Chicago's Pizza

This is definitely one of my go-to restaurants. Whether you are getting to go, or dine in, this place always feels at home. The food is always up to par. The service is excellent. I feel very welcomed every visit. The restaurant itself is well taken care of and apleasant environment to be in.

Pro - there's a lunch time salad bar! It's not huge by any means, but there's a variety of pizzas, breadsticks, dipping sauces and salad options to choose from which is rare at pizza places these days. I had pepperoni and sausage pizza and it was pretty standard. It's hard to go wrong with pizza- some are better than others and most fall in the average area, which is where I would rank Chicago's. They have the deep dish on the menu, which you can also order off, but I just did the buffet and tried the New York style slices. I would go back, but it won't be a regular spot for me.

We experienced very poor customer service. I placed a scheduled delivery order of $200 worth of pizza. The pizza was scheduled for delivery after 6:30 PM. The scheduled delivery time was chosen on purpose because the pizzas were for an event. The restaurant made the order as soon as they received it at 4:00 PM. They called to let me know they were made early and had been sitting out waiting to be picked up. They were unwilling to remake any of the pizzas or offer any type of compensation for receiving cold pizzas that had been made over two hours before the scheduled delivery time.

Pizza was fire. Great service. Life long customer. The bread sticks a must. The thin crust BBQ chicken pizza is my favorite!

Pizza is good, but skip the bread sticks. They were just cooked pieces of pizza dough with no salt or butter on them. The place is on the small size, but that makes it nice because it's quieter than the one on Stop 11.

We ordered the thin crust Buffalo Chicken Pizza and there was as a layer of WAX PAPER under the toppings. The worst part is I had already eaten some before I realized.

Some of the best pizza if not the best in bargersville/greenwood area. Most of the Chicagos pizza places are good but this one is by far the best. Also a very friendly team who have been there for years. Life long customer for sure. Don't miss out!

We used to love Chicago's pizza in bargersville. Ordered take out tonight, pizza was burnt, cold and had very light toppings. Bread sticks were burnt as well. Told the pizza would take 15-20 minutes, and it took over an hour. Very disappointed

We've been regulars for a while. me and my friends will come in here all the time and the get the chicago fire with breadsticks. all of the sudden we come in and the prices are raised, the breadstick design was changed and the restaurant had gotten cockier. absolutely ridiculous, will not be coming back. ridiculous!

Chicago's Pizza Bargersville, IN is a favorite for pizza. Traditional crust, Italian sausage and extra cheese. Yum.. always cooked to perfection. I dined in today for the first time. The waitress was awesome. The fresh brewed tea was great. Also try their hot ham and cheese..no sauce on it for me..it is great too. Another feature..they have a room for large groups .looks like it would seat 12 or more ..nice for a birthday pizza party. Awesome experience. Excellent service, great food and a great price.