Gordon’s Milkshake Bar

One of the best milkshakes I've ever had. While in town, I had to stop by for one of their handspun, beautifully crafted milkshakes topped with delicious sweet treats. I got the butter cream cake shake and it didnt disappoint. To top it off, the service was impeccable, quick and attentive and the shop was colorful with quirky decor. If you're in the area, stop in and treat yourself!

This place is awful!Milkshakes have no flavor, it's literally milk with toppings, like are you even using ice cream?And the staff is so unfriendly, barely uttered a word to us.Don't waste your money.

Not sure if this place is still open. Went by on a Saturday around 3 and they were closed. We've had problems the last few times we've swing by (over months) where they either weren't open, the milkshake machines were all down, or they didn't have their vegan product available. Too bad since we used to love their milkshakes and would go out of our way to visit.

I have loved Gordon's since they opened! Whenever I'm having dinner in the area, I will stop in and grab dessert at Gordon's. I'm kind of sad that they took away the brownies and beignets, but I love a good milkshake so I can't complain too much! The service can be a bit slow, but I think it's worth the wait. My favorite milkshake of all time is the buttery whipple. It's a seasonal drink that only comes around for the Butter Art Fair season, but I think about it all year around!

I personally was very underwhelmed by my peanut butter milkshake because there was no peanut butter taste. My partner got the vegan cookies and cream milkshake, and he enjoyed it, but even with trying his, there was not much of a cookie taste. I think he just enjoyed it because, most vegan options are pretty bland.I really wanted to like this place because it is black owned, but the service was very subpar, we were barely greeted upon walking in, and even when asking questions, the worker was not helpful in answering questions. For the price of these milkshakes, I'm not sure I will be returning for another try or not because they are on the more expensive side It is a nice location since it is directly on mass Avenue and near a lot of other places like the garage, but if you do go, you will have to pay for street parking in order to visit

This has been my favorite milkshake place in Indy since 2020. If you are visiting indy or have always lived here, you MUST try this place. The milkshakes are absolutely amazing and being someone who can't have dairy they can make almost any shake dairy free or vegan. Don't sleep on the other desserts they have available like the beignets, they are good too!The milkshakes/desserts are made to order, so depending on the time of the year, the wait can be long, but it's definitely WORTH it! I have not seen this place available for pickup or doordash, so you have to go there to order it. They have cute lighting and a few seats inside, so you can either take it to go or enjoy it inside!

I've walked by this spot so many times over the past year and finally decided to stop in now that it's summer.I really wanted to like this place, but it just didn't do it for me. The milkshake tasted very artificial and was way too sweet (and this is coming from someone who has a BIG sweet tooth). I ordered the red velvet love and the cake blended into the milkshake tasted old/stale. I tried to power through given that the specialty shakes are $13, but I couldn't even finish the whole thing because it made my stomach hurt.It's a shame because the shakes look so delicious but the taste just isn't right. I wonder if I just ordered the wrong thing or came in on an off day.Service was okay. The man working the register was nice but the other two workers making the shakes were not as friendly.

I was walking with a friend on a very hot day along Mass Ave and was craving something cold. Stumbled upon this place during my walk and SO GLAD that I did! I quickly walked in and was happy to see how spacious it actually was compared to the outside! Plenty of seating which I always appreciate. The cashier behind the counter was very patient with me as I looked over the menu. I quickly ordered a chocolate milkshake and sat down. When I received it, the milkshake was very creamy and rich. Overall good experience and I will be back to try the ice-cream cause they have that too!

What is this?! If I could give no stars I would. I'm visiting from out of town and this place was highly recommended. Why? Not sure. I always want to support Black Owned businesses so I was happy to visit. However, from the moment my friends and I stepped in, it was a lackluster experience. The employees and manager were not knowledgeable and they claim to have vegan and dairy free options but they only have vanilla soft serve that comes out of a pouch and the manager brought it out of the back to show us the powdered mix. The employees also mentioned that they buy the other ice cream from a store?? against our judgement we ordered and it was not good, and the brownie sundae we got was covered in lukewarm hot fudge and served over a hard thick brownie..to top it off, they served it in a foil pan. The dairy free ice cream had no flavor. This place is awful. Highly DO not recommend.

We hang out on Mass Ave, but haven't tried here before. I have to give them credit for some pretty epic milkshakes. That said, the space was cramped and unkempt. And the shakes were running over the sides and not quite up to my standards presentation wise for a $13 shake. There were also a lot of gnats. The staff were friendly, and I think with a little care, this place could be a nice treat.