Smoked Tuna Salad Sandwich
Caplinger's Special Sandwich
Great Meal Options!
Blackened Salmon Dinner
Fresh Fish and Seafood Delivered Every Day. Special Orders Welcomed
Caplinger's Special Sandwich
The crispy soft shell crab!
Oro king salmon. Look at that marbling
Ranked Top 20 Lobster Roll in the USA!
Salads and shrimp to go
a piece of bread with cheese on it
View inside fish counter
a sandwich and chips
a chicken sandwich with lettuce and tomato
a basket of fried food
Caplinger's Special Sandwich
a plate of fish and vegetables
sandwiches, food, sandwich
a hand in a pan of food
Catfish - Min
a deep fryer filled with fried donuts
Caplinger's Special Sandwich
Excited for the food!
Amber C.
Dec 5, 2024
Caplinger's is forever that girl!If you're looking for fresh, yummy, well seasond seafood - Caplinger's is the place to be! Tucked on Indy's northeast side, it's perfectly positioned for visitors to the local hospital or Castleton Square mall. The foodnis perfectly prepared and always SO good. Even the sides make themselves lnown as stars of the show. I appreciate the generous portions and that food is served HOT.Caplinger's is a must try!
Read More
Sara R.
Nov 23, 2024
After a morning of craft/hobby browsing at Lawrence Central High School, I had worked up a little appetite. I didn't want to go anywhere that would take too long, but my options between Lawrence Central and my house were kind of slim. Suddenly, I was driving up Shadeland Ave and I remembered Caplinger's Fresh Catch. My mind told me I'd be having a fried grouper sandwich. However, once my tastebuds sampled the smoked tuna salad, plans changed. I know it might not sound good, but I'm thinking a tub of it with some buttery crackers would be an excellent way to start your Thanksgiving FEASTivities! I still WILL have that fried grouper sandwich. Some day. #Getlostindiana
Read More
Sarah S.
Sep 21, 2024
I'm pregnant and have been craving crab legs for weeks. My husband did his research and found out Caplingers had king crab legs that they'd cook fresh for you. We went tonight and I was absolutely blown away. If we didn't have a budget, I'd be back every day of the week. The butter served alongside was delightful, and I was given plenty of lemons to pair with the delightful leg meat. Will absolutely be back for special occasions in the future!To add, french fries were really delicious, crab cake was amazing, would not get the green beans again. Husband thought perch was good, but he'll probably go for a different fish next time like cod.
Read More
Michael B.
Feb 18, 2025
Caplinger's is now renowned for fresh seafood and a great selection every day. Central Indiana is gaining more seafood options and you can be assured that Caplinger's has the kind of turnaround on their fish that it will be first class. Be forewarned that there are several items on the menu that can get pricey, i.e. the fried grouper but it's worth it. The staff is knowledgeable and friendly. After ordering at the counter, be prepared for a bit of a wait even if they don't look that busy.
Read More
Brenda J.
Oct 19, 2024
My go to fish spot. I ordered my usual catfish sandwich. My cousin got the crawfish with yams and baked beans.
Read More
Sheree W.
Jul 14, 2024
I really can't believe I just made my way to Caplingers. I pass by there a million times and just never stopped. A coupon came in the mail and to be honest that is what prompted my visit. Upon pulling up, the parking lot is busy but I was able to find a spot right in front which is good. I went on a Friday around 3:30 and it was busy, seemed like people were coming out with to go orders. When I went inside, I had no idea there is actually seating inside. I don't know why I thought it was just to go orders. When you walk in there is a cabinet of fresh fish that you can buy, or you can have it prepared for you. I ordered a Grouper Sandwich, and a side of fries. Fries do NOT come with the sandwich so just beware of that.You order and then they will bring the food to your table when it is ready should you decide to dine in. The food was really good, I mean really good. It tasted very fresh and not greasy like some fish places. It was clean inside and the staff were very nice.Now that I know I can go and get seafood and not just any seafood but good seafood I'll be back for sure.Oh and pricing is reasonable, the Grouper sandwich I think was about $16.
Read More
Caitlin M.
Feb 11, 2025
Great fish market and restaurant! Anytime we do a seafood boil we come here to get everything. All seafood needs can be met here!
Read More
Jennie B.
Feb 3, 2025
Very nice staff. Great food. Reminds me of old Florida. Highly recommend for fresh seafood
Read More
Moody F.
Feb 25, 2025
Great food and fresh, they are busy often especially the weekend, so plan ahead of time to be there.It's nice and clean, restarting was clean.
Read More
Tamara H.
Feb 28, 2025
First time diners here although we've heard about them for years. The food was absolutely wonderful! Will definitely come back, again and again. The staff was wonderful too! Highly recommend!
Read More