).See you one more time for another shrimp cocktail before I bail my former home turf of Indy.

Come for the shrimp cocktail and then dream about it until your next visit! Love this location especially since it's on the north side of Indy. I recently visited their Christmas pop up bar and it was super cute! A fun time with family with great drinks and delicious food.

Came here with some friends for the Miracle on 82nd Street Pop-Up and it was so cute! So many cute Christmas decorations and I appreciated that there was plenty of seating. This pop-up is actually outside and at the back of the restaurant but they did have heaters which was nice! Our waitress was very kind and patient as we looked over the drink menu and we also received some complimentary nuts while waiting! I ordered the Evergreen Gin and Tonic and it was perfectly balanced and very good! Overall, fun and cute experience outside of the restaurant!

spectacular from walking in the doors being greeted immediately. i had a reservation and they allowed me to be seated early while i awaited my date. service was phenomenal and it was busy but it still felt intimate. highly recommend and i will be back!