Bella Pizzeria

As a family from the East Coast, we are always searching for a pizza joint that offers anything that resembles a classic New York slice. Luckily, we found Bella Pizzeria in the Hamilton Town Center mall! The pizza tastes and looks more like authentic New York than just "New York-style." Also, the large pies can feed 4 people for a very affordable price. When I'm not in the mood for pizza, I usually opt for the breadsticks or garlic knots, which are basically Heaven in bread form. They are buttery, garlicky, and are made even better when dipped in cheese or marinara sauce. One small thing that is certainly worth mentioning is that Bella's customer service is unmatched. Whether you call ahead for pickup or order at the restaurant, every staff member is so polite and welcoming. It's just another thing that makes Bella one of my favorite pizza places! I love stopping by Bella for a quick taste of home!

Really good pizza, lots of toppings. Fast delivery directly to the hotel room. Friendly person took my order when over the phone and honored an online deal because I was having issues with the website.

This was our first time coming here for lunch. The place had plenty of room to sit inside and a few tables outside. The two people at the register is very friendly. I made sure to check in on yelp, and they gave me three free garlic knots, which were very tasty. The pizza had a nice crisp dough and the salad was great for a side salad. We ordered the slice, salad and soda combo, which was a pretty good price for lunch. We will definitely be back.

Bella pizzeria is a nice little place. Kind of reminds me of Puccini's because their calzones are better than their pizzas (in my opinion, of course). One thing you HAVE to get is the garlic knots. The garlic knots with their homemade ranch is absolutely amazing. Service is usually moderately fast. Pizza is pretty good usually, but I usually get a calzone.

I stopped in here last week prior to a concert. Staff was friendly and service was pretty quick. They had a decent selection. I went with a pepperoni slice, breadsticks with sauce and a drink. It was a lot of food. I didn't enjoy the ranch, so I wouldn't suggest ordering that. Would come back here again.

My boyfriend and I stopped in as we weren't hungry for a huge dinner and this definitely met what we were looking for. I ordered the slice of pizza combo with salad. The crust was crunchy but chewy and very tasty. One of my favorite types! The sauce does have a little kick. The staff were friendly and got everything out to everyone pretty quickly. It looks like they have pasta options as well, which I definitely want to go back to try.

Best italian food in the Noblesville / Carmel area Pictured is their buffalo chicken pizza & their Panzerotti......

I can't believe I've never reviewed Bella. The absolute best NY pie maybe even better than home grown Bay ridge. The first bite takes me right back everytime. I was born in Brooklyn i should know. The crust sauce and cheese to die for. Toppings? Who needs em! Anchovies on the side? Absolutely! A Cannoli? You bet! Nice kids taking care of business too! You can't go wrong!

So we just ordered delivery from here and it was our first time trying their restaurant so we got some of everything. We got an XL build your own with pepperoni bacon onion and extra cheese. Not sure if they put extra cheese or not. Definitely not in my opinion. The pizza was decent. We then ordered a baked ziti pasta and lasagna which both come with 3 garlic knots. We love bread so we were excited for the garlic knots but they were hard and like rubber. Same with the 4piece pepperoni sticks. The cheesy weezy was a little better but not much. I think it's near closing time for them as we placed our order at 7pm tonight but still we were charged the same $60 that anyone else would have paid so we expect fresh quality food too. Delivery was fast but we live very close to them.

I am not a fan of pizza... yet I crave bella pizza mouthwatering goodness. The sauce has the perfect tart flavor and it's just so good.