Circles Ice Cream

Circles Ice Cream is the best ice cream in Indianapolis. Nothing compares.There's no physical store- they have freezers placed in several restaurants that you buy the ice cream room using a QR code. Each pint is $13 but it's well worth the price.I got 3 flavors:1) tiramisu: AMAZING. I wish I was eating it right now. This tasted exactly like tiramisu. The subtle coffee flavor was perfect. The crumble throughout the pint made every bite taste like actual tiramisu cake. 2) peppermint bark: the PERFECT amount of peppermint flavor. It was so rich and soft. The crushed candy cane on top (and throughout the whole pint) made for a nice flavorful crunch. 3) Mexican wedding cake: what made this flavor perfect is that there was actual dulce de leche & cake crumbles in the pint. It was so sweet and every bite had enough of the toppings. Their flavors are so unique and they are always coming out with new ones. I definitely recommend anyone living in Indy to try it!

This local ice cream is so good! My husband became aware of this local ice cream on social media. They have some seasonal flavors that we really wanted to try. Once we looked at their website, we realized there were tons of flavors that looked delicious.One interesting thing is that they have standalone freezers in different businesses all over Indianapolis. You can go and scan and pay online, see these attached photos for one of the freezers at hotel tango in Zionsville. If you look at their website or social media, you can find out all the locations of the freezers. I am not sure if they have an actual location elsewhere.We have tried the seasonal carrot cake ice cream, which was the best ice cream I have literally ever had! It had tons of toppings and layers of cream cheese icing throughout the pint. We also tried banoffee pie, which was really good.I believe the cost was $13 per pint. I know it sounds a little expensive, but totally worth it and I love supporting a local business.

There's a lot of great ice cream in Indy -- heck, in the Midwest -- but I'm not sure there's one that's better than Circles. Circles has perfected a dense, layered ice cream that is both decadent and innovative. Every flavor is a winner, and the seasonal rotations are always augmented by new creations. One of the best things about Circles is the way you get it. Freezers can be found at local grocery stores, bodegas, even distilleries like Hotel Tango. You just scan a QR code, grab the pint you want, pay for it, and off you go. Circles used to be a delivery-only operation, and this method makes way more sense. Circles also does incredible dairy-free ice cream -- I usually don't even know it's dairy-free. If you haven't given it a try, the price point can sometimes scare people off, but it's absolutely worth every penny.

I'm addicted. I only get Circles icecream now.My favorite flavors so far are the Creamsicle Cheesecake, Coffee Milk. Pretzel Toffee. They've had a few coffee ones that ate great too, Coffee Cake Crumble and Tiramisu. They have a new setup at Wildwood Market where you can go in to the icecream case on the left of the store and scan a QR code to pay, pull out what you bought, and leave. It feels mischievous but you know you paid! Haha. Follow their Instagram to get sneak peeks on upcoming flavors and when they drop new loads at Wildwood.

Wow!!! I found out about them on social media and that also helped me find where they are located. It's confusing because when you map them it brings you to a store only open on weekends. So follow them on Instagram and they will post a story or post about where they put a cooler full of amazing ice cream or where they restocked. I have gotten watermelon sugar high and cookie milk and they were delicious!!!! They have layers of extra toppings throughout and come in cute pints you can take home. You buy them using a QR code on the cooler. Go get some!

Forgot to take a picture of my ice cream but it was amazing!! The campfire smores is an amazing flavor and so is the coffee cake crumble. I used their instagram to find local shops that have the freezers with pints!

Honestly I dream about this ice cream! Not gonna lie, I am a girl who tries to watch her calories but when it comes to Circles Ice Cream I don't even think twice! This ice cream is worth it!! I got to try Circles Ice Cream for the first time two years ago at the Yelp Christmas Bazzar, after that it was a done deal and I was hooked. I love the creative flavors Wes and his team comes up with and it's always exciting when they collaborate with other local Indy restaurant/food locations. You won't find this ice cream in a store, they deliver to you on Saturday. Pre-COVID he would sometimes set up shop at Hotel Tango or other locations around town and you could buy pints, and I'm sure that will come back one day.I'm not a chocolate lover so I have stayed away from those flavors, otherwise I would say everything is incredible! (I know chocolate lovers love those flavors as well, or so my family members who have become hooked have told me) Come Christmas time you NEED to get Gingerbread as it is one of my top 3 flavors. Next in that list is Mexican Wedding Cake, and then after that it is currently a toss up between Strawberry PB&J and Blueberry Muffin! However there are still many flavors I haven't tried. Anyways do yourself a favor and buy this incredible ice cream for the next Saturday delivery!

Slapping. I'm not sure if there's a better level above that but it is my fave ice cream in the world. Above Ben an Jerry's, Graeters, Humphrey Slocombe, Bi Rite, Salt and Straw...if you haven't heard of the last three y'all need to get out more. Don't spend it on ice cream...go traveling. My fave so far is puppy chow. I like my ice cream full of stuff. So if you don't, this ain't the ice cream for you.

Top 5 favorite ice creams I've had in my life. Period. S'mores campfire, yes. COOKIE MILK, YAS. key lime pie.... In the words of my friend, "it'll make your tongue slap your brain" and I think it did. Truly amazing ice cream. Only downside is the price so be prepared to pay more for a pint than usual. But it is worth it. Key lime pie and cookie milk is a must. Thank you.

Some of the best ice cream I've ever had! As I have gotten older I've realized I have an intolerance to dairy. I was thrilled when I saw that Circles made a dairy free option. The chai pistachio was so delicious! Thank you Circles for making some incredible ice cream!