Goodfella's Pizza

The food was fantastic! The pizza, sticks and and poppers were all full of flavor, pipping hot and the order was ready on time. The pizza was cooked perfectly, the crust wasn't too much, but just right. Met the owner, super friendly and very customer focused. The inside was small but can easily seat a number of families. Overall, great location and pizzeria!

This was my first time to Goodfellas. We travel through Wabash on the way to and from Lafayette. We've always thought there had to be some good eating in Wabash. We found one!Good fellas does have dine in! The inside is small and not very attractive. It's very plain but comfortable and very clean. Even the restroom was very clean! When you get here you order at the counter and self serve drinks.We ordered the corn poppers to start. They looked interesting and are made on site. The popper came in various shapes and sizes - all random. I would have preferred something more consistent like a hush puppy ball. The breading was soft with pieces of corn inside. The breading has a slight buttery flavor to go with the dough taste. The corn taste was mild - I thought it could have used more corn to increase the taste. The popper had a sweet flavoring as well. I really thought the popper should have served with a sauce of some kind.The pizza was very good! The crust was soft while being cooked sufficiently. The sauce was not very prominent - it really wasn't very noticeable and didn't accent the taste much. The topping was piled high. We had plenty of meats and cheese. Everything was very fresh.The staff was pretty busy with delivery and drive through orders. The counter/cashier/host was pleasant and professional. She wasn't very prepared for 20 questions that might come from a new customer. However she got the job done! The two young men that brought out the appetizers and pizza weren't very friendly. Overall...if you are looking for pizza in Wabash...you have to try Goodfellas!

Goodfellas will be to your house/tiny-apartment, or whatever you got in the allotted time and it pretty good. got a real thick bistro type smell and taste to it. i will eat there now and then for sure. And the service always speedy NICE!

I'm from the East Coast and love the Brooklyn Style pizza (foldable thin crust). I never thought I'd ever get my beloved slice again until I happened to find Goodfella's on Massachusetts Ave. OMG! This has saved me and brought back many good memories of times long past.

I'm going to be honest, after reading the previous bad reviews and noting that the parking lot was empty on a Sunday evening we almost chose a different dining option. These two things that led me to believe we were in for sub-par pizza. But with two small starving kids we decided to forge ahead. I am so glad we did. Wow. This pizza was great. We ordered breadsticks (hot and buttery), a small pizza with no sauce for our picky child, and an 18" hand tossed pepperoni, mushroom and onion. The crust was soft and tasty on its own plus great sauce and plenty of toppings. It was even good microwaved for breakfast (shhh...) the next morning. I can't speak for the others who were unhappy with their experience but, to me, Goodfellas lived up to the hype I always hear from Monte "The Music Man" Sieberns. My only suggestions: music in the dining area and real utensils for people that like to eat the middle pizza pieces with a fork.

Another great experience at Goodfellas, North Manchester! Pizzas are delicious and tons of toppings. Our kids love it too! Staff is friendly. Dining area is clean and family friendly.

Stopped by here on the way through town at dinner time. It is a very clean and small resturant. It had about 6 indoor tables and a few out door tables. The pizza was good, but not great. They square cut the pizza which is OK. The hand tossed crust was too flimsy to hold. Even though it was square cut, the pizza was not crisp enough to hold. It had to be eaten with a fork or two hands. I am not sure if the thin crust is any crisper. They have plastic forks which are not good enough for cutting the crust. I had to use the edge of the pizza slice spatula to cut the pizza into bites small enough to eat with a fork.The sauce was put on it very thin and did not contribute much too the flavor of the pizza. I had to convince my daughter that there was sauce on there by showing her the red stain on the crust. The locals are very friendly, which was a plus.They don't serve beer.

My boyfriend and I come here every time we stop through Wabash. We absolutely love it here! It's just a tiny little place with six tables and a local following for delivery. The pizza is very yummy and they have lots of unique pizzas! The breadsticks are pretty good, and their prices are reasonable. We love the Big Deal (double decker pepperoni) and the CI (chicken bacon ranch). If only we could pick up this pizza and put it in our hometown!

Best little pizza shop in Wabash, IN & Wabash County. Food is great and staff is pleasant.. always a great place to visit!.

Simply put, the best pizza ever! Delivery service was speedy and the people are wonderful.