Cozy seating
Coffee menu
16oz Cold Brew Coffee
food
Interior
Outdoor seating
S'mores cookie
Hours
March coffee/dessert flight
a neon sign that says but first coffee
Coffee Flight
Menu
My blueberry lemon scone.
Coffee flight with oat creamer. Blueberry muffin.
Coffee Flight
Briskets and gravy
Blueberry scone
Pastries
Yummy HUGE cinnamon roll!!
food
Justin C.
Jan 25, 2025
Butter Sugar Flour may look small from the outside, but it has a warm and inviting atmosphere that makes it worth the visit. The service was incredibly friendly and attentive, making our experience even better.I had a regular black coffee, and it was excellent--rich and well-balanced. We also tried the vanilla bourbon iced coffee, which was easily one of the best we've had. To top it off, the cinnamon roll was delicious, perfectly baked with just the right amount of sweetness.Even though it was a bit of a drive for us, we'd gladly make the trip again to support this fantastic local business over a chain like Starbucks. The added convenience of a drive-through is a nice touch for those on the go. Overall, a great experience, and we'll definitely be back!
Read More
Katherine A.
Aug 21, 2024
Wow! The pastries are amazing. That may be an understatement. Beautiful, huge, artistic. I couldn't decide what to get. Everything is made fresh in-house. The bagels - fresh. Croissants- fresh. Scones - fresh. And more. I settled on a blueberry lemon scone. They also make trendy coffees. I was coffeed out for the day, so I didn't try. Kaitlyn, the clerk, said they'd warm my scone while I took a seat. The dining area is small and cozy. There were a couple people working and sipping lattes. The scone was incredible with a wonderful glaze drizzle. It was the best scone I've ever had. It is as filled with large blueberries and a hint of lemon. The shop is cute. There's outside seating if you don't mind the sounds of the highway. They have a drive through that is popular. This shop is a definite plus for Trafalgar and an easy 5 star. I'll be stopping frequently.
Read More
Christina B.
Jun 11, 2024
Very small shop in Trafalgar, IN. The shop is very small but cozy with some local wares available for purchase. They have convenient parking and a drive thru.My daughter went for a chocolate croissant, blueberry muffin and a coffee. All items were executed well and tasty. We would visit again if in the area.
Read More
Danielle M.
Mar 26, 2023
I visited BSF with my mom. We split the coffee/dessert flight. The flight was definitely on the sweeter side. As someone who enjoys the taste of coffee, there wasn't much coffee flavor in the flight. We really enjoyed the Andes Mint ice cream.Inside, it is very small with limited seating. We found some chairs that were in front of the fireplace. It was cozy. The staff was very helpful, as it was our first time visiting and we had some questions about the menu.We didn't get any pastries, but the ones displayed looked very good. Especially the large cinnamon roll.If I go back, I'm going to skip out on the coffee flight and get a latte instead.
Read More
Kelly S.
Mar 12, 2023
This is the cutest little bakery and coffee shop in Trafalgar! I saw the coffee flights (which also come with a dessert option) and even though I don't like coffee, they were so pretty and visually appealing, I stopped in to try them. While the Irish Creme was too strong for my taste, the Andes Mint and Lucky Charms had a really nice flavor! I also really enjoyed the orange dreamsicle immensely and thank them for subbing that in for the pineapple that usually comes with it - that's exceptional customer service!I can't wait to go back and try some baked goods. Definitely make a trip in there, even if you live outside the area.
Read More
Dannelle P.
Feb 16, 2023
A group of friends stopped at this cute little coffee shop on a road trip. It's small and cozy. We were greater with warm smiles and the batista answered all of our questions. I ordered the iced coffee flight and a warm blue berry muffin. My friend got the cinnamon roll that was HUGE, definitely shareable and so good!!!! Make sure you check this place out.
Read More
Erin Lee R.
Nov 12, 2023
This place is cute, cute, cute! Small and sweet and just right for a catch-up coffee and pastry with a friend! Not a lot of seating, but we went during off-peak hours and had no problems finding a place to sit. Delish!
Read More
Ashley H.
Feb 15, 2023
Quaint little space with a homey personality They have a variety of coffees - and I loved every one that was on the coffee flight! The cinnamon roll was so big and enough for 2 people. It came out warm, and the icing was melt in your mouth. My friend had the blueberry muffin and it was the same way - SO MANH BLUEBERRIES If you don't have enough time to stop in they have a drive thru that is super convenient. Last but not least, THE STAFF! So friendly and helpful and took their time explaining the different coffees!
Read More
Billie O.
Sep 28, 2023
The pastries are fabulous. The drinks are great. The atmosphere is gorgeous and the service is wonderful.
Read More
Jake C.
May 27, 2023
We tried the s'mores cookies, blueberry scone, brisket and gravy, as well as ordered a coffee flight, which comes with 4 types of coffees paired with a small food item! The service was excellent and fast. The shop is beautiful inside with with an awesome homey feel. I will visit here every time I'm in this area!
Read More