Buck Creek Pizza - Dayton Station

I visited this pizza joint for lunch on a recommendation from a local while working in town. There's not a lot to choose from in Dayton Indiana and I was in the mood as usual for something different. Upon entering the establishment I immediately was drawn to the rustic feel of the interior and I immediately felt welcome. You place your order at the counter and the menu is overhead. They have daily specials along with a nice selection of pizza, wings, sandwiches and appetizers. I had pizza the night before so I went for the Stromboli and garlic bread and cheese. I can tell you that everyone who entered after me ordered pizza. A gentleman came out of the back and spoke with me while I was waiting on my food and he inquired what I ordered and he raves about how good the pizza is and that I should of orders one since it's my first time in. I assume he's the owner but I never confirmed. He was super nice and very friendly. The food arrived and my garlic bread was absolutely delicious. The Stromboli was the classic Sausage, onion and sauce on a toasted hoagie bun. Neither one disappointed!

We had 10"pepperoni pizza with extra cheese and breadsticks with cheese. No complaints at all about the food. Was delicious!!!Not much space inside but that's not bad unless you have a big group.

Really solid pizza! Such a neat pizza place with super friendly people. We ordered the 10" deluxe pizza and it was overflowing with very fresh toppings! I also liked that they had jars of Parmesan and hot pepper flakes at the table. The fountain drinks were also good. If you are in the area it is a must eat at pizza place!

Amazing pizza!!!! Love the BBQ pizza. Good service. Orders have always been on time.

Dayton Station has awesome pizza! Our favorite is their Italian sausage pizza. It was gone before I could get a picture. Super thick and loaded with meat, cheese, and sauce.

Our family really enjoys getting take out from this local pizza joint! Over multiple visits the pizzas, dough boys, and wings we have ordered have all been delicious every time. If you're a sauce person and debating on ranch or bleu cheese or one of each, go with double ranch! The staff is always polite and working hard. Thank you, Keep up the great work!

We ordered a small deluxe pizza tonight. Knew we overpaid with delivery. Included a tip for driver. Husband said what kind of pizza is this. No pepperoni or bacon. Saw sprinkles of sausage. Couldn't taste pizza sauce . I asked for no black olives so that part was correct. Sad to say we won't be ordering from Buck Creek anytime soon as the last time we ordered was two years ago. It came warm and edible. Who ever purchases this pizza place could take it far . Maybe less menu choices would allow better ingredients for a menu staple.

Best Pizza you're going to find in the Lafayette/Dayton area by far!!!! I'm a Chicago style pizza lover, but since Lafayette doesn't have that kinda pizza here, Buck Creek is the closest and next best thing! I'm telling you, ya gotta try it. Keep up the good work B.C. Pizza!

My go to place for a great pizza when I'm in Lafayette! Pizza is very good, sometimes a bit inconsistent but usually doesn't affect the quality of the pie.

The food is always great here, but it seems like most of the people that work there are rude.