Caplinger's Fresh Catch
Caplinger's Fresh Catch
Fresh seafood is delivered daily.
food, soups and chowder
Grilled Walleye Sandwich
Charles, our Meridian manager is an OG with Caplinger's. He was 15 years old when he and Andrew 1st worked together at 56th St. Fish Market.
Caplinger's Special
Our Smoked Tuna Salad is LEGENDARY!
Customer service is our specialty.
Locally sourced fish to ensure freshness and great taste!
Lobster Roll, Fried Okra, Hush Puppies
sushi and sashimi
Locally sourced fish to ensure freshness and great taste!
food, oysters and mussels
Locally sourced fish to ensure freshness and great taste!
Blackened Walleye Dinner
Catfish Dinner
Locally sourced fish to ensure freshness and great taste!
We have our own blend of breading that sets us apart from all the others.
We carry Indy's freshest and best variety of seafood.
Outdoor seating area that is available for large parties at NO COST!
Outdoor seating area that is available for large parties at NO COST!
Erik's Grouper Sandwich & Collard Greens
a man working in a fish shop
the inside of the store
Nathan W.
Jan 25, 2025
It's rare today that you find an established that makes it so easy to see the pride they take in their work! Great food and great service! Honestly I cannot remember ever eating a better piece of fish!
Read More
Geneva L.
Oct 7, 2024
The service was amazing. Tim needs a raise he went above and made us feel welcomed. He needs a raise and promotion. He alone made us want to return. The food was fresh and amazing. The chicken breast was juicy and flavorful. The greens and red beans and rice were so good. I could eat their greens every day. Their walley is cooked and flavored well and it tastes like it was caught and cooked the same day.I don't think you can go wrong ordering anything from here.They are reasonably priced and they are generous with their portions. If you have not been here you need to check them out.
Read More
Andrew W.
Dec 31, 2024
We had an incredible experience at Caplinger's Fresh Catch! The customer service was outstanding - friendly and welcoming from beginning to end. The food was fresh and cooked to perfection, with a great variety of fish, sides, and more on the menu. The laid-back atmosphere made for a relaxing, casual dining experience. We even had the pleasure of meeting the owner, who was gracious and down-to-earth. He even gave us thank you card and a small gift card for our next visit. We can't wait to return and highly recommend this spot!
Read More
Brittney R.
Aug 20, 2024
Very small restaurant and fresh fish market but high quality food and service. There are two refrigerators with bottled drinks, desserts, prepared foods, goods, frozen fish and seafood. There is a large display of fresh fish and seafood for the market. You order at a small counter and there are about 6 tables for dine in. They have delicious drink options with mixed fruit juices, soda, sweet tea, and Tamika Catchings bottled tea. They have sandwiches, salmon, shrimp, oysters, catfish, etc. The sides are delicious. I recommend both their mac n cheese and fried ocra.
Read More
Storm R.
Feb 20, 2025
I love Caplingers! I recommend the grilled salmon with collard greens and cornbread. Also the fried catfish and salmon sandwiches are delicious. You won't be disappointed!
Read More
Theresa A.
Jan 22, 2025
Best seafood in town . Needing to purchase seafood they have it all ! Needing to find a place to eat amazing food and employees. Love this place . I'm a seafood lover I highly recommend!
Read More
Jackson H.
Mar 31, 2024
This place is a go to and a must try if you want some great seafood in a casual setting. They have a counter where you can just buy raw fish (have them cook it or take home to cook) and you can also order and sit at the tables to eat. They have quite a few fish sandwiches made with lots of different fish, their lobster roll is amazing, the gator bites are really good, and so is most other things on the menu. I do sometimes struggle deciding whether to go here or somewhere with more ambience because you pay the same price even without being "fancy". It is certainly not a cheap meal at $25 a person on average but it is a good meal!
Read More
Jen F.
Mar 24, 2024
I really wish we could do half stars because I would give this a 3.5 star rating. We placed an online pickup order and everything was correct. That's a nice attention to detail. Entrees and sandwiches were great. All sauces were included, etc. The side of candied yams is absolutely the most amazing thing in this world. So good. Here's where things went kinda sideways for me. A large side of red beans and rice and an order of lobster bisque were obviously heavily microwaved. You know when you reheat something in a plastic to-go container and the rim gets kinda crusty and the plastic gets weird? Yea. That. The lobster bisque was really good, but my heart was broken at the crust ring around the container. It's bisque. Be gentle. The red beans and rice were an utter disaster. It was as if someone packaged this pint to-go container three days prior and then nuked it for my order. The rice was a sticky gelatinous mess at the bottom and the beans were undercooked. The sauce, which was sparse, just sat on top of the rice mess. I've wanted to try Caplinger's since the original location opened and now they have four! I look forward to going back and ordering thoughtfully.
Read More
Ebony L.
Jan 18, 2025
Best seafood spot in Indy! I truly enjoy their catfish and fried okra. My mother loves the fried oysters.
Read More
Brandon C.
Mar 3, 2025
Food, selection and staff are all outstanding. Indianapolis has never seen fresh fish like this!
Read More
