Hoosier Mama Pie Company
Hoosier Mama Pie Company
A bright tangy orange cream in a pecan graham cracker crust topped with lightly sweetened whipped cream. A safer bet than a Florida vacation this year.
We spike our maple pecan pie with chocolate chips and bourbon and dress it with stripes of chocolate ganache.
A delicious combination of autumn fruits.
This is an old southern classic. A sweet lemon custard pie that is the perfect compliment to a coffee or espresso.
Our decadent chocolate takes on the southern staple. We use single bean 70% Venezuelan chocolate. Customers nicknamed this the "brownie pie."
Rich thick chocolate pastry cream topped with lightly sweetened whipped cream and bittersweet chocolate curls.
A pretty golden custard flavored and decorated with chopped candied ginger.
Maple provides a more complex sweetness to our pecan pie.
Serve up s'more pie at your next campfire. Goes great with ghost stories and sing-alongs. No stick whittlin' required.
Our creamy quiche with sauteed mushrooms and gruyere.
An Indiana farm classic. A sweet creamy brown sugar filling inside a buttery pie crust.
Our exotic twist on an old favorite.
Tangy buttermilk adds zip to this pie with a cake-y layer and a smooth custard layer.
Oatmeal pie is the perfect breakfast pie! Oatmeal with the sweetness of maple syrup and hint of spice.
Fresh bananas in a thick layer of vanilla pastry cream topped with white chocolate curls.
A sweet peanut butter filling in a gingersnap crust topped with chocolate ganache and chopped salted peanuts.
Our creamy quiche with broccoli florets and sharp Cheddar cheese.
Metropolis coffee co's famous redline espresso gives this delicate cream pie its deep coffee flavor.
A creamy custard with concentrated roasted banana flavor.
Our creamy quiche with bacon onion and Cheddar.
Lemon curd from freshly squeezed lemons topped with a billowy cloud of meringue.
Tart apples enveloped in a tangy sour cream custard topped with a sweet walnut crumble.
Fresh squeezed key limes and a crisp ginger snap crust are the secrets to our version of this iconic pie. topped with whipped cream. (meringue can be substituted via email).
A smooth custard with concentrated coconut flavor topped with toasted coconut.
You guessed it. we put bananas in the bottom of our chocolate cream pie and it's really yummy. We also garnish the top with dried banana chips.
Slice of Lemon Custard Pie - not too sweet, very eggy flavor
Cherry Clafoutis Slice
Banana Cream Pie
Cherry Clafoutis Slice
a black and white photo
First time at this original Hoosier Mama location!!
Apple, Blueberry, Walnut Pie.
Patio
Cozy corner
food
Chicken pot pie
Boston Creme Pie
interior
Patio
Apple Blueberry Walnut Instagram @beyond.foodie
outside
6" chocolate chess.
6" chicken pot pie. Bought frozen, and reheated per instructions, ha!
9" chocolate peanut butter crunch, with the PB and crunch on the side (pie was still too warm from the oven!)
Chamomile Tea
Ryan C.
Jul 23, 2024
This place is fire! My partner and I ordered three food items: a sausage and Parmesan quiche, a ratatouille hand pie (empanada?) and a banana cream pie. All were fantastic, but I will remember banana cream one for a long time. Nothing hugely innovative about it, but it was exactly what you'd want a banana cream pie to be: thick and custardy, sweet (but not overly) and milky, spiked with vanilla, and with a crisp and buttery crust. My orange and cardamom latte was also super tasty. Hoosier Mama's back patio is very peaceful, and the decor inside has that homey, midwestern grandmother feel. Can't recommend this place enough.
Read More
Kristina K.
Apr 21, 2024
Everyone I asked about what I should try in Chicago was RAVING about this place, and maybe that's part of the reason why my expectations were so high.. tbh the vibes are pretty cool, but everything is way too expensive for what you're getting. We ordered quite a few different items: quiche, pastries, empanada thingies... all of them were a bit dry (except the quiche. That was good)Would I come back? Maybe if it was convenient. But I'm not going out of my way to come here
Read More
Allison H.
Apr 13, 2024
So deserving of its high reviews! This place turned me into a pie-lover.I tried the banana cream pie (just a quick bite before I left Chicago). It was the most unforgettable bite of my whole trip. I'm not usually a fan of banana cream (not a fan of Magnolia Bakery's banana pudding either) but this place hits all the marks-- the cream is pillowy, sweet (with no artificial flavors) and speckled with vanilla bean; the slivers of banana are tender yet firm, and the crust is buttery and flaky. Truly everything I could ask for in a pie. Service is quick. You can choose to dine in, where you can eat a warmed-up pie and admire the kitschy interior (there's a collection of pie tins decorating the wall) or take one to-go-- locals seem to do the latter. A lot of folks get the chicken pot pie-- I'll definitely try that next.
Read More
Erin C.
Aug 10, 2024
A hot Americano and a piece of breakfast pie is the best Saturday morning I can think of. Patio couldn't be cuter with a water feature and Parisian cafe music in the background. Cute inside but a little cramped. Be prepared to wait in line but it's totally that good. Definitely lives up to the old style pie shop claim. Lots of options to have fun with.
Read More
Kaitlin K.
May 4, 2024
Wowza super tasty pies! Ordering ahead and pickup were a breeze. The key line was creamy, tart and so delicious. I loved it!!!
Read More
Ann L.
Dec 26, 2023
Finally got to try the famous pies from this bakery.Ordered the chess pie for Christmas and added in pecan pie my husband's favorite. Crust is buttery and flaky (sturdy). I really enjoyed the chess pie which is basically a giant brownie pie. Pecan pie flavors are spot on. Wish the crust was a bit more crumbly but that's the fun of trying all the pie places
Read More
Jordan L.
Jun 22, 2024
You step into this place and you feel like you've been transported back in time. It gives very much an old school diner feel, but like progressive. The smells are immaculate, in fact I don't know if there are better smells in Chicago. The prices were reasonable and the service was friendly. We took our slices to go slices to go but there was seating inside and in their back patio area. We got several flavors and they were kind of hit if miss depending on your preference. Our favorite was the strawberry sour cream. The blueberry apple was also good. The coconut crème lacked the flavor I was expecting. This place cranks out a variety of flavor in both sweet and savory so trust and believe I will be keeping an eye on the flavors to see when I'll make a trip back.
Read More
Charlie T.
Jul 6, 2024
Amazing apple pie - full of flavor without being heavy, and the best cup of coffee I've had in the whole city of Chicago.
Read More
Shashank S.
Sep 3, 2023
Street parking with patio. Fun ambience with great service.Cute place with nice decor. Everything is fresh and handmade
Read More
John S.
Jun 19, 2024
Purchased two of their small pies from Green City Market, an apple and a strawberry rhubarb. I know this place gets good reviews and all, but man I'm sorry these were not the greatest pies. The apple was way too sweet, while the strawberry was a bit better. The undercrust on both was soggy and undone, and not very flaky. The filling was too heavy and crust too thin for the amount of filling. At $12 each for a small, I didn't think it was much better than a larger pie you would get at Mariano's or some other grocery store.
Read More
Rated: 4.6 (476 reviews) · $$
Bakeries, Coffee & Tea, Breakfast & Brunch
