The Most Flavorful Desserts in Indianapolis

Trojan Horse

★★★★☆ 3.6 (248) • $$

"Came here with a friend after not coming here in several years. Food was great, service was quick though being short staffed, and our server was amazing. I order a grilled tenderloin with fries. We also got an appetizer, the Saganaki. So delicious! I will literally return just to eat the Saganaki again! The vibe is nice and quiet. The lower level feels as though you're relaxing with your friends in a basement with music playing. I'd recommend to others for sure!"

Yafa Golden Coffee

★★★★★ 4.8 (66)

"If you're a true coffee snob, try the espresso. Not bad. This review requires 85 more characters to post."

A Smudge Sweeter

★★★★★ 5 (2)

"When a local bakery had to pull out of an event we had scheduled, I scoured the internet for a delicious and festive business to step in. I found A Smudge Sweeter on Instagram, and after admiring all of their beautiful, custom desserts, I sent a message. The owner responded quickly and was able to make 50 cake pops for our party with only a week's notice. Not only did she make cake pops, but they were intricate, incredibly-themed cake pops that brought a lot of fun to our event. The party was right before Thanksgiving, so the cake pops had fun toppers that looked like turkeys, footballs, autumn leaves, etc. They were also delicious, which is sometimes hard to do when they're that beautiful too. You can now order dessert tasting platters from this business, which is definitely the next thing I want to try! Perfect to try out all of their offerings before making a decision on an upcoming gift.... or a fun thing to bring over to a friend's house for a fun night!"

Hyderabad House

★★★★☆ 4.1 (138) • $$

"Great Indian food, huge selection, responsive service, beautiful restaurant at very reasonable prices.There is also a large selection of Desi Chinese dishes and desserts.This may be our go to Indian restaurant now."

Taylor's Bakery

★★★★☆ 4 (98) • $$

"So all things sweet and good you gotta come here! I've been patronizing Taylor's Bakery ever since my oldest daughter's birthday which was in the late 90's and she's a Halloween baby to boo! So now it has come full circle now I went to pick up my granddaughters birthday cake.. it reminded me the days when I would go to pick up her mom's birthday cake! Their cakes are gorgeous and super moist.. and this was completed in 24 hours you can't beat that! It's a little pricey but it's going to be so worth seeing my granddaughter's face.. service there was great everyone was friendly and we had to take advantage of National Donut Day it was buy 6 get 6 free! I really like the Fishers location but I've been to the Allisonville Road location too! So if you're ever in the need for a quick sweet treat Taylor's Bakery is your place!"

Verona Coffee House

★★★★☆ 4.2 (11)

"Extremely friendly staff with great drinks and food. Clean cute study spot or place to hangout with friends!"

Shapiro's Delicatessen

★★★★☆ 4 • $$

"My son and I visited before the Billy Joel / Sting concert. We were able to get parking there as well. Bonus! Shapiro's Deli has a cafeteria feel with plenty of seating and a carry out area for those that want to order and go. I forgot to take pics of our dinners but I had the burger on an egg bun and a side of mac and cheese and deviled eggs. My son got the meatloaf entree that came with 2 sides and bread. We also split a slice of strawberry cheesecake. There was so much food that we couldn't finish it, not that we didn't try. All was great except for the mac and cheese, it was a bit runny. That didn't stop my son from finishing the mac and cheese he got tho. lol. I did get pics of the people waiting in line. The line got sooooo much longer after we entered it, which goes to show that Shapiros is worth the wait. We all could've gone elsewhere and chose to not. Great food but a bit pricey so be sure to check the menu before arriving so that you have a plan if you're trying to stay in a budget."

Bop Bakery

★★★★★ 5 (9)

"This girl is my jam!! She's made several batches of cookies for me and cupcakes. She's super responsive and a great communicator. Not only is she a great person, but the cookies ARE SO GOOD! The best cookies I've ever tasted. She's my go-to for any sort of celebration from here on out!"

Carnitas El Tarasco

★★★★☆ 4.1 (7)

"Tried Carnitas El Tarasco for lunch on Sunday. I love their food! The meat has an amazing flavor and tenderness. I also appreciated how their menu had unique food items that I don't see at other Mexican restaurants in Indy. Their carne asada tacos, guac, and Torta Ahogada (I've only seen this at one other place in Indy) tasted amazing. Definitely coming back for more food! Highly recommend this place for authentic and delicious Mexican Food!"

Casa Brava Authentic Mexican Cuisine

★★★★☆ 3.5 (51) • $$

"Unexpected surprise. Food was fantastic! Had the chorizo and queso as well as the steak fajitas. Lots of good food well prepared."

Smokin Jim's BBQ and Steakhouse

★★★★☆ 3.5 (100) • $$

"Fantastic BBQ!! My husband loves the ribs & I love their burgers!! They have great loaded baked potatoes & other sides. We really love them & they are Christian run, which is really nice."

Sunny's Chicken

★★★★☆ 4.1 (76) • $

"Amazing fried chicken & mushrooms!! Crispy, crunchy, flavorful, just enough seasoning, juicy!!!Mashed potatoes, Mac n cheese, biscuits - huge bummer!! YUCK!!! Biscuits were hard. Potatoes not seasoned and tasted fake and dry - same with Mac and cheese. Also, we ordered extra biscuits and didn't get them. Next time we go here it will be for the chicken and mushrooms and make our own sides."

Tin's House Thai Cuisine

★★★★☆ 4.3 (154) • $$

"We arrived and say the closed sign, but decided to check the door -- and so glad we did! They had forgotten to flip it :)The staff welcomed us in and told us they are Thai Muslims, which was super cool. All of the food is halal :)We were sat quickly and brought waters and this beautiful soup. The flavors were delicate, but not minimal. It was delicious!Kaeng Hoa -- DELIGHTFUL! It was perfectly fried and delicious, but paired with the sambal it was absolutely divine!24 -- pad kee mao -- a personal favorite at all Thai shops. This one is a bit different in that the noodles aren't the big flat ones you'd expect, but still a flat rice noodle. Holy cow! The flavors are tantalizing. 26 -- pad see ewe -- a new adventure! My forever dining partner couldn't resist and absolutely loved it! I tried a bite and it was simply heavenly! Definitely have found our new Thai shop on the west side!"

Diner 67

★★★★☆ 3.9 (16)

"67 Diner is a family restaurant just off an I-69 exit for Anderson. The banners suggest it is new, but it has been in operation for ~one year. The venue is rather plain inside and out, but do not let first impressions fool you. Give them a chance.As I was in the middle of the Pork Tenderloin Belt (central IN and portions of west central & SW OH), I was seeking a classic BPTS. Diner 69 did not disappoint! It arrived hot and huge with the appropriate condiments (mustard) and fresh veggies.I was thrilled with the staff - terrific teamwork. My server was Mackayla. But if she was the least bit busy elsewhere, the others immediately stepped-in to assist. Pay attention to the daily specials on the whiteboard. Bonus: Breakfast is available all day!The dining area and restroom were clean."

Crumbl - Fishers

★★★★☆ 4 (226) • $$

"Quick, efficient. Crumbl. You're getting what you order. No problems ordered many times. Not my type of cookie."

Ugly Crab

★★★★☆ 4 (135) • $$

"This is the best seafood broil I've had in my entire life. And, I love seafood bro, and look for it everywhere. Plus, the price is very acceptable. Do yourself a favor and stop here."

Buy Felicia's Sweet Treats

★★★★★ 5 (5)

"I've tried Buy Felicia's cookies, brownies, cupcakes and cakes...they are very high quality and simply beautiful. The cakes are tall with several layers and rival any of the fancy cake-bakeries around town. The Lemon Blueberry cake is my favorite with snickerdoodle cookies and banana muffins a close second. I highly recommend checking out Buy Felicia's sweet treats if you want a beautiful cake made with love."

Paper Street Bakery

★★★★★ 5 (3)

"Cute bakery. Variety of different baked goods. My boys loved their iced cookie & gingerbread cookies. Things were well priced. The store was clean. We enjoyed visiting and would stop back in when we are in Liberty."

BRU Burger Bar

★★★★☆ 4.3 (17) • $$

"We had a fabulous Happy Hour visit to Bru Burger at Keystone. I met friends that I hadn't seen in a while. The restaurant is upscale inside with high ceiling and cozy booths. Terra, our server, was 5 star welcoming, friendly, engaging and attentive. She made recommendations and with a great sense of humor. We sat for three hours, talked, giggled, and never felt rushed. We ordered several signature cocktails. I had a Pear Cosmo, which was delicious. I also had a Spicy Pomegranate Margarita, which as absolutely fabulous, and my favorite. (Drinks are $3 off during Happy Hour). We shared a huge platter of BBQ Nachos, which were fresh with lots of toppings including guacamole. The hand battered Onion Rings were addictive with the airy batter and sweet onions and included house made fresh spicy ketchup. The Bru Board was ok with a selection of cheese and salamis. The tomato jam on the Bru Board and pimiento cheese were our favorites on the board. The apps are half priced during happy hour, so it was our chance to try a lot of different things. Bru Burger is a member of the Cunningham Group of restaurants so you can get points on your VIP card. The restaurant had nice outdoor seating for warmer weather. They are located on a side road, so you don't have to be in the crazy Keystone traffic. There is plenty of parking including very close handicapped. I'd return in a heartbeat. So good."

Xchocol'Art

★★★★★ 4.9 (28)

"Really great chocolates! Got the "world tour" 18 piece pack and every type was amazing! Good to know the owners handmake these and they're dealt kind. Located in the arts district of Carmel, the place is really pretty! All around great service."

Hickory Hillz BBQ

★★★★☆ 4.2 (131) • $

"Wow. This place has good bbq! Not to mention great sides. I smoke my own meat and make my own pulled pork so I'm very picky. Their pulled pork was just okay but my husband really enjoyed.I had the burnt end sandwich and it was a 5 out of 5. I just did not expect it to come saucy but very good. We called at 11:30 AM on a Saturday and they were already sold out of brisket. We arrived about 12 noon and had to wait a good 15 minutes just to order. This place is busy! And for good reason. My favorite part might be the smoked barbecue beans and spicy coleslaw. Will be back a lot!"

Katch the Kitchen

★★★★☆ 3.5 (21)

"Great atmosphere, food and customer service. Pam was an awesome server. We ordered salmon and grits with a side of French toast. Perfectly cooked to order and arranged. We will definitely return."

Walk-On’s Sports Bistreaux - Fishers, IN

★★★★☆ 4 (91) • $$

"We've been here several times now and wish it was still downtown but definitely worth the drive to Fisher's.Before you arrive, try to review the online menu. Many different options from traditional Louisiana specialties to Alligator tacos.We walked in and immediately seated in a requested booth. The hostess was pleasant, efficient and great at multi-tasking. Our server, Ryan, arrived moments after we were seated. He never missed a step, observant, checked on us several times but never intruded, was knowledgeable about the menu and a pleasure to have as our server.My husband ordered the Red Beans and Smoked Sausage which he devoured. I ordered the Grilled Blackened Catfish with grilled shrimp, smothered in delicious Etouffee. It was so scrumptious, I didn't want it to disappear. I did manage to save a small portion to have later tonight as a snack. It isn't spicy but if you enjoy spicy, the kitchen will accommodate you.The restaurant atmosphere is a fun sports bar with flat screens everywhere. The separate bar is a great place to dine and watch a game with tall-top tables and bar seating.It is a full service bar serving specialty cocktails, draft beer plus bottled/can beers.We love the food, great service, perfect location for viewing sporting events and nice spot for larger groups."

Frida's Paleteria y Neveria

★★★★★ 4.6 (8)

"I stopped by here for the first time the other day. You cannot see inside from the parking lot windows are kind of covered which is ashame because inside is really cute decorated. They have seating and u just go up to the counter to order. I got there and there was no one around I was the only person there. I thought someone would come out from the back and help me. Well I stood there for a long time and finally had to say hello as to calling someone to help and nothing. Kept hearing someone doing something in the back. I had to yell out again hello and nothing i almost walked out of there. I was going to say hello again when the lady finally came out to help me. Didn't even apologize for me having to wait. She was pretty serious like if I was interrupting her. I asked for a raspado well she said they didn't have any at the time it was around 3pm oh well then I just went with an Agua Fresca pepino with chia it was really good. There's plenty of parking in front of the store. Might come again to give it another chance, I love supporting hispanic businesses hopefully there's better customer service next time."

The Monk's

★★★★☆ 4.4 (137) • $$

"Fantastic place. Surprising find up in Indiana. Food is top quality, I had a classic chicken tikka masala and found every single delightful flavor and texture within. Nothing missing. Service is quick and friendly. Dining area is a bit grey and high ceiling, I prefer things a bit cozier but some find that professional and modern."

TeeJay's Sweet Tooth

★★★★★ 4.8 (277) • $$

"We all scream for TeeJay's!! Plenty of choices to choose from! Friendly service! And uniquely delicious ways to enjoy your ice cream! Went here for birthday desert and was not disappointed! I cannot believe how fresh and tasty the ice cream was! The mouth feel and the flavors are just to scream for! Please do your tastebuds a favor and swing by you won't let them down! The interior is simple and the vibes it gives off are just right!"

India Garden Restaurant

★★★★☆ 3.6 (242) • $$

"We enjoyed our lunch here this past week. The chicken tikki was spot on, the tandoori was yummy as well. The veggie dish was just sparse, they need to put more veggies in it and a little less sauce. We enjoyed the naan and they give you PLENTY as well as a big dish of rice. We're not big on carbs, but If you are.... You're all set!Service was good, we had ice teas as well. Lunch was about $30 for both meals."

LICK SoBro

★★★★★ 4.7 (43)

"Truly my favorite ice cream in Indy. I'm someone who can't have much sugar or dairy and... even I can't resist LICK ice cream. First of all, it's made with all organic dairy and every flavor is made from scratch. You're getting real, high-quality ingredients here. They also always have a vegan option that is surprisingly creamy for not having dairy. Score!I'll never forget the first flavor I ever tried here: mint chocolate chip. I couldn't believe how much better it was than any I've ever had. I didn't know that such a traditional flavor could taste so above and beyond what I was used to. Over time, I've branched out and tried their unique flavor combinations, with my new favorite being the brown butter cookie dough. They also have a hot cocoa ice cream float -- the perfect winter ice cream treat.Other flavors I need to try: + Gingersnap lemon curd+ Rosewater pistachio brittle + Champagne and berries+ Gorgonzola candied pecan (one of their most popular flavors!)+ Cedar and whiskey with local West Fork Whiskey + Vegan chocolate marshmallowI mean... is your mouth watering now?! Owner Meredith crushes it and you're going to absolutely love every flavor you try. They used to be located in the CCIC building downtown and make ice cream for local restaurants. Now, they have a location in The Garage Food Hall off of Mass Ave and just opened up in this cute little blue house on 54th and The Monon. They have a single free parking spot out front and two or three free parking spots off to the right side of the building. There are two small bar stools inside, but this spot is mostly for takeout, which is great because you can enjoy your ice cream while on a nice stroll down The Monon. They also have pints and half pints to take home!"

Quality Ingredients Cooking

★★★★★ 5 (2)

"They catered our 25th Anniversary. Top notch and priceless! I highly recommend them for a priceless experience."

Burro Loco

★★★★☆ 4.2 (127) • $$

"Awesome salsa, good food, GREAT margarita and good service. This place had a great atmosphere. As what Gen. MacArthur said, I will return."

Aroma Indian Cuisine and Bar

★★★★☆ 4.2 (230) • $$

"The food was quite bland and lackluster. A drink menu was provided but then told that they have almost none of the drinks available. Lastly, the lampshades in the dining room were absolutely filthy. Completely caked in dust and grime."

La Michoacana - Paleteria

★★★★★ 4.7 (38) • $

"One of my favorite ice cream shops! Creamy ice cream and so many flavors! They even have light food options. The service is great!"

RJS Tacos & Burritos

★★★★☆ 4.1 (49) • $

"I eat these tacos every Friday. I get American style shrimp tacos on corn tortillas. I love them. It's delicious and very filling. They are speedy and offer delivery and pick up options."

Carl's Donuts & Bakery

★★★★☆ 4.2 (69)

"Carl's is a locally-owned combination cafe and donut shop located in a little strip mall in Avon. The donuts are no secret as we followed a line of cars into the parking lot on a Sunday morning. There was a line of people waiting patiently to select their donuts when we walked in. There were many cases filled with fresh donuts, fritters, danish, turnovers and more. Two clerk were assisting customers, most of whom were buying several dozen donuts. I got a glazed donut and my husband got an apple fritter. The fritter was bigger than his head. My glazed donut was a cake donut. It was light with a perfect glaze. The apple fritter was like a coffee cake with lots of apples and a glazed topping. He shared the fritter with our granddaughters. There was plenty to go around. The cafe serves breakfast, lunch and dinner. They have daily meal specials. The lady in line ahead of us said the pork tenderloin is the best in town. Pork tenderloin is only served Monday-Thursday. We'll have to come back. They have about 20 tables for eat-in dining. There is a unisex restroom. Stop #4 of the donut trail will require a return visit."

Shake & Dough

★★★★★ 4.7 (7)

"YUMMY!! I've been here a few times. I try to go each time I'm at the Greenwood Mall. They're usually pretty busy, unfortunately. However, the shakes are SO GOOD! Being that they're handmade you can taste the freshness. I've also had the cookie dough, which was great as well but it's just so sweet and the scoops are pretty large. I would highly recommend this place!"