Pot of Gold
Caramel Macchiato
Nut Butter
Caramel Macchiato
In the back they have seating that's great if you are coming to get some work done.
Lavender lemonade
Adorable display and seating area!
Blended Unicorn
a shelf of coffee and cinnamon toasters
Mocha
Vanilla Latte
Snow Man Latte
Displayed nut butter to buy
Vanilla latte
interior
Just a small sampling of the available nut butters
Seating Area at American Dream Coffeehouse Noblesville
Blended Berry Blast
Free nut butter samples
drink
drink
Beautiful place!
Ayla N.
Feb 9, 2025
If you're on the hunt for a coffee shop that's as dream-worthy as its name, look no further than American Dream! They've got a menu that's as unique as it is delicious - ranging from the classics to creative speciality drinks. I went for the Caramel Raspberry Mocha (iced, decaf, with oat milk, because why not live a little? :D) The rich, velvety caramel blends perfectly with the raspberry, and that mocha flavor - perfection. I'll definitely be back for another. If you're into nut butters you'll be in heaven - they have an ENTIRE wall dedicated to specialty flavors! American Dream is the kind of place where you get to indulge your taste buds and let your coffee fantasies run wild. It's a must-try, and who knows? It might just become your new favorite coffee shop!
Read MoreSheree W.
Nov 16, 2024
Stopped in here after doing some shopping in the area. When I walked in there was just one other person there and also one person working. It took a little time for that person to get the person in front of me's order together so I did wait for maybe 5 minutes. or so before giving my order. The place must be pretty new and because everything looks pretty fresh. There is plenty of seating for conversation. Not sure the ideal place to work, but certainly to sit for a few minutes. I ordered just a regular coffee and it was under $5 which is nice.They sale some sort of butters which I think you put on bread maybe...? Also protein cookies. Love the colors of the place, feels really warm inside.
Read MoreSydney T.
Mar 2, 2025
This place was so cute and had so many flavorful options. I went for the Snowman Iced Latte which consisted of Vanilla and Toasted Marshmallow ~ delicious. They had a variety of Nut Butters available to purchase that I cannot wait to grab the next time I pop in. Nutritional label added for Scotcharoos, which sounds so good! For noon on a Sunday, the place was empty & I got my drink immediately. The vibes were good, and the cute signage around the shop gave ample opportunity for some photo ops. Can't wait to visit in the future with friends/family!
Read MoreLisa H.
Oct 31, 2024
Stopped by while doing some shopping for a caffeine pick me up and was pleasantly surprised to find the other treats available. They have so many varieties of peanut, cashew and almond butters with amazing add ins. I was pleasantly surprised when the barista offered us tastes of the butters we were interested in. After tasting a few we ended up purchasing some for gifts. Also thought it was cool that they had a toppings bar that you could add even more delicious treats into your purchases.
Read MoreOlivia O.
Oct 19, 2024
I was so looking forward to going here and trying the various samples of nut butters! I heard of them through the carmel farmers market and would love getting the little sample packs. Sadly they informed me that they no longer offer samples and will not be selling the nut butters so whatever was left I should grab if I wanted. Since we made the trek there I decided to at least get a coffee. I ordered the honey and cinnamon latte. It was pretty good but a bit pricey. The shop itself is cute and a good vibe and the deserts/pastries looked good.
Read MoreStefanie W.
Aug 23, 2024
I found this store bc the farmers market in Carmel, hosted them! I randomly picked the cappuccino but butter bc coffee makes everything taste better! Wow! I ate that jar in 3 days and didn't want to share with anyone. Pretty sad they're based out of Greenfield and I wasn't driving that far for peanut butter. However , they do ship online but then I noticed the coffee shop in HTC. Also a 30 minute drive but seemed closer. I walked in and of course, they didn't have any of the cappuccino butter, so I instead I bought 8 new tubs and received 2 free drinks. I snagged a dirty chai latte and a pineapple lemonade for my son. We throughly enjoyed it and suggested a punch card bc it made me a loyal customer!!!
Read MoreMegan F.
Oct 11, 2023
I am late to the game because I had no clue that American Dream had a full line of nut butters. They had some samples available, and so many unique flavor combinations. I ordered a latte, which was perfect to walk around the shops. Friendly service too and plenty of indoor and outdoor seating!
Read MoreKarla S.
Dec 8, 2023
So aesthetically pleasing!!! This spot is soooo cute!! I absolutely loved the decor. The "wow" factor is absolutely there when you walk in. While this is cute, there is one thing that makes this spot less accessible. Parking is inconvenient in relationship to the store front. I parked at Red Robin and walked over. Parking is huge for me (at this age lol) so I would probably only visit if I was already coming to the mall and would be walking around. Perhaps that is there target audience :)!There are no food options. I didn't see anything but nut butters and cookies in terms of available food options. Speaking of nut butters, this is where it's at!! They have a plethora of options, flavors, diet friendly choices! We were able to sample a few and they are tasty!! I tried a peanut butter latte and it was just ok. I'd love to give this place another shot! Maybe try another drink. The staff was friendly enough. They didn't jump in and offer suggestions or super warm and inviting. I told them it was my first time and had to ask lots of questions to get them to interact. It was a bit awkward. But in the end, after we had been there for awhile, they seem to have warmed up.
Read MoreDave C.
Apr 13, 2024
Very friendly guy behind the counter. This was our first time trying this shop. Very good coffee and muffin and the variety of nut butters they have are very good. Since it's located in Hamilton Town Center there is plenty of parking, you may just have to walk a little. Worth stopping in if you are in the area.
Read MoreErin Lee R.
Jun 30, 2024
Super cute coffee shop. The blended chai with whipped cream on top is perfect for a hot day. They have a crazy selection of specialty nut butters, and every drink they make is a work of art. Friendly staff. It does take a bit for them to make the drinks, but it's worth it!
Read More