a salad in a styrofoam container
a sandwich with meat and vegetables
Front of store
Prep space
Menu
Options!
Order and pay at the counter.
Sandwich choices
6 inch peppered beef, salami, provolone and veggies.
Salad
Meatball and cheese sandwich
#20
#20
This is the REAL place to get a sub!!!!
outside
3/29/20
Soups
Better selection of brands and flavors than most sub shops
6 inch tuna $3.80
interior
They also carry family size chips
outside
menu
Cookies
Average J.
Jan 3, 2025
This place is REALLY GREAT! From the bread to the proteins this is just amazing subs. The service is always super nice and friendly. You just don't see that anymore. So it is not only a joy to go to but the subs are outstanding no matter which you choose. The bread is nice and soft. They have all kinds of high quality proteins that they pile on (on like all those national chains). Veggies are super fresh and crunching. Just love this place and am thrilled each and every time I go.
Read More
Steven R.
Nov 23, 2024
Always get the #7 Salami and cappaaculo some of the best sandwiches in Denton. The owner and his employees are always friendly and the owner always remembers my order. Service is outstanding highly recommended.
Read More
Sharon B.
Aug 5, 2024
New to Denton, My fourth time visiting an never disappointed. Great sandwich n salads at Amazing price Always Fresh
Read More
Annie A.
May 9, 2024
Sandwiches are delicious and you can get almost any 12 inch sandwich for under $10. Subway and New York themed.
Read More
Larry M.
Aug 15, 2024
Found this place on yelp and based on the reviews, decided to try it. Got here and we were not disappointed. The food is fresh made in front of you. The pricing is fabulous for what you get and everything is delicious and beats out the chains by a mile, plus we're supporting a local business. I will definitely add this to my list to come back.
Read More
Jourdan W.
Jul 19, 2024
I love this place! I've been here multiple times since I moved to Denton a few months back. I was drawn to the location by their sign outside which says "35 years" and was intrigued. I prefer to support a small business when I can, especially one that has persisted like this one. They are one of the few places that seem to still have reasonable prices amongst their chain competitors, and they don't compromise on quality. The ingredients are fresh, delicious, and generously portioned. New York Sub Way will be a staple for me and my husband for years to come!
Read More
Christina J.
Jul 23, 2024
The best subs around. Once you try this restaurant you will not go back to any other. The decor is interesting. And the service is great. We go as often as possible.
Read More
Isabella R.
Dec 8, 2024
DELICIOUS, affordable, and the staff is friendly and hilarious. Cute vintage-y vibe. Highly recommend.
Read More
Dusty B.
Aug 16, 2024
Cute little shop with great food. Service was fast and friendly. Sandwiches were fresh, tasted amazing and came out very quickly. Definitely recommend.
Read More
Richard K.
Aug 10, 2024
Subs are great. They don't skimp on the meat and cheese. Bread was soft, fresh and held all the sandwich ingredients together. You're missing out on a good sub if you don't order the #20. Potato salad side was a little pasty but still had great flavor. A filling lunch with a large sub, potato salad and XL drink for $12! Aren't many places that can compare.
Read More