Ahlemeyer Farms Old Time Bakery

I have been a customer of theirs since 2007. I have always loved their cherry pies. However, it seems since the new ownership has started in 2023 the cherry pie crust isn't the same anymore. It used to be flaky and cooked. Below is a picture of how they used to come and another of how they come now. When I called to ask what I need to do or ask to get the crust to rise and be flaky, Samantha was not nice because I told her I didn't have access to an oven on Memorial weekend camping to cook the top more. My family advised the dough to be soggy and inedible. I told Samantha it was gross. She got upset and told me not to use the term "gross" for it. Soggy dough is gross and I am sure not going tell her it was good. She did offer to switch it out on Tues after Memorial but I was taken back by her getting upset when I merely wanted to know how to get the crust cooked like it used to be cooked. If the crust is soggy and gross then it's soggy and gross. I'm not going to sugar coat it . If you can't handle someone saying that something didn't turn out right for a 20$ pie making it gross then maybe customer service isn't your forte. I surely wasn't rude about it but it definitely made me change my mind about supporting local small business. At least yours

Definitely worth the trip from where I live to Columbus to eat there! Just wish they would ship!

I absolutely love this bakery! They catered to vegan and gluten free people before the new owner took over. Now-they are 99% vegan and I love that! You can't tell the difference in taste at all! They still do gluten free which is awesome! We've been buying pies from here for holidays for years. I don't plan on stopping either! You an absolutely have to try the oatmeal cream pie! It's to die for!!

I was in the area and stopped by not really knowing what I wanted. As I walked in I could smell something heavenly. It was zucchini bread. So of course I bought a small loaf and a loaf of banana bread.Both breads were delightful warmed about 15 seconds in the microwave and with a slab of butter. My husband and I enjoyed them with coffee as a quick breakfast. They sell lots of pies and other goodies. Something for everyone that likes sugar.

If you are in Columbus, particularly northeast of downtown, make a point to stop into Ahlemeyer Farms Bakery to pickup some tasty goodies! Not only do they have whole pies, but they sell bags of chocolate goodies (pretzels and peanuts), single slices of some of their bread (I got zucchini), a variety of cookies, and even some pasta noodles!They also carry some locally made jams on a stand inside the small interior. The server behind the counter was very friendly and helpful. She mentioned they were a bakery for 28 years, so they must be doing something right. Making delicious food is what they do!I must comment on the blackberry turnover. It was absolutely the best I've had. No skimping on fruit filling and no mess from dripping. It simply gives you a lot of flavor with each bite. They also add just a bit of sweet icing on top of the flaky pastry.I also picked up a single Zucchini bread (most and tasty, but not too spiced) and a bag of peanut clusters which were larger than most clusters I've had and with a bit more crunch to the chocolate which worked well with the peanut crunch inside.Lots to choose from so take your time and browse.Review #2066

So I did not get to stop by Ahlemeyer Farms itself I stopped by a shop that had their products on display on my way back from Brown County Indiana. We had a ravishing craving for pumpkin bread and apple butter and my husband grabbed some apple cider. Basically we ate Fall. It was amazing! The pumpkin bread was moist and delicious. The best we have ever had! I just wanted to say thanks. My boys and husband really enjoyed it!

Stopped by for the first time today. They have a great selection of breads and pies among other baked goods. The sourdough is delicious. Highly recommend.

Amazing pies and goodies. Placed an order on line and it was exactly as requested. I can't wait to try their other desserts!

New ownership has taken over the bakery. Pies are not the same quality.Not the same friendly people. Not worth the price they are charging. Paid 50 dollars for 2 pies. Was going to purchase a sugar pie but it was dark with way too much cinnamon. Butterscotch pie was very liquid you could not cut into pieces. Pie crust was very hard. Meringue was hard. Called to complain and they had a bad attitude. New policy to charge a convenience fee of 3 per cent. That should be a cost for doing business. Most people do not carry that much cash.nu

I came from Texas to visit my brother and fortunately found out about Ahlemeyer Farms Bakery a few days after I arrived here.They are an old time bakery with grandma's recipes, their pie crusts are like I used to eat as a kid (70 years ago). Everything I have ever gotten from them is to die for. I have friends in Bloomington asking me to bring pies over for them when I go to visit. I certainly hope they raise enough on their GoFund me to stay in business bc I want to go there when I come back in the fall to visit. I thank them for keeping the traditional bakery alive, the mass produced goodies are not the same.