Garibaldi's Italian Eatery

Every time I come to town this is one of my first stops! I used to live 3 hours away and it was a must. Tip* order garlic bread with extra garlic seasoning.

I have been eating at Garibaldi's from back in the day when it was locatedat Town and Country mall.They have great pizza and subs. I have not had too much else there, but others that have, love everything they've ordered. My wife loves the patty melts, my mom likes the mostacolli, and our son loves the chicken nuggets.We had a Birthday party for our son several years ago and they reserved a large table for his group and let us serve cake that we provided. The kids had a great time and they went out of their way to make this a special event. They even gave him a giant inflatable Inccrdielbe Hulk!! I do miss their seafood sub from the 1980's! They have tuna subs I think but the seafood sub was one of the best I've ever had. Garibladis - can you bring back this very missed menu item?

What a cool experience at Garibaldi's! There's such an extensive menu, everyone found something they wanted to eat. I loved the (cheesesteak sandwich) Steak and Cheese which is under their Subs section. Delicious tender beef, mushrooms (I added it), and melty mozzarella on a soft roll. There was so much, I had leftovers for 2 days! Others had the steak supreme & it was just as packed filled with ingredients. We also had baked mostaccoli with meat sauce. They didn't skimp on the meat in the sauce and the cheese. The garlic bread was very soft and yet crunchy. The service here is always great. The staff is friendly and welcoming. They were super patient when we didn't know what we wanted and were happy to give suggestions. They sell pizzas by the slice as well! They're generous sized slices! The inside of the restaurant is fun with a rock 'n roll decor. There is a nice salt water tank filled with fish that keeps the attention of everyone. It's clean and bright with lots of seating!

I absolutely love this place for authentic New York-style pizza, whether you're grabbing a slice or indulging in a whole pie. The pepperoni and mushroom are my personal favorites--they're packed with flavor and always cooked to perfection. Whether you dine in or get it delivered, the quality is consistently excellent. The prices are reasonable too, making it a go-to spot for me since moving to Arlington Heights. This is hands down the best pizza I've found here!

Service was quick, but pasta was very, very overcooked. Unfortunately won't be returning.

Drove over 30 minutes just to get lunch here lol... this place has a massive menu, and it's all good. I'm partial to the roast beef sub served on a warm roll, with the seasoned fries. Pro tip: they have a honey mustard sauce that's cut with horseradish for a little kick. It's served with their onion rings, so you have to ask for the "onion ring dipping sauce" to get it on the side, but it's SO GOOD. My fiancé doesn't even like horseradish, but he was scooping this up with his fries. It's great on everything and will give your sandwich an extra punch.

A slice, and not super generous, and a pop was just under $10. I won't be going back there anytime soon. That's just ridiculous.

Great NY style pizza by the slice or the whole pie. My fav is pepperoni or mushroom. It's great in-house or delivery. Good price. It's my favorite pizza that I've had since moving up to AH.

Decent food with a large selection though nothing special. Average prices but don't feel it is a value for what you get. Interior is typical and service is hit or miss.

First time coming here and the last. Burger was completely raw. Now I'm worried I may be sick