The Most Delectable Pizza in Indianapolis

MadTree Brewing

★★★★☆ 4.4 (658) • $$

"IT'S LONG BUT READ IT!!!!!Long time coming...been a regular at 1.0 (original brewery) then regulars at 2.0 (existing brewery) had the first beers served. Seen quite a few changes over the years. (The brewery scene is not what it was). Seen staff come n go. We went through a lean time where the food just wasn't worth going as often. BUT NOW the food is awesome n we're back w a vengeance!!! Have a great time w the bartenders as we always have. For us it's nice to be back home!!!Thanks Kenny n Brady for fixing things! Do yourself a favor and visit! There's something for everyone! CHEERS! JC"

Iaria's Italian Restaurant

★★★★☆ 4.2 (639) • $$

"We love Iarias! My first visit here was in 1990! Can't beat the chicken piccata or the pizza. Everyone in our family loves to gather here for great food and a great wait staff."

Upland Brewing - Bloomington

★★★★☆ 4 (686) • $$

"Went there for lunch with some friends today. I had the fish and chips, they had the tenderloin sandwich. Everything was simply amazing! My fish was absolutely crispy on the outside, tender, and juicy on the inside. The house made tartar sauce made the dish complete. It was accompanied by housemaid fries, which were absolutely fantastic. I wish I had thought to take a picture before I devoured my lunch. The service is always fantastic at this place. I love going there in the summer when you can sit on the patio. But the inside is beautifully decorated with amazing murals and just an overall great vibe."

King Dough Indy

★★★★☆ 4.3 (505) • $$

"My family and I ended up walking over here for dinner after attending the Cheese & Wine Festival in the area. The place looked packed and we thought we were going to have a wait. It must've been our lucky night because we were seated immediately. There are quite a few different types of pizzas and some appetizers as well. We ordered some wings and Parmesan truffle fries, and for pizzas my girls had their classic cheese and Mi Amor and I ordered the Stinky Pete. Everything (wings and fries) came out within 30 minutes which was great because my 7 year old was "starving". The fried were crisped to perfection, everyone enjoyed the wings although I personally didn't find anything special about them.Now the pizzas......amazing. The dough was the thickness I love and must've been cooked in a wood fire oven based on the way the crust browned. The only thing lacking is the crust, for me, didn't have any real flavor but the toppings on top packed enough to make it enjoyable.The windows were open so you got to have the feeling of sitting outside without actually being outside which was nice. The staff was very friendly and gave their favorite recommendations on pizza which was nice, although I had peeked at the menu prior to so I already had an idea what I wanted. We all agreed we would come back again even though it's very loud inside."

Brozinni Pizzeria

★★★★☆ 4.3 (493) • $$

"We had a large party dine in on a Sunday night and had a really wonderful experience!! The food was so so good, really wonderfully prepared and delicious. The portion sizes are pretty outrageous - 2 orders of the breadsticks and 3 20" pizzas were way too much for 15 people, but in the best way. We opted to have our pizzas party sliced (16 slices instead of 8), which worked wonderfully for our party. If you dine here, you HAVE to try their house-made ranch. Oh my word this was INCREDIBLE! One of the best decisions to have some of this alongside our breadsticks and pizza for dipping. We all agreed we would be coming back here because of our positive experience and because of how yummy the food was. Thanks Brozinni!!My experience with ADA was also decent! I have a medical alert service dog and had a relatively normal experience at this restaurant. I called ahead to let them know my party was coming, and they were very professional in handling it. They do not take reservations. I arrived first so I could get situated at my table (as getting a dog situated at a large table/booth can sometimes be a challenge), but unfortunately they were not willing to seat me early until others in my party showed up. Despite having the table ready, I had to wait by the door with my dog until a group of my friends came in. It was a bit of a struggle for me to get myself and my dog in our corner booth with everyone else there, moving the chairs around, etc., hence why I got there early to do that. It was a bit of a flustering moment, but that's just life & the world of ADA. But generally they handled having my dog & myself there positively which is good. Could the accommodations have been better? Yes. Were they good overall? Yes. Overall, thankful things went smoothly :)"

Camporosso

★★★★☆ 4.4 (400) • $$

"Food was great, had a brick oven pizza. Great service, cute garage door patio. Adding words to end review."

I Tre Mori

★★★★★ 4.5 (368) • $$

"We stumbled upon this gem during our travels. The restaurant was bright, clean, and had a super cute aesthetic. It offered some of the best Italian food I've ever had.Ordered:- Pizza Vegetariana- 4 Formaggi Spaghetti- BruschettaThe food was incredibly fresh and flavorful. The pizza, pasta, and bruschetta were tasty, with an amazing crust. The wood-fired oven pizza was at its finest, with fresh ingredients and authentic flavors. Everything tasted amazing and was bursting with freshness and flavor.The price point might seem a bit high at first, but the quality is worth it. The service was good, and the prices were reasonable considering the high quality. The cleanliness, light and bright colors, and ample dining space added to the great experience. We left feeling very satisfied. They also have a drive-through option, which is convenient for quick takeout."

Diavola Pizza

★★★★☆ 4.2 (400) • $$

"We sat at the bar and the bartender was super friendly. Inside was cozy and perfect for our winter visit. We started with the brussels sprouts, which had bacon, parm, and truffle oil. They were quite a treat. They came out piping hot, which was also a great sign for the rest of our meal. We also got the genovese pizza which had a base of pesto and was topped with chicken, sun dried tomatoes and caramelized onion. It was delicious. I even heard a "best pizza I've had in Indy" spoken. It was also fresh from their brick oven, the crust was crispy yet soft on the inside and the toppings were delicious. It was a win.The only thing I didn't like about the restaurant was that the cocktail menu didn't have prices. That never really makes sense to me and I'm not as laid back as I'd like to be about that kind of thing lol. In the end, I got the Italian Gentlemen cocktail (Bourbon, Campari, Orange Bitters, Lemon Juice and Agave) and it ended up being $14. It was spirit forward and a very good drink so I was happy. We also got a tequila soda with lime which ended up being $9. There is a shared free parking lot and it was easy to find a spot."

Futuro

★★★★★ 4.7 (315) • $$

"I tried some of Futuro's amazing pizzas recently.I purchased the "Classic" pizza Tavern style and a Pepperoni pizza Detroit style and breadsticks. Alyssa helped me and was extremely friendly and helpful. The first bite was the Tavern. All my wife kept saying was mmm...mmm...mmm. so, that was a hit and I would definitely agree! Next we sampled the breadsticks. My first thought was how soft they were and tasted the parm and seasonings. Not a normal breadstick. I commented I could eat a full order of just them! Lastly we tried the Detroit. As with the Tavern, the toppings are abundant. From end to end, corner to corner. I'm a fan of Detroit style and spent many years there for work. I tried a lot and I would put this right up with the best. The crust was perfectly crisp and golden brown. Next time, I'm going for the Chicago-style!Note: There is seating upstairs and outside."

Passione

★★★★★ 4.5 (342) • $$

"My husband and I love Passione.. the restaurant is small but perfect for a quick date night. Our go to meal is the Bruschetta and the Margherita Fresco with prosciutto and arugula, although you can't go wrong with any of the items. Their wings are also amazing. They are wood fired and just delicious!! Definitely a must try in fishers!"

Jockamo Upper Crust Pizza

★★★★☆ 4.2 (377) • $$

"Great spot for some truly amazing and unique pizza options! We went here for a Greenwood book club (which meets here monthly and orders pizza which is a win win in my book...literature humor). The staff was friendly and quite efficient for our large group and had a great attitude. Orders were taken quickly and for the rush it was quickly made as well in my opinion, hardly any time to wait at all! Well done!We loved that they have vegan options for cheese and sausages as well as gluten free crust options too. We got a mostly veggie one with goat's cheese that had a tangy sauce and some great flavors. I would for sure get it again as it was good that night and the next when we had our leftovers.We will be back here for both the food and atmosphere, and not just for book club either!"

The Gruff

★★★★☆ 4.1 (381) • $$

"We received a $10 off meal coupon as a gift and decided to check this place out. We are so glad that we did. First let me share that everything is homemade at this establishment and that makes it extra special for me. Knowing that they take that extra step means a lot. Our server was extremely knowledgeable and helpful. As a teacher it's his second job to help support his family, I appreciated how he made us feel welcomed and how he provided us with insight about the restaurant and their food. Clean, busy and friendly is how I would sum it up. Good food and drinks. We will return too!"

ZwanzigZ Pizza & Brewing

★★★★☆ 4 (390) • $$

"This is a nice local family restaurant and brewery located on the outskirts of downtown Columbus. Please do not ask me to pronounce the name though. They have their own private parking lot in the back and free street parking available in the front. There is also a decent sized dining area with televisions on the walls and a nice patio out to the side of the restaurant. You will find a tasting room to the right as you come in the front door, with booths and a bar. They periodically host tastings and special events here. The staff there is so friendly and helpful. They periodically checked in on us while we were there and one even came to our table and told the kids a dad joke.They do not have table service here so if you plan on dining in like I did then you have to place your order at the counter and they will bring your food out to you when it is ready. I ordered a lasagna pizza and some breadsticks for the littles. I also got one of their craft sodas and I am glad that I did. It was so good. I will say that this place is a bit on the higher end, but you pay for quality.It took about 15 to 20 minutes for me to get my food and it was delicious. I was expecting the pizza to taste more like lasagna, maybe with some ricotta, but it was still good. The breadsticks were fresh and perfect. This is a nice place to eat some "Za" , they also have salads, calzones, and hoagies. They also have a nice selection of craft beer and wine. A 4.5 rating would be more appropriate, but since that is not an option, I decided to go with a 5 because that it what I feel this restaurant is closer to. I highly recommend checking this place out. It is a good family restaurant with some very tasty food."

Magoo's California Pizza

★★★★★ 4.5 (290) • $

"First time here at this strip mall pizza place and it was amazing! Came in and there was nobody in the building except for the workers. It was a very basic, unassuming interior with some tables and not much else on the walls. We almost walked away because the place seemed dead. We decided to stay and opted for the medium size pizza for 2 people.They let us split the pizza in half to try 2 different flavors--chicken tikka and beef kabob. As we waited, the crowd inside grew and grew. People were coming in and out for take out and more people were ordered for dine in. By the time our pizza came, the place was packed with such a diverse mix of people--very representative of the neighborhood.The pizza itself was fantastic. Both the chicken tikka and the beef kabob were delicious. The beef was our favorite and each bite of beef was packed with flavor. Even the crust was perfectly crispy and tasty. Easily my favorite pizza place in the city!"

Main Street Grille

★★★★☆ 4.2 (326) • $$

"Hands-down, the best pizza in the Greenwood area! This photo says it all! My grandson was so excited when this huge pizza was brought to the table. Service is always fast and friendly, the pizza is amazing, made in a wood burning stove in the front!"

Adriatico's

★★★★☆ 3.8 (371) • $$

"I look forward to Adriatico's each time I visit Cincinnati. Terrific, clean, well stocked bar with friendly staff and patrons. Great bar to hang and watch games. I love the thin crusted pizzas. This time had the Spicy Italian pizza, a shot of 1800 Reposado, and a cold draft PBR. Recommend!"

Lennie's

★★★★☆ 4.2 (302) • $$

"Great day to be at Lennie's Brewpub in Bloomington, Indiana. They have great beer, fantastic food, and some great handcrafted sodas made by The Sodaguy! The service is wonderful. They have both indoor and outdoor seating. If you are in the area, check them out!"

Crafters Pizza and Drafthouse

★★★★★ 4.5 (262) • $$

"Crafter's Pizza lives up to all the great hype. We went over to check out the Colts game day specials. When you walk through the door, the aroma of baking pizza dough is intoxicating. The bar/dining room is upscale with lots of tables. We sat in the bar. TV monitors were playing various football games. The bar is locally owned. They offer several Sunday drink specials and I selected the $5 Bloody Mary which comes with a beer chaser. (They really know how to treat a girl). My husband had a craft IPA that was on tap that he liked. John was our server and he was attentive, friendly and helped explain various dishes. He checked on us regularly. The bar was hopping but they seemed to have enough staffing to keep people happy. My husband had a small Grandma's Money pizza. The pizza was top with a delicious blend of sausage, roasted tomatoes, mozzarella balls, prosciutto, pomodoro sauce and more. The crust has a great flavor and texture. I had the BT Wedge salad which is an upscale version of the classic salad. The dressing is fresh made with lots of blue cheese. Two wedges of young romaine are covered with dressing, bacon, roasted tomatoes and pickled onions. The salad is filling and delicious. We loved our visit so much that we joined the Club. Club members get emails describing specials. Parking is a bit cramped in the strip mall."

Pizzology

★★★★☆ 3.9 (347) • $$

"More than thrilled to say the least that this place has finally opened up again. Missed it and the amazing food. I'll give them the benefit of the doubt with this being their second weekend back, but they definitely need to work on the hostess stand and making sure they get people seated when tables become available. Place was packed when we arrived but there were several open tables and no one being seated. Service overall slow tonight, but to reiterate, the place was swamped. Food was amazing though and worth the wait. White Devil pizza and the Pepperoni and Pistachio pizza are what we ordered. Also went with the warm ricotta dip and bread which is always incredible. Music and ambiance were average tonight. Regardless, we'll absolutely be back. Might go with a pickup order next time"

Mug n Bun

★★★★☆ 3.6 (388) • $

"Long time old fashion car hop!!! Food is good...they have a full menu with all sorts of things, we ordered double cheeseburger, chili cheese dogs and onion rings and mugs of homemade root beer!!! Service was great and atmosphere is awesome..definitely family and pet friendly. They have a nice covered area with tables to eat and you can also just pull up and someone will come and take your order. Also a walk in restaurant next door!! Give them a try...we definitely will be going back to try other menu items."

Magoo's California Pizza - Avon

★★★★★ 4.6 (237) • $$

"Fantastic pizza and service ! Chicken Tika with garlic sauce is Fantastic and so was the Supreme !"

Some Guys Pizza Pasta Grill

★★★★☆ 4.2 (279) • $$

"Some Guys is still the best around. Get any wood fired pizza and you will not be disappointed. My favorite is the House Pepperoni and add onion. The pepperoni is very thick and spicy. It goes well with a glass of red Zinfandel. I always love they have local beers on tap and their house salad is one of the best! Try the bbq chicken sandwich. It has smoked Gouda cheese piled on top. Enjoy!"

Ale Emporium

★★★★☆ 3.6 (359) • $$

"Ale is a fan favorite in our household. Between the amount of tvs and yummy food it's hard not to want to watch a game here. Their ranch is the best in the world lol sometimes you will have extremely long wait times so just be aware of what time you're coming (basically depends on who is playing and how big of a game it is)"

Little Miami Brewing Company

★★★★☆ 3.9 (296) • $$

"I really like coming here when I'm on a kayaking trip! It's located right on the river and super close to the bike path, so it's very accessible, but keep in mind if you're kayaking that the hill up to the brewery could be challenging for some. Also, it's quite busy sometimes, but rightfully so! They have fantastic pizza, and the sandwiches are really great too. They have a variety of beers too, and the staff are always happy to help you decide. I like how this place has seating all over. There is ample seating inside, outside at the picnic tables, in lounge chairs overlooking the river or on the roof. I'll definitely be returning in the future."

Pies & Pints

★★★★☆ 3.8 (294) • $$

"My wife and I had dinner today at this location. Our waitress, Riley was the nicest person to wait on us in a long time. We did have a mix up on the order, but the manager made it right and gave us a nice discount. The food was very good. I had a large pizza with mushrooms and half pepperoni's. My wife had a cauliflower pizza with mushrooms and olives. We also had a Caesars salad (Croutons were a little hard). Thanks Pies & Pints for a wonderful dining experience. Hope to see you again soon and I hope Riley and the manager are still there.PS - Dining here can be a little on the expensive side"

New Bethel Ordinary

★★★★☆ 4 (249) • $$

"FOLLOWUP ON MY REVIEWIt's been a few days since my initial review, and I just wanted to add a few afterthoughts to my experience with the large Meatlovers from New Bethel Ordinary. I have had 1 piece each day since. There are 8 triangle slices on the pizza and each one has been enough to satisfy a decent appetite. I heated the slices with an infrared toaster oven, which heats from the inside out. The pizza was $29, including tax. That comes to about $3.63 per slice. If you think about it, that's not particularly cheap. But I must say, each re-heated pie slice has been very good. I have added a couple of pics to show what the leftover slices look like. I wouldn't get this pizza too often, but it really hits the spot once in a while."

Pies & Pints

★★★★☆ 4.1 (229) • $$

"My friend and I paid a visit to Pies and Pints to sample their beers and pizzas. It was right before dinner time the venue wasn't busy - score! First up, we selected a flight of draft beers to share to help us change gears from work. It turns out that they've got a really wide selection of drafts available, so we had trouble narrowing it down to four; with a little input from our very helpful server, we pulled the deed off and then proceeded to order dinner. You can order either pies or slices, so we got a pie to share and a slice each. When the pizza arrived, we dug in; The crust was crispy with a decent amount of chew, and the sauce was pretty good; it had a nice blend of both spicy and sweet flavor, and it wasn't too heavy on the tomatoes. For me, the slice turned out to be a much better choice than the street corn pie we picked. Not that there was anything wrong with the street corn pizza, it's just that the flavor profile of the toppings didn't do it for me. That said, the quality of the crust, the sauce, and the toppings was more than satisfactory, and the beers were great - I look forward to a return visit to try something different!"

Giorgio's Pizza

★★★★☆ 3.9 (252) • $

"After a long and freezing walk around Downtown Indianapolis, this was THE PERFECT end to our night. There was plenty of room to sit and enjoy your pizza. We ordered two white, one sausage and one ham and pepperoni. The crust was outstanding. It was the closest to an NY Pizza I've had recently. Because the pizzas were so good, we ordered a Cannoli - and it was delicious. We were served our orders very quickly. I highly recommend you stop by here if you're in downtown Indianapolis."

Rockstone & Big Lug Taproom

★★★★☆ 4 (237) • $$

"I visited this restaurant during devourindy and I was impressed! I enjoyed every bring except the pie and cheese bread. The pie was too much and the cheese bread tasted bad which is a shocker. The service wasn't bad but it was a little slow. I didn't mind because it was very busy. It's a nice space, music not too loud. I'd visit again for the pizza."

Salvatori's Authentic Italian Eatery - New Haven

★★★★★ 4.6 (175) • $$

"Third time I've stopped at Salvatori's on my way to or from a soccer game in Michigan, and this place never disappoints! The food is always amazing and the atmosphere cozy. On this visit we split a loaded calzone with marinara for dipping. It was cheesy, full of meat, sauce and veggies and super filling. We also split a small house salad - it was so full it spilled over the bowl! Finally we got one of their decadent cinnamon rolls to go - perfect with a cup of coffee later in our hotel room. Don't let the gas station location fool you - Salvatori's is the real deal."

Rockstar Pizza

★★★★☆ 4.1 (205) • $$

"Excellent quality of food and service. The menu has a ton of options, can always find something for everyone. Would highly recommend!"

The Red Pepperoni

★★★★☆ 4.3 (181) • $$

"Delicious pizza place offering both indoor and outdoor seating. The waitstaff proved knowledgeable about the many types of pizza offered here. The pizza arrived at our table hot and tasty . A good beer selection is also available Restrooms are so so. Parking is available in front and along the side street. The ambience is very open."

Local Post East End Eatery

★★★★☆ 3.9 (209) • $$

"So I was in the east end for work and just really wanted a grilled cheese and soup. I looked up to see what was around me and this place popped up. After looking at the menu I decided to try it. Although the grilled cheese is a mix of cheeses (including goat cheese) but I figured it would be ok...I mean who doesn't like goat cheese. I ordered the grilled cheese and tomato soup. The atmosphere was nice...it's has a bar and it's pretty spacious. The food....well it wasn't bad. It was just blah....the soup was very bland and although it sounded good...goat cheese grilled cheese is not a good idea. But I was so hungry I ate it. I would them again but later in the day...like I said it wasn't bad but it wasn't that meal that I was looking for....they were being fancy and what I needed was plain jane"

Lou Malnati's Pizzeria

★★★★☆ 4.2 (178) • $$

"Just like the "Mother Ship" in the Windy City, this Lou Malnati's location serves exceptional Chicago-style pizza. For my money, there's none better!Tip: Not only is the pizza first-class, but there's also ample parking availableThe dining room is warm and inviting, and the staff here are all welcoming and efficient. In addition to their legendary deep-dish pies, Lou's also serves delicious thin-crust pizzas as well :-)"

Krimmer's Italianette Pizzeria

★★★★☆ 3.9 (200) • $

"A perfect little pizza parlor in Cincinnati with charming looks and a cozy atmosphere. The pizza and breadsticks were phenomenal. Hand tossed and hand rolled to perfection. The cheese and pepperoni were high quality. Even the bacon and ham on the Hawaiian was appreciated. The service was a little slow but I can't complain when they had a moderate crowd with tons of takeout orders going out the front. The calzones also looked great at our neighbor table. This is a picture perfect pizza parlor I can happily visit again when in town."