Old Town Pizzeria & Tap House

This place is great!My favorite pizza is the Puaa/Meat Lovers and I also enjoy the meatballs which are served in their delicious tomato sauce and with some cheesy bread.And when dining in, I am always thankful for the sink in the middle of all the tables!Service is always great and it's easy to park around back in the lot.

We're in Wahiawā at least once a week, so we've passed this place several times. We weren't able to drive to pick up lunch, so we thought why not give OTP a try (and get it delivered). We've had Detroit pies when we travel as well as locally (shout out Pizza Mamo), so we were happy to see them offer the style of pizza. We got a veggie and a cheese. With delivery, wait was about an hour, which is fine though I wish it wasn't Uber eats and was the actual shop delivering the pizza. In my opinion, Uber Eats is always slower and results in food that is lukewarm. Total cost around $55 which was reasonable.However, the bigger problem was the pizza itself. Before getting into it, I'm just going to say that the sauce is fantastic --good flavor profile with a hint of spice. I wish I could say the same about the pizza. The cheese lacks flavor, the edges were not crisp and barely held their shape, and the pizza itself was underdone. Honestly, I think an investment in a better quality cheese would really help and perhaps more time spent on the crust. Unfortunately, I don't think we'll be back, but as it was our first experience, we might try to dine in instead and see if that makes a difference or pick it up ourselves.

Parking is behind the building, in the Walgreens parking lot but you can't turn left if you're going North on Kam - turn left on Olive Avenue and go around Walgreens to get there Not the cleanest place - I had to ask for a wash rag to wipe down my own table. Every single table inside and outside looked like it had been ran through. Probly be helpful to take a once around every now and then considering patrons seat themselves Not the fastest to getting your beer poured - we stood and waited by the counter even though there was a guy standing there just looking around. He seemed like he was new. The guy making the pizzas realized we were probly waiting for beers and helped usThe pizzas themselves were tasty and came out relatively quick Not a bad experience but dirty tables are an eyesore right off the bat

Brought home pizza that was burnt! Pizza was terrible. What a ripoff!!Gave 2 stars because the Detroit Pizza wasn't burnt.

We went to Old Town Pizzeria & Tap House to get some food since we were in Wahiawa, we got some pizzas and I got a Meatball Sub the Meatball sub was very cheesy and the sauce was pleasantly spicy so I was quite happy My friends enjoyed the pizzas and said it was tasty. The inside of the place had that look of a beer hall and looked comfortable to sit eat and drink. parking was plentiful and the help were nice also. If I am around Wahiawa again i wouldn't mind stopping in again.

Went here for Chicken In a Barrel and was pleasantly surprised to find Old Town Pizzeria inside too... perfect options/variety for our family of 4. Got the 16" Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza and a pitcher of beer (2 sizes of pitchers available - check out Happy Hour specials). Pizza was great... cheesy and creamy - nice cheese pull as we ate. It was delicious and exactly what we wanted. 2 teens pretty much ate the entire pizza. Would definitely return.

Having drove past here a ton of times we finally stopped! Ordered a few things and grabbed a table...The Detroit style pizza with the thick crust and sauce on top, the caprese salad and a couple beers. The pizza was light and fluffy, the marinara sauce was off putting. A little too overwhelming for the otherwise light pizza. The caprese salad with smoked chicken was decent, but not something I'd crave.Overall the good service is what netted this place 4 stars. The food is a solid 3 at most. Worth a try but not on my repeat list.

Not only was the food amazing, the service was exceptional!! I loved the tables that were shaped like surfboards and our table had a chest board. They provided us with the pieces. Game on baby!!!

I was excited to try their pizza out because of the unique names and combinations. Unfortunately, I was not satisfied. I ordered the pesto pizza, and the base is pesto, which ended up tasting a bit dry. The amount of cheese was also minimal, which I could see by other posts but it just didn't quite feel like a pizza. I also ordered the garlic knots and had very little garlic, but was nice and soft. I'm not sure if I'll try them again, but we took home the left overs and plan on adding extra cheese to it.

Do not I repeat! Do not come close to closing time! They get low and cut corners on the order vs just letting you know it won't be the same. Ordered 2 salads for $30 one was missing bacon and had a sprinkle of chicken. The other one had no dressing and half the ingredients.