Goodfellas Pizzeria

Really good! The dough was awesome as was the entire pizza. The people were really cool and they have an awesome deal. Big slice + drink + side for $10! All over that and really enjoyed it. Top flight pizza.

Goodfellas? I think you mean Greatfellas! Because this Goodfellas Pizzeria in Bloomington is superb. The food, service, price and even the organization of the restaurant (yes, I notice those things) were excellent.They serve the lunch special every day from 11 a.m. to 3 p.m. The lunch special is a slice of pizza, your choice of a side (a breadstick, a salad [caprese, pasta or lettuce salad], or a dessert [cheesecake, chocolate chip cookie, black-and-white cookie or cannoli]) and a drink for $9. I need to talk about the breadsticks here first, because they are enormous. They're about the size of an adult tibia. The breadsticks come with a dipping sauce (marinara or nacho cheese), and honestly, a breadstick and a sauce would make for a nice little lunch. The breadsticks are that huge.The pizza slices are also huge. My children had to hold them with two hands. We compared the slices to their heads, and I think the pizza slices might have been slightly larger than their heads. Huge, people. I don't mince words here. I love a place that sells pizza by the slice, and this place does but does it to the max.Oh, and the pizza was great. It had a crunch to it, but it was also soft around the edges, and the sauce and cheese were just the right amounts. It's the kind of slice you picture in your mind when you think about getting a good slice of pizza.Goodfellas is located close to Indiana University, so just know that it might be difficult to find parking. We found lots of parking in a lot that was behind a building that was across the street from Goodfellas. Parking was free on Sundays, too, which was a bonus because we visited on a Sunday.

The slices are huge. The pizza wasn't bad. Not the best I had but decent. I had the bacon chicken with ranch. Staff were real nice, college students. Late night

would put 4 or eveN 5 stars but I've had both entire pizzas and slices with gooey dough on more than one occasion... However, when it's NOT GOOEY this is hands down the BEST pizza in town. Perfect crisp/crunch to it; solid ingredients everything comes together to make a truly delicious slice. One of my go-to spots; despite the whole gooey dough thing Notes: 1) sometimes there are really outlandish and completely undesirable combos on the premade pizza slices; at which point I just leave to spend my dollars elsewhere. @ whoever is in charge of that quit doing weird shit; would much rather see margarita pizza as a regular staple. 2) a bit overcharged esp considering you run the risk of encountering gooey dough pretty much every other time... this is a college town and 2 slices of pizza should never ever cost the same as an entire pizza; regardless of topping count. Other pizza by the slice joints are $3... they charge double or more. 3) would like to see the half off Monday pizzas go back to including the bigger ones too.4) ranch. stop charging for it.

You really can't beat the fact that they have $4.50 cheese slices. Everyone that I've come into contact there that works there is incredibly nice and willing to have a conversation. Too often I go to places where people just want to stare at their phone and not be bothered to have a decent conversation with a patron. Here though, it's great conversation about whatever game is on the tv, the job, etc.Having family in New York City (along with all the other Burroughs) and having been to multiple pizza places (shout out to Di Fara Pizza, and Antony's Pizza), this is as close to home you're going to get in Indy! Give it a go for a great NY Slice, and for lunch add a side and drink.... And all that for $10 and some change... in this economy.... It's simply bellissimo

Good place great food/pizza nice portions fresh vegetables friendly staff it's a great after bar hopping too

$9 for a slice (giant), a side, and a drink??? What a lunch special! We had stellar service. The woman who checked us out correctly inferred we were splitting a slice and offered to cut it for us. The breadsticks are about half the length of your body, so plenty filling! The pizza was yummy. Thinner style, flexible, and not super saucy.

Today we left to get lunch without a place in mind to eat. As we were walking down the road, my sweet boy asked me if I had ever had "Goodfellas", to which I said nope ! And he goes, well that's about to change...We went inside a small restaurant with barely enough sitting room. There was a counter where you could see the pizzas they had available. We ordered the lunch special which was $8 for a slice of pizza, a side, and a drink. I got a cheese pizza, bigger than my face ! And an 8ft long breadstick ! They were both delicious. I was not at all disappointed. The pizza is a New York style, so expect thin crust. Definitely recommend visiting !

Just saying, this place has some fun people, with some really good pizza. Come here just to see someone but get some goods while i'm here. Food is delicious, People are awesome, Music there was also great picks

Breadsticks are wonderful when they are soft and chewy but are too often over baked and are then crunchy and hollow. Please address this as I would like to order them often but I have to avoid them now. The cheese bread is always great! It's a nice place with good ambience