El Pastorcito

Excellent enchiladas served with rice, beans and sliced fresh avocado, with a nice red sauce and melted cheese. Friendly service and decent prices. The food was piping hot and delicious. The restaurant is also next door to Ofelia's Bakery which is a real winner.

Decent food, fast service on a weeknight.We ordered huevos rancheros and carne asada. When we got there only one other table but it quickly filled up. Food came out quickly. Only one server but she was efficient. Will try there again.

Was looking for a spot to ease that Mexican food craving and found this spot in a small strip center not to far away from home. Due to the favorable Yelp reviews here I am. It is a tiny spot with six booth tables and four, four top tables. Simple interior with ceramic tile floor and wainscot. There are two decorative wood awnings, and two flat screen TV's with dueling shows. When I walked in I was greeted by a friendly and helpful waitress, I placed my Togo order and waited with an ice cold Diet Coke. We ordered the chicken fajitas and they were well prepared and quite tasty!This is a great neighborhood spot with good food!

I honestly didn't expect to give this place a 5 star rating when I ordered take out, but what a pleasant surprise! I ordered a vegetarian burrito, side order of refried beans and chips with pico and guacamole. In the dead of winter, everything was so fresh and it was clearly made from scratch. The guacamole was the real thing and no weird creamy filler (as some restaurants add, which is a real pet peeve of mine). I was very impressed with the burrito, which was filled with fajita style veggies and Mexican cheese...it also came with rice as a side! The portions were HUGE, I had 2 full meals from the order. Their prices can't be beat, either! I can't speak to their authenticity (I'm a born and raised Indiana gal) but the flavors and freshness will keep me coming back.

Walked in, the waitress made eye contact with me and walked to the back, so I sat myself - nobody came out to greet me. My friend joined me and we sat for a few, their were two other tables who had menu and drinks - we left b/c a racist establishment such as this will not receive our money.

Definitely a solid spot. Food was authentic, minus the chips, which I had seen in other reviews. I love the chip brand they serve though so I could care less about that. Guac was fresh and had good chunks of avo. I got 2 Al Pastor and 1 carnitas tacos. Both were good. The carnitas had a bit of char on the edges which gave it a little crisp which I was a big fan of. I would have liked to see more pineapple chunks in the pastor, but that seems to be lacking in the Indy area. Not my favorite Mexican spot in the area, but have to give them credit for the authenticity and great taste!

Another good dish... Marjolla del a Diabla. Yummy. Full perch scored and fried in Diabla sauce. Perfectly cooked and happily supplemented with tortillas and fresh picante. Happy Hombre'. This was served with rice and accompanied tomato lettuce onion and lime wedges.

Love this place! It's a little hole in the wall on the west side but it's amazing and so authentic!! I been going to this location for the past 7 years! It's worth the trip! They have one of the best horchatas! A definite must try!

Good authentic Mexican grub. We had the chicken fajitas and chicken quesadilla. They brought out a carousel of salsas (salsa verde, tomatilla salsa, pico de gallo) but it didn't have the usual salsa served in most Mexican restaurants which was a bummer to me but others in my party enjoyed it. The tomatilla salsa was SUPER spicy, so be forewarned!! The queso was watery and pretty disappointing. The corn tortillas for the fajitas were super good. Overall it's a decent place to grab a bite of Mexican cuisine and I would probably return if I am in this area again.

The lady that takes your order was really nice but about it there was a cockroach in the wall the guy that's in the kitchen did not seemed very happy, do not recommend this place at all.