Worst salad I ever had .. never again
Italian Sub
Adult bevs
Outside
Menu (11/24)
Menu (12/24)
menu
the dining area
the menu
Menu 3/2022
Dining Room
the menu
Pizza box
Tony's Deluxe Pizza. So good.
Italian sub
Addictive breadsticks!
7-Cheese Pizza
Meat lovers barley anting toppings on this thick crust
Meat lovers
Breadsticks
Gyro platter!
Menu 3/2022
Cheese pizza
Garden Veggie Pizza - Thin & Crispy
Katherine A.
Nov 3, 2024
I love this old school, family-run pizza shop close to downtown Carmel. And the hype about the breadsticks is real - the sticks are hot, chewy and addictive!The restaurant is not trendy or upscale with plastic tablecloths, but the family vibes are fun. When we ordered at the front counter, we could hear the cooks in the back bantering and laughing. They serve pizzas, subs and salads. Prices are very reasonable and make feeding a large family easy. They have a decent selection of craft beers, including Sunking. The wine selection is a bit sad (only Barefoot). We met for a family celebration on Saturday. We ordered assorted pizzas, subs and breadsticks to share. The food comes out as it is ready and hot. Tony's Deluxe pizza is delicious. The crust is chewy, one of the better crusts around town. Toppings were generous and flavorful. The Italian Sub is really good with perfectly proportioned bread to filling ratio. I ate half for breakfast the next day. The kids had the 7-Cheese Blend. I didn't try it but the kids seemed to really enjoy it. If you looking for something upscale, this probably isn't you spot. If you're looking for a great old school pizza or sandwich, I highly recommend checking out this family owned biz.
Read MoreJim B.
Nov 16, 2024
Ordered 3 pizzas and all 3 had burnt crust. The crust was hard and inedible. The "deep dish" was just thick crust with minimal toppings and sauce. Extra sauce and topping is what makes a DEEP DISH. A thicker crust is not a deep dish pizza. Very disappointing!!
Read MoreClinton C.
Nov 10, 2024
Ordered take out the other night to share with family and I wasn't disappointed! This time I got the original pizza dough and it was really good! Toppings were a little sparse but I can't complain because that just depends on who is making the pies that night! Also got a large Antipasto salad and it's was made fresh and delicious with their house dressing! Along with everything I ordered I got the famous " too much butter" reviewed breadsticks that stole the show! I could live on those breadsticks and salad alone next time! Really good food and as always amazingly great service!
Read MoreKate S.
Feb 2, 2025
The restaurant definitely has an old-school vibe. I had a great salad and breadsticks.
Read MoreMikaela L.
Nov 7, 2024
This was my first time ordering from this restaurant. I had the Greek salad, breadsticks, and buffalo chicken pizza, and everything was delicious. The food was delivered warm and fresh. I highly recommend it if you're in the Carmel area. The service was excellent and didn't disappoint us.
Read MoreEileen M.
Jan 17, 2025
Terrible service. They yelled at me for making a complaint brought some burley girl over to then attack me again over pizza they burnt and brought to me cold. Avoid at all cost or it will cost you your mind because they'll come at you hard & belittle you for complaining about their horrible food. The inside of their restaurant is nothing to go home and write about. The whole experience was awful. Then told me I'm now on their list to never deliver to us again.
Read MoreCoco C.
May 24, 2024
I called in my prefer then went to pick it up and no one told me how long the wait was or anything . People walking in ordering sitting down getting food before my 37.00 pizza and salad. The pizza was dry with barely any toppings and the salad was supposed to be a large but it definitely wasn't worth the 12.50 I was charged . Safe to say I will continue passing this place up .. definitely better experiences in CarmelFor the money I wasted
Read MoreBecky R.
Jan 3, 2025
First visit to Greek Tony's. The pizza was fantastic!! I hope to make it back before the majestic city of Carmel wipes out that corner to make room for more overpriced apartments.
Read MoreNiki B.
Jun 22, 2023
I've driven past this pizza shop hundreds of times and finally stopped in over the weekend. I've seen multiple Yelp Elites say that they have some of the best breadsticks in town, so how can you not stop in once you know that?! The restaurant is located in an old strip mall that has somehow escaped Carmel's construction and updating... I'm sure it'll happen soon. Regardless, it's a divey pizza spot where lots of local sports teams always meet up. It's casual, affordable, and they have tables that you can move together. This time though, we called ahead to place a takeout order. We got a medium pizza, half with cheese and half with black olives and red pepper. And you already know we got an order of breadsticks! They come with a side of cheese and we paid for a side of marinara too. We thought their menu was cool, with interesting pizza combos, such as the meatball, Mexican, or Greek pizzas. It also sounds like they have a great Greek salad. Everything was good and the breadsticks are delicious, thanks to the garlic butter pooling off of them. The pizza had a good flavor and my husband said it was one of his favorites he's had recently. I'm usually more of a thin crust, "healthy" pizza kind of gal, but I enjoyed it and liked the divey vibes.
Read MoreKaryn S.
Feb 18, 2024
Super casual place with GREAT gyros! My husband I I shared a gyro platter because it came with a Greek salad. That salad dressing was the best I've had in a long time. The salad was full of greens, green pepper , onion and soft feta cheese. It wasn't huge salad but just enough to share. They have the best tzatziki sauce in town. This is the ONLY place wll go when we get a craving for gyros!!
Read More