Jerry's Pizza Mill

We went there late afternoon/early evening on Saturday. Lots of seating were available as it seemed like many people ordered for takeout. They don't serve alcohol, and the lady at the cashier suggested us to go a liquor shop across the parking. Good pizza and BYOB !!

Hostess/cashier clearly understands that my husband cannot eat cheese; it stated on the receipt "half no cheese, green peppers instead"; waitress agrees with our instructions because my husband is lactose intolerant, cook disagreeing with written instructions and proceeded to pick out the cheese with his ungloved fingers and sent it back to my table. Unreal. Not pono. A'oleOnly reason why I rated this 2 stars was because the only employee who did not have a problem with our order was the cook, everyone else that works there believes he should have remade the order correctly. Board of Health here I come.

Great Pizza and Great burgers! Service was friendly and quick. Pizza 16" and cheese bread for only $35!!! Great deal for sure!

Great service! We used to come here a lot, after Covid this is the first time in years! Still amazing! Ordered the white pizza and the fettuccine with marinara and meatballs. Also a side of cheese garlic fries. The only item that the wife and I agreed was not worth it was the fries. They seemed like an afterthought either way cheese. Not worth it.The white pizza is fantastic! No matter what always order a large! It's a few bucks more but you'll want the extra! Perfect!The pasta the wife said was good and she ate most of it. I was too full to try it, but I'll take her word for it.Overall well worth the drive to Waialua!

The dough is great. Thats always a good start. But yeah, time and time again this little country gem delivers . Clean with friendly service in a subtly kitsch one of a kind country town ambiance. And cherry on top? It's BYOB with a liquor store right across the way. We ordered the Waialua, because when you're at a pizza joint in Waialua... Can't wait to come back next time we come this way.

The lady here was so sweet, she definitely made our day. They have $5 slice deals on Tuesdays and Thursdays, which was an amazing surprise when we walked in. The pizza was soooo good. Definitely stop here if you get the chance!

Wow, the pizza is good from here. Wow wow wow it's always been good and it will always be good because the person owns it demands. That is great pizza. Let me just state that. It has no competition whatsoever!

This little hidden gem is tucked away in Waialua. Where the old Waialua sugar mill was located, it is a nostalgic little restaurant. They bake their own bread for their Sub Sandwiches, make a variety of delicious Pizzas, burgers, and side dishes. Today, 1/6/24, we dined in, and the AC was out, and the restaurant is looking like it's in need of some TLC. We love all their food on the menu, and it tastes great. I hope the owner can find a way to refurbish this little establishment. It's a GREAT spot, and you can even BYOB.

Best pizza on island by far just incredible ordered a slice and got two for $10 and had to wait about 15 mins but it's so worth it just fantastic

Had an errand on that side of island. Decided to try restaurant since picky grandson loves cheese pizza.So glad we did because the service and food was excellent! Would highly recommend this place!!