Brockway Pub

Where do you go on a fine soft day in late December In Indiana to watch the game and grab a hearty meal? Brockway Pub. Super delicious. The chops hit the spot with the braised cabbage and colcannon. There is more than enough (yay! Breakfast). Guinness take a bit and are the perfect temperature. Find a seat. The server will find you and you well fed and hydrated. There are enough TVs all tuned to the Colts. Tuesday is session night. Go a listen or join it on trad Irish music by the folks just looking to play together. Släinte!

Service was bad, food ok, ambiance nothing to write home about. I know this review is rather brief but why spent more time thinking about a very forgettable dinning experience

This is one of my favorite Irish pubs in Indy and one of the best places to go for a Guinness. When we stopped in, we also ordered the Scotch Eggs. Talk about deliciousness!! Thee might be the best Scottish Eggs I've had! They were crispy in the outside and bursting with flavor. The staff was friendly and attentive. I'm a fan of all the decor too. We go here most times we're on the north side.

Stopped in to one of my favorite Irish pubs in Indy for a tasty pint of Guinness. While here, we had the scotch eggs, which are some of the best I've had!!! The staff is friendly and attentive and always a good conversation with fellow patrons. If you're in the area, you definitely need to stop in!

Went here after dinner with friends to catch the IU vs. Purdue game. The amount of tv's was great and the people and atmosphere where nice and not to loud or crowded. It is a smaller place as seen from the pics but it ads to the ambiance. The only issue we had which is my fault for not checking my bill before I gave the server my card was being charged for a drink I never got. I only had ordered a whiskey on the rocks and cider so how she lost count of the amount of drinks I had stumps me but be it as it may overall a decent place.

Purchased a gift certificate via Fox59 to try the place out as a family [myself, wife, 22 y/o daughter & 19 y/o son]. Felt it was unique in its decor & layout compared to other options around. It was seat yourselves and we probably should have chosen a larger table for our group of 4, but we liked the character of our little booth and stools that was just off of the bar. Our server was very pleasant and attentive, quickly finding the answers to our questions such as if Smithwick's was included in the daily pint special (it was). We found the music selection peculiar, or at least not committed to the Irish vibe. Assume it appeals to some demographic, maybe younger, but not my wife and I so much. Daughter knew the music, but she said we heard the same song twice apparently within the hour+ that we were there.Sampled the fish bites, eggs, and pickle chips appetizers. Egg option was unique, son liked it a lot although not sure I personally would order again. Pickle chips were pretty good, we would consider them on a future visit. Fish was fine, although I assume it was just a 'nugget' version of the standard fish & chips. Probably wouldn't do it again.Daughter ordered chicken sandwich with dublin chips. She enjoyed the sandwich and really liked her cheesy chips. Son went with Reuben and fries. Thought fries were OK, sandwich was good but probably preferred the Reuben at Muldoon's. Wife and I each did the fish wrap, she with the plain chips and me with the fries. Both enjoyed the wrap with its grilled cod and would do it again. Also both preferred the chips she ordered, but felt they needed a bit more seasoning or flavor.Very much appreciated the happy hour & daily specials on a Monday [1/2 off appetizers, $4 or $5 (?) pints, $8 handhelds]. Would definitely entertain a return for the same specials offers. Son likes Premiere League and is very interested in returning for future soccer viewing.

I've been to Brockway twice now, and evaluating this restaurant reminds me of one of the taglines used in the 1990's TV show The X-Files - "I want to believe...". I want Brockway to be my go-to source for the Pub experience. I want very badly for the food to impress me. I want the service to be great. The problem is, those things never really materialize. The ambiance is certainly great, and the location on Old Meridian is a prime spot. But, that's where the fun stops. Bangers & Mash is usually something I get very excited about, but here, the dish lacked excitement. I'm sure we'll probably be back again. I came very close to just doing three stars, to avoid seeming negative. But, two is all I could muster here. I'll come again, and I'll branch out on the menu a little. But I'm not getting my hopes up.

I wanted to try something new for st paddy's this year and let's just say what I expected wasn't at all what I received ! The service and ambiance was no friendly and just ok they only were service st paddy's day menu with a very select menu ! I got the shepads pie served in a paper tray no served with a single side for $19 and my friend a sandwich and fires for $15 ! I do give them grace as it is the busiest few days for them but I wish server would have been friendly asking if we needed other things with more flavor for food and served on a plate ! The manager did take care of my concerns which I appreciate not sure I would choose to return for lunch maybe after st paddy's day to try other menu items definetely a bar vibe

Food menu was disgusting and sticky with old food or drinks. Guinness on tap is a plus, I've had better and worse pours at other places. Everything was beyond salty except for the fries with 0 seasoning. Service was ok, doubtful I'd be back. Decorated Irish theme that just felt fake and hokie

Way too expensive for an Irish pub, at an Irish pub you should be able to go there after work have a few beers maybe a sandwich and pay under 20 bucks, I'm pretty sure Guinness is seven dollars there