Goodfellas Pizzeria - Broad Ripple

Well I accidentally ordered a huge pizza. I was really really wanting NY Style Pizza and only two places in Indy came up. It was a toss up of driving further and having a parking lot. Or closer and searching for parking since B-Ripple chose to remove parking on Broad Ripple Ave. We tossed a coin and B-ripple won. The pizza I got was like 24 in across. It was just two of us eating it. It did fit the bill for NY Style and it hit the spot Friday night and again Sat night and last two pieces Sunday night. So splitting it up between 3 meals the cost wasn't really that much. Be careful. It will auto add a 20% tip on line if not paying attention and you will be charged a service fee on top of that. We'd probably do the pizza again but parking in B-ripple sucks.

Bumping up my review for this Goodfellas Pizzeria because the 22-inch pizza is impressive. I've ordered the 22" twice now, and each time, I'm completely taken aback by how large it is. I felt like a cartoon character carrying the pizza box to my car. I could barely fit the box into the passenger seat of my SUV. Each slice of the 22-inch pizza is unwieldy and perfectly greasy and foldable. For a pizza this big, you want minimal toppings, because otherwise, the slices will be difficult to pick up. Adding just pepperoni is perfect.I'm still a little miffed that there isn't seating in this joint, but I guess it makes sense. There is zero parking in front of the restaurant because it faces Broad Ripple Avenue, and minimal parking around the corner. I was in a parking pickle when I went to pick up my to-go order -- I couldn't find a space! Luckily, I found some parking in the back of the restaurant. The parking in this area looks like it's off limits because there's a fence around it and you need to enter through a gate, but (I think) you're allowed to park there if you're just popping out to get your to-go order. Allow some time for your order to be ready. It took about 30 minutes for my pizza to be ready, but it was great when I finally got to eat it.

Forewarning this place only offers bar style seating so it wasn't ideal with children. The food was great and the staff is so dang nice it's enough to make me come back here!! Place was clean, they made my pizza fresh right there. My only complaint is our pizza was very soggy/greasy so you may need to ask for well done. The flavor was good though. They offer a great lunch deal and slices of pizza are available all day. I'd come back when I just want a slice or lunch.

Goodfellas is a great by-the-slice pizza joint. I've never seen the same person behind the counter twice. And the state of the drink machine and other amenities is always a crap shoot. But the pizza is good, cheap, fast, and tasty.

Goodfellas Pizza in Broad Ripple has always been a go-to spot for a delicious slice, but my recent visit was elevated to an extraordinary experience thanks to the stellar service provided by Chloe. From the moment I walked in, Chloe's warm and genuine smile set the tone for a wonderful evening. She greeted me with enthusiasm and made sure to take the time to explain the menu, highlighting her personal favorites and offering recommendations that did not disappoint.Throughout my order, Chloe's attentiveness was impeccable. She checked in frequently but unobtrusively, ensuring that everything was perfect. Her knowledge of the menu and passion for the food were evident, and she handled every request with grace and efficiency. Chloe's ability to balance multiple tables while providing personalized service to each guest was truly impressive.What truly stood out was Chloe's ability to make every customer feel valued. She went above and beyond, adding a personal touch that transformed a simple meal into a memorable dining experience. Her kindness, professionalism, and genuine care for her customers make her a true asset to Goodfellas Pizza.Chloe's exceptional service deserves recognition. It's clear she is an invaluable member of the team, and her dedication and hard work warrant a pay raise and a promotion. Goodfellas Pizza is fortunate to have her, and her outstanding service ensures that every visit is a delight. Highly recommended!

I decided to take advantage of Goodfellas' 50% pizza Monday special and ordered online. As a vegetarian, I was so excited to see how many options Goodfellas had to offer. I ordered 2 pizzas: the "taste of Naples" pie and "the bootlegger." "Taste of Naples" is essentially a margherita pizza. "The bootlegger" was a pesto-based pie with sun dried tomatoes, spinach, and mushroom. Of the two, the bootlegger was my favorite! Both were delicious but the bootlegger is definitely my new go-to pie.My pickup order was ready right on time and was extremely hot (preferred)! Even though it was busy in the restaurant, the pickup process was extremely easy.

REAL New York pizza in Indiana!! Can't find this anywhere in Michigan, sadly.Mostly to go orders, though there is a counter to eat in.Lots of famous Italians and movie photos on the wall which is all right Hope they get a place like this up North, preferably East Lansing.

Pizza is yummmm We went in for a late night dinner after getting drinks around town and decided to get some pizza at GoodFellas and I'm glad we did! They sold pizza by the slice and it was such a good deal considering their pizzas are huge. We also got a cup of cheese to dip the pizzas in and they were amazing. Not much space to sit at so we just stood and ate at the counter (keep that in mind). This place is great for when you're looking for something quick, cheap, and delicious after a late night out.

Been here thrice in the last month. There are a lot of good pizza joints in Indy, and this is certainly one of them. Consistent, good crust (not too floppy), quality toppings and great cheese1st time had the The Boss. I ordered it by accident as chicken and ranch isn't really my thing on pizza. It was ok. 2nd time had Paulie's Favorite. Fantastic! My favorite of theirs thus far. 3rd time The Goodfella. It was solid. Ordered takeout, ready when it is supposed to be. Staff is friendly enough. I'll be back. Especially for half priced Mondays!

Fast service, great tasting pizza! We get pizza every Sunday and this has been a staple! Pizza has a lot of sauce!