Rustica Pizzeria

The staff is always warm & welcoming, the pizza is definitely superior to most if not all pizzerias in town, & the prices are reasonable for sure. This place has it all. Happily been giving them my business for about a decade & my kids very much appreciate pizza party Friday's.Pro tip. If you're brave enough to try making your own pizza, they can provide you with dough & sauce! It's a lot of fun with the kids.

After having an utter fail last week at a neighborhood pizza joint, my husband came across this spot while picking up cheesecake from sweet garden. He bought a large pizza that was part meatball and part chicken/mushroom. Everything was delicious. My only partial complaint was the pizza was kinda limp in the middle but prob bc we live 20 min away and we ate at home. The crust was perfect and the amount of cheese and toppings were not skimpy. Def would order from here again.

Mixed review as I'm assuming one of the owners called to apologize with the mixup. It was our first time trying. Ordered via website for delivery. Order was not delivered, so I called about half hour after and he said he read it too fast and thought it was pick up. He apologized and included a free dessert which was nice. I understand mix ups, so I was ok with it. I ordered wings hot extra crispy, turkey sub and Stromboli. The wings were not tossed at all, it's like they were tossed in Tabasco and it melted off , they were plain and chewy. Not sure if it's because they sat around for my delivery, I'm assuming they would have remade them due to the error. Stromboli was great but undercooked. I threw it in the air fryer for 8 minutes and it was perfect. Sub was good. Again, I understand mix ups and appreciate the manager calling to apologize, but this being our first visit, didn't leave a good impression overall.

Been passing by this area but never went in until today. We were greeted by a man I'm guessing is the owner. My sons loves pizza so we ordered then I saw the sicilian pizza which according to him, they use double dough so its thick. Got the meatlovers Sicilian and for sure there are leftovers to bring home. They make their own sauce so I also got the lasagna which is an old family recipe.I dont know why I never went there sooner. Food is great, service is great as well. However, it is warm inside not sure if the a/c is out or weak so they use fansAs expected, got a lot of leftovers to take home. The pizza reminds me of deep dish pizza but cut into squares

This place has the BEST pizza, salads, pastas & sandwiches. It's a local favorite of ours & one that we take friends & family to when they are in town. Try the Rustica Supreme pizza or any of the pastas, Philly cheesesteaks are awesome! Inviting, fun atmosphere..service is excellent every time. We stop in to watch football & have a beer too. Really a great place!

Love the atmosphere and the food is so delicious, wish I would have took a photo before we ran through it the owner is the absolute best and super personable. The pizza crust is the best. Definitely recommend!

We have been a customers t in this place many years ago when it was under different management! Unfortunatly we did not liked the new management and we did not like the Pizza! Just two nights ago we actually stopped for the 2 NY style pizza it's a drink! We loved the pizza it was thin New York style we Loved it! We decided to try the pasta dishes! We ordered chicken parm and tortellini in pink sauce to our surprise it came with side salad and garlic bread! $14.99 each including the side salad and Garlic bread! Great Price and a lot for serving! We ate twice of the sand serving!This restaurant is highly recommended if you want a real home cooked meal! If you crave a real New York Pizza come to Pizzeria Rustica!!! 5 stars freshness and deliciousness!! Come to Enjoy!

So good!!!! Staff is ROCKIN!!!! Endless sodas! And pizza is great! We walk in and they remember what we like, and it's ready in a flash!

Today was our first time buying a pizza from Rustic and from talking to them on the phone- meeting them in person was a five star experience for us! When I got home and took the first bite of pizza, I had to call them to tell them how much we enjoy the pizza! We are how an every day customer.

The staff are so nice. Our drinks kept getting refilled and the food AMAZING! Our large pizzas here in Hawai'i are not as big as the large pizzas we ordered at Rustica and your garlic cheese breads...LOVED IT! Had 4 orders of it! Sorry kids started eating before I could get a whole photo and missing garlic cheese breads.