The Most Flavorful Delis in Indianapolis

Fat Dan's Deli

★★★★☆ 4.2 (551) • $$

"Showed up trying to kill some time with a craving for a burger and a beer. Saw the menu and immediately changed my mind. There's a lot on the menu that sounded great but I ended up pulling the trigger on a house smoked reuben with fries. The fries are addicting. So addicting I considered ordering more to go but I couldn't muster up a way to reheat them without losing the magic. There's random sides of a potato mixed in with like what you'd see in waffle fries. Little treasures like finding an onion ring in your fries as a young kid. The reuben had the thickest cut corned beef I've seen. The beef is the star on this bad boy, not overwhelmed with sauce or kraut. I think the thick cut beef helps hold the sandwich together better since it isn't a mountain of piled up meat equating to a lopsided sandwich. The food came out quick. Fries were fresh af and piping hot. Definitely coming back. There is too much on the menu that caught my eye not to."

Ripple Bagel & Deli

★★★★★ 4.5 (437) • $

"Ripple Bagel & Deli is a locally owned deli that has been in Broad Ripple since the 1970's. Their sandwiches are made on their freshly made (in-house) bagels. The shop is eclectic, with a cool neighborhood vibe. When I stopped by, the tables were full except for one that I snagged. The place was hopping. I ordered and paid at the counter. They had a huge assortment of plain, breakfast sandwiches and lunch sandwich options, including veggie options. I chose the Five-0, consisting of bacon, cream cheese on an onion bagel. Most of the bagels are steamed to keep them soft and chewy. My sandwich was ready in 10 minutes. The Five-0 was warm and delicious with lots of crispy bacon and a great bagel. I could eat these everyday. The clerk was super friendly and helpful. He described how the bagels were prepped and offered me a hard copy of the menu. They serve coffee as well. Prices are reasonable. Parking in Broad Ripple is limited and metered. I found parking about a block away and dropped all my change into the meter. I'll be stopping every time I'm in BR."

Love Handle

★★★★☆ 4.3 (379) • $$

"Love Handle is a trendy cafe that serves breakfast, lunch and dinner on the north end of Mass Ave. The dining room is colorful with the walls decorated in vintage paint by number art and other quirky items. The bright yellow and green vinyl seating is fun and comfortable. The menu is on a chalk board near the counter where you order. The best way to describe the good is Southern-inspired. I wanted to try the biscuit sliders that were in other Yelp reviews but they were not on the menu. I asked and the clerk said they could make some for us, the sliders are $7 each. The sliders came out in about 12 minutes served on vintage mismatched plates. I loved the sliders. The fried oyster biscuit slider was delicious. The oysters were juicy and had a lot of flavor with a light breading. The biscuits are salty, flaky and very good. There was a sauce on the oysters and melted cheese. The beef brisket biscuit slider was very good. There were two thick slices of tender brisket, melted cheese, a delicious sweet jam on one of their signature biscuits. The meat was slightly fatty, but good. They serve coffee, tea and assorted bottled and canned beverages, including beer. There are a few games around to play while you drink your coffee. There is metered street parking out front."

The Gruff

★★★★☆ 4.1 (381) • $$

"We received a $10 off meal coupon as a gift and decided to check this place out. We are so glad that we did. First let me share that everything is homemade at this establishment and that makes it extra special for me. Knowing that they take that extra step means a lot. Our server was extremely knowledgeable and helpful. As a teacher it's his second job to help support his family, I appreciated how he made us feel welcomed and how he provided us with insight about the restaurant and their food. Clean, busy and friendly is how I would sum it up. Good food and drinks. We will return too!"

Rise 'n Roll Bakery

★★★★★ 4.5 (199) • $

"Rise n Roll has friendly staff and delicious options. We love to get their homemade butters and jams. And their donuts. And their pies. And and and....They really do have delicious food. The donuts are my personal favorite as they offer so many different kinds. I don't have a personal favorite but I will say that of the word "crunch" or the words "peanut butter" are in the names, you simply can't go wrong. Bought two dozen for family who were visiting from out of state and each one was a hit. We WILL be back!"

Illinois Street Food Emporium

★★★★☆ 4.2 (194) • $$

"This neighborhood gem has been around for many years, and is still well-loved by the locals! I dropped in one day to do a bit of work and have brunch. I stood in line to order and had a nice conversation with a woman who said her swim group came here after their class at the Rivi. It was just before lunch and the place was hopping! I ordered at the counter and sat down with my number, only to wait a few minutes before my food was delivered. I chose the Greek scrambler at the recommendation of the very sweet employee taking my order. It was served with fresh fruit and two slices of wheat toast. For the price, it was definitely a deal, and the eggs were cooked perfectly to my liking. The fruit was indeed fresh and sweet, and the coffee was flavorful. They have a bakery case with cookies/pastries and a coffee bar. Also, the nice woman I talked with raved about their prepared meals in the refrigerated case by the door. They had quiches, soups, meals, even flatbread pizzas to go! Everything was very reasonably priced, as well. The dining area was quite clean and there were no tables in need of bussing.I'm definitely going to return to try a couple of their prepared items at my next visit!"

Titus Bakery & Deli

★★★★☆ 4.4 (167) • $

"Titus serves more than delicious donuts. They serve deli sandwiches using Boar's Head meats and freshly made rolls. This was my first visit to the Westfield location of this local chain. Getting in to the strip mall off SR32 is a little challenging because you have to use an access road. There is a drive-up or you can ho inside and see all the award-winning colorful donuts and confectioneries. The staff is friendly and efficient. You order at the counter and wait for your sandwich. You pick the sandwich all the ingredients that you want on the sandwich.They have 8 tables and seat about 20 people. There is also a room for private parties or meetings. I sip coffee as I wait for my sandwich. The coffee is self-serve and good. My Roast Beef sandwich is good. The bread is fresh and the tomato actually is thick and has flavor. The banana peppers and tangy mayonnaise add flavor to my perfect sandwich. They make beautiful birthday cakes and host kid's birthday parties in their private room. Parties include a magic show and kid's decorate their own donuts."

Quatman Cafe

★★★★☆ 4 (201) • $

"It's crazy to see that my last review was over ten years ago! While the price of the cheeseburger special has gone up (only by $2.50) and they've moved their location (just slightly) the food and experience is still the same no frills deliciousness.They have indoor and outdoor dining now and they let you order lettuce and tomato on your burger, but you still get your food on paper plate and the burger special still comes with fries and a drink of choice (including a beer if you want). The burger with onions and pickles is the way to go and it's delicious every time. I have never tried anything else here and I don't know if I ever will. It's exactly what I want and while I know people love the other items on the menu it's hard not to order the cheeseburger when I know it's perfection.If you've never been, they do have a parking lot along with street parking. The servers are friendly and helpful too. You'll see a lot of regulars here as well as families.This one of those old school, welcoming spots that feels like dining at a family member's place for a get together- especially now that they have the outdoor seating. It is no frills, but what they do they do well and at a great price.We stop by at least once every time we're in town."

The Beehive

★★★★☆ 4.4 (107) • $

"The Beehive in Danville is usually our first stop in town. We pick up lattes and choose from their wide variety of breakfast sandwiches or BYO salads (chicken salad is best!), and then walk over to the square to window shop. Service is always friendly and food is above average!Not getting food? There's also a cooler section with take-home meals and a small apparel/gift section with a cute honey bee theme!"

The Homestead

★★★★★ 4.8 (76)

"Breakfast Croissant 10/10!First time here and it didn't disappoint. I got some to go items and a hot meal as well. I'll definitely be back. This place is the perfect place to go if you want meals frozen for a gift."

Dagwood's Deli

★★★★☆ 3.7 (116) • $

"I have been here quite a few times and it never disappoints!! I got the Dagwood on wheat it was delicious. My husband got a turkey sandwich on their amazing fresh, warm sub bread. I thought it was very nice! (just not as good as mine) Their drink cups are a cute little souvenir. Yes the place is old. Yes it looks a little dingy. There is a reason it has been around for so long...give it a try!"

Myers' Market

★★★★★ 4.7 (58) • $

"This business is a combo of small market, butcher shop, and deli with dine in seating. The west end of the shop is devoted to a seating area while the east end is filled with displays of local products including canned items (jellies etc.) and candies. They also have some fresh bread and baked items.The left side of the market has the meats and cheeses available to order. They had several folks working behind the counter to be able to keep up with the customers. I had already eaten before stopping in here to shop, so I passed on getting a sandwich or soup. I find it quite ingenious to offer lunch meals as a way to supplement the market when a lot of folks don't have the devices necessary to keep meats fresh in their offices if they shop at lunch. Maybe seeing the counters full of great looking options may bring them back for a purchase before dinner.Review #3628"

Cincy Gourmet Deli

★★★★☆ 4.4 (61)

"A little piece of New York in Cincinnati! If you've ever visited New York, you know how great the Bodegas are. Well, luckily we have one right here in Clifton! This place has everything you can imagine from salads to sandwiches to cheesesteaks. My personal favorite is the pesto panini. There are so many options for drinks as well. It is a perfect stop for a quick lunch or a light dinner. Highly recommend!"

Silverglades on 8th

★★★★☆ 3.9 (75) • $

"You guys never cease to amaze me. I love how delicious the sausage and peppers are. When you eat it slowly it's like eating a work of art. The ambience is very nice and the place is always jammed packed. You've to get there early to avoid the big line ups. The meals are affordable and worth trying. I remember I once had a deli sandwich and it was out of this world. If you're looking for a different place to try I recommend this place very highly! I'm recommending this place to all my friends."

Midday Gourmet Deli & Catering

★★★★★ 4.5 (50) • $

"This deli has been sitting in this little strip mall for quite some time even when nothing else was there. They have a daily special usually a sandwich or wrap with a soup of choice. Typically have 4-6 soups available everyday. I usually go with the special because they all have been pretty good. But you have plenty of sandwich, salad and soup options if that special of the day is not your jam."

Bodega

★★★★☆ 3.9 (61) • $

"First visit and was a nice one too! The quaint storefront in uptown for a start. But also friendly service and a good sandwich value as well. Parking is my meter in front of their business. It's tiny inside with a few tables that will likely be occupied by Miami University students. None of the tables were being wiped down and all of the napkins were depleted. They had ample supply statue register.Order at the counter after reviewing the menu board.on the wall. It's a smallish menu that works well for them. They also open for breakfast which is newer post COVID. I got a hot pastrami on white and my daughter grilled cheese on white. Sandwiches come with a bag of chips. They offer fountain Coke product drinks and bottled. The joint has a NY Deli vibe which I like. With only three total staff, likely all students it was a bit slow on pulling the orders together. However I was not in a hurry either. The orders popped up 15 min or so and I paid at that time. Tip is off the machine. My daughter really liked her sandwich with fresh bread and gooey American cheese. The plating was no frills. Mine was very good as well with only complaint a section of fatty meat that should not have been used. In my opinion the sandwich should be served cut in half. The chips were good too!I can see myself being back on future visits. 3.5 rounding up."

New York Gourmet Deli

★★★★★ 4.5 (26)

"Stellar fresh ingredients and kind service. Easy to order, quick service, it reminded me of a NY bodega."

Banter's Fresh Meats

★★★★★ 4.5 (23)

"Just one look at the photo and you can see this Butcher shop has very nice selections of Beef, Pork and Chicken. Their prices seem reasonable and the staff is very nice. They offer a unique a blueberry maple syrup breakfast sausage patty, which I'll try at some point too. What a nice butcher shop! It all looks really good!"

Horner's Butcher Block

★★★★☆ 4.4 (21) • $$

"Great selection of deli meats and specialty foods. They even have a good selection of cheeses and pickles. A great butcher shop with good selection of ham, roast beef, ground beef and other meats. This is the best butcher shops in the area.P.S. I have been here numerous times in 2017 as well and plan on coming back even more."

Eve’s Garden Deli

★★★★★ 4.9 (16)

"I absolutely love this place! its soooo delicious! The service is exceptional and the husband and wife team is a dynamic duo. I always get Lamar's Sweet Chicken Sandwich and it's scrumptious. The Sauce on there is divine! Y'all have to try it if you love it's combination and have a sweet and spicy palate."

Jersey Mike's Subs

★★★★☆ 3.9 (19)

"Yet another Mike's I just had to check out because I'm on a roll collecting rewards points and entering their basketball trivia sweepstakes. Every order via the app gets you another entry for their free trip to the Final Four in Houston. This location is just a tad smaller than the other places I have visited. I was here during the noon hour and the dining seating was still more than adequate. Today I tried a "bowl." Yes, you can order a sub sandwich without the bun and get the insides in a bowl which is rectangle in shape. You can save half the calories and even more on carbs. A #17 regular is 710 calories while a bowl is only 430 calories per the app. It is the way to go for me since I watch my waistline religiously especially after buying all new smaller size clothing ;-)My meal was excellent as usual. I do have to eat it quickly because without the bun the meat cools off faster sitting on a bed of cold lettuce. Hey Mike's, if your reading this, figure out a way to make the lettuce warmer for the bowls. In addition to the usual Chocolate Chip Cookies offered, they also have Snicker Doodles and Brownies all from the same company, David's Cookies. An employee said their brownies are very popular. I have not seen the brownies in the other stores. One thing do I like seeing is that in addition to keeping their tables clean and wiped down often they also restock the chips racks. I see this attention to detail at every location I been to so far which is four so far and counting."

Fridge & Pantry

★★★☆☆ 3.3 (25)

"They handled a busy weekend really well! Food was great! Worth the wait! We will go back on our next visit!"

Jersey Mike's Subs

★★★★☆ 4.3 (8)

"I love Jersey Mikes. I have an intolerance to gluten and they have gluten free bread for subs however I can have a little gluten so I choose the wraps. I do wish they would get gluten free wraps. You might want to start toasting gf bread as it makes it taste better. I digress, the service is always good and the restaurant clean. I always take my sandwich to go and never have to wait."

The Corner Deli

★★★★★ 4.8 (6)

"As a New Yorker I approve!! New to Ohio the pizza is for real I love that they sell by the slice! Love to support local business and the owner is a great guy. Can't wait to try a sub"

Jersey Mike's Subs

★★★★★ 5 (4)

"Freshest of subs and anything Mikes Way has that east coast traditional flavor! Love Jersey Mikes!"

Jersey Mike's Subs

★★★★☆ 3.5 (8)

"Ordering online for pickup was convenient and it was ready at the time promised. The food was accurate and included my sandwich modifications. They have two vegetarian options, a cold veggie sandwich and hot portobello sandwich. The cold veggie sandwich on rosemary parmesan bread was great with fresh swiss and provolone cheese. Employees were friendly, even while being busy."

Cousins Subs

★★★☆☆ 2.5 (15)

"We had the fried cheese curds. Perfect lightly crispy on the outside and delightful because CHEESE."