Goodfellas Pizzeria - Mass Ave

Nice spot for a quick meal after an event at the Athenaeum. Within walking distance from the venue. A little high in cost, but well worth the taste. Short wait time, great customer service at the order counter.

This is a 2 for 1 if you can handle it! There is pizza on one side and cocktails on the other. You enter a really nice area, greeted with black and white tile floors. There are a bunch of tables and a table with stools that face the window you can look out of after you eat. You are immediately greeted at the door and you can see a few pizza options in the pizza window. Once you know what you want, they heat up the slice that's in the window. If it's not there, they will make it fresh. The breadsticks are so delish. I tend to get the pepperoni pizza. The smell of pizza dough is so intoxicating and the slices are bigger than your head! If you want to dine in, they offer you paper plates. I suggest grabbing some napkins because of the grease, but in a good way. Not too much. The bathrooms are always clean and fresh. I always enjoy coming here and love that I can grab a slice late night after going to a bar/lounge.

I've always had good service and love the pizza. Today the 2 employees that served me and rang me up sounded as if they were unfamiliar with the lunch special. I had to specify to the guy ringing me up that I had the salad (which I had put on the counter next to the boxed slice) so we did not need to wait on a bread stick. Then he didn't think there were any dressing choices except ranch when I could clearly see many dressing containers beyond just ranch...in the fridge. he didn't know what they were but did offer he'd give me a different one if I sons like the one that appeared to be a vinaigrette. I said I'm sure I will like it.The most disappointing part was the girl put my slice straight into the box. I never realized the slices were hot but that you always put them into the oven to crisp them up. I thought maybe there was a new process.I got in my car and started to head home. I grabbed my slice of pizza and it was floppy and not even remotely crisp like always. How could this employee be there during the lunch hour and not know you always hear the slice up in the oven.Maybe you will say she was very busy and trying to save time. When I walked in there was 1 guy ahead of me being rung up. A few people came in after me, but it's not like there was a line out the door.Anyhow, my piza was a floppy mess and not crispy like always. It was just disappointing.

Okay late night spot. Visited in for a slice late night after a concert. I wish detroit had these late night slice joints. Pizza is good. Of course the kids working there are crazy obnoxious, but it's a college crowd typically. It was enjoying to watch the pizza dough in the air. Line moved quick and they nice. Food was tasty. Price was kinda high. Priced per ingredient.

We went here for a cheap dinner after the zoo lights. We liked that we could just get pizza by the slice and didn't have to buy an entire pizza to take half back to the hotel room. The vibe inside was definitely either pre-game before going to the bar or where you go after the bar to get a late night bite to eat. I think it closes at 3am on the weekend. However, there were all different types of people there from families to younger groups about to go out. We had our daughter with us and there were high chairs available. The tables were a little dirty, but there is probably a big turn over rate in customers with minimal wipe down time. The took our order and got us our food quickly. There was a decent amount of seating, so it wasn't hard to find a seat at all. I got a pepperoni pizza and the single slices are huge. You really get a good bang for your buck. I liked the texture of the crust and thought the sauce was flavorful. The cheese was a bit heavy handed, so it was a little rubbery, but overall it was good.

I've been here a few times and never had a problem. Always enjoyed the pizza and speakeasy lounge. Came in last night about 7:30, and the guy waiting on us was clearly like sooo high ha. He kept asking what we wanted. My friend wanted a cheese slice and he said we're out--a guy behind hi says we have one in the oven! But the guy helping us couldn't put two and two together so my friend couldn't get a plain cheese slice and went with a veggie slice. Then literally two seconds later they bring out the cheese and the guy just stared at us. He used gloves when grabbing our slices and putting in oven then he had his hand touching the pizza slice when ringing us up ...the whole thing was just really weird. Like come on don't be stoned working. My pizza he didn't barely warm up and they were out of cheese sauce. Won't be going back anytime soon--really disappointed.

Give me a NY style slice of cheese and a coke and I'm a happy girl! Nothing fancy just simple and great. Not lacking in sturdiness either this was a thin but strong slice that folded into eating perfection. IYKYKOnly downside was the breadstick. That was mid. But my slice and cherry coke hit the spot per usual.

Stopped in after the concert and like always they always deliver! Chris was amazing too. Can't go wrong with Goodfellas!

I attempted to order via their website, which would not load the payment options. I then attempted to call them no less than 8 times. it would ring for around 30 seconds and they would pickup to hang up. my wife then attempted to call with the same behaviors. she then drove down there, because we really wanted to try it and they said 'oh were you the one that called like 15 times'. and then made the wrong pizza. absolutely outrageously terrible customer service.

The pizza was great. I felt it needed a little more sauce on it to be 5-star but it was still delicious. Breadsticks were great too.