Elliott Bay Pizza
Elliott Bay Pizza
Love at first bite.
Aloha burger. Fresh ingredients. Cheesy and saucy.
Lunch
a burger and french fries
The Garlic Highway Pizza
a hamburger and french fries
pepperoni, mushrooms, and cheese
Not just pizza, but flame-broiled burgers, hot subs, and calzones. Mamma Mia!
The Deluxe No black olives
interior
We hope that means the visit will be worth the walk.
Small pizza place. Thw smell of fresh pizza brought us in!
food, pizza
pizza, drink
interior
pizza, food
food
interior
interior
Maui sub -- 6in
This is the note that I referenced in my review. So charming!
outside
Half cheese half whatever my husband wanted.
The Deluxe ...
Daina C.
Jun 3, 2024
Despite what the website says, they are not open on Sundays. We tried calling to place an order, but no one answered. Driving by shortly after 12:00 PM, the place was definitely closed!We have enjoyed their sandwiches in the past, but they are so unreliable lately.
Read More
Amanda D.
Jan 30, 2023
I'm not a big fan of pizza...but here she is with a 5 star review!Staying in QA for a long weekend and this place seemed like the perfect place to carb up before a night out with friends. I ordered a small deluxe pizza with no mushrooms and my husband ordered a 12 inch meatball sub.First of all, my pizza was adorable. Crust was delicious with the right amount of sweet flavor and there was minimal sauce. I. Love. Minimal. Sauce.Second, the meatball sub was giant. 12 inches long and 12 inches thick. Good hell. He was able to make 2 meals out of that. Would definitely recommend.
Read More
J. G.
Jul 4, 2023
We ordered delivery to our hotel visiting Seattle and they delivered the pizza via Grub Hub hot and fresh. Crust is just fine but the toppings were fresh, flavorful and no skimpy. Highly recommend A Taste of Greece.The garlic cheese breadsticks were more crispy than soft but my kids loved them.Solid, affordable pizza!
Read More
Pratima M.
Dec 14, 2020
Elliot Bay Pizza has solid pizza for a good price! It was super easy to call on the phone and order ahead -- we were able to get in and out in minutes. We got an XL sized "The Garlic Highway" for 3 people who were really hungry and it was filling and more than enough food. The flavor was definitely really good but not anything that special, and it also wound up getting a bit colder once we walked there and back home. That being said, it was good pizza for its price and I'll definitely be back if I'm craving some in Queen Anne!
Read More
Renee S.
Mar 23, 2022
Popped in while walking the hood, and grabbed a slice of pizza. They didn't have many slices out at the time, so I settled for pepperoni. Had I been by sooner, there would be more options. While disappointed there wasn't a veggie available, I appreciated that they don't make slices too close to closing time, potentially creating more food waste. They also have a huge menu of whole pizzas, sandwiches, salads and burgers which I'd like to go back for some time. You order at the register and either it in their small dining room area of take to go. The dining room is nothing special...not atmospheric, but very utilitarian, for a quick bite. They are open until 8pm.
Read More
George R.
Dec 11, 2021
This place has literally gotten like 100 times better since they put those Mexican guys on the grill. Quality is amazing! And for me it's all about the FLAME BURGERS. Best burger in Queen Anne. Dicks is literally trash and a gut bomb, you wanna come here for a burger for sure! I stop by and order To go like once a week now.
Read More
Darrion H.
Dec 23, 2023
I was undecided. Pizza or burger. Luckily these guys had both so we skipped our original plan to stop by Big Max to come here. My partner wanted pizza and I wanted burgers. Let's just say I'm very happy we came here despite the place looking a bit ran down from the outside.On the inside you can tell it's a pizza spot, but from the outside it's like they are advertising as a burger spot. So confusing. Who cares, they have plenty of burger options. My partner switched minds and ordered a burger also. Probably because the menu looked so darn good. Even tho I'm very happy with my visit I gotta keep it real. Their burgers are better than their pizza. The pizza just looked ok. I guess the burgers LOOKED ok also. My burger TASTED amazing. I bet their sandwiches are better than their pizza also. To be further honest no it was not the absolute best burger ever, but boy was it exactly the type of burger I wanted. So juicy and all the toppings so fresh. The meat was cooked perfect, slightly pink yet cooked all the way through. Juice was dripping on the table after every other bite. As soon as the dropped off my burger I immediately wish I would have also order so fries a I could savor them. I saved the worst for last. No parking outside as it's on the upper Queen Anne strip close to the Trader Joe's and Safeway. Parking is so slim I just walk to Queen Anne. It's not their fault. So what is their fault. Well it's just a bit eww inside even tho the place seems clean. They also don't offer us water or anything to drink. We dined in. I can't think of any place I've dined in that didn't either just bring water or at least ask... I'll be back regardless. I gotta try their subs now that I know their burgers are mad how I like em. Juicy and tasty and fresh and sauces to perfection. Yes. They even added proper amounts of sauce. Yes big max is super new and bright and yes they have tasty burgers as well, but on this day, I couldn't be happier with the decision to come here instead.
Read More
amy s.
Sep 20, 2023
A variety of things on the menu, quick and easy, great pizza and I like the meatball sub too
Read More
Z Z.
May 29, 2023
Don't know why this place doesn't have better reviews. The food is always delicious! Their plain pepperoni pizza and onion rings are to die for. The major challenges I have with this place thought is that they don't consistently answer their phone and their website needs to be updated. This also isn't the kind of place you want to really sit down and eat in for any sort of ambiance.
Read More
Ben D.
Feb 20, 2023
I almost never leave a review. I order local a lot, and so even when it is not great, I typically will give the restaurant a pass. Especially if it was my first time ordering from there as it was today with Elliott Bay Pizza. That being said, this order was ROUGH. I got a medium pizza, order of bread sticks, and a Philly cheese steak sub. The pizza was alright. There is definitely better pizza in the immediate area, but it was solid. The bread sticks were way overcooked and inedible, but sometimes mistakes happen. I wouldn't expect to receive those mistakes in my order, but it happens. I had read a lot of reviews about how this store had some of the best subs in Seattle, and this is where I'm really disappointed. I ordered a Philly, and what I received was 80% bread with two thin slices of roast beef and some cheese/onions on top. To the store owner - please do not call this a Philly. This is offensive to anyone that understands how to make one. I don't know what this was, but I would encourage you to actually eat a real Philly before branding one of your subs as such. On top of that, it was toasted for so long, that almost all of the bread was crisp to the point of inedible. I tried to take a few bites. Somewhat succeeded but ultimately decides that 1/5 of a six inch sub was enough. The rest of that sub went straight into the trash because it tasted horrible and caused physical pain in my mouth due to the viciously hard nature of that over toasted bread. If this was in the restaurant, I would have had a pretty frank conversation with whomever was working in the store at the time. Y'all really thought that was fine to serve? Nothing deserves that kind of abuse, especially not what started out as seemingly tasty bread. This was quite possibly a war crime against good sandwiches everywhere. Elliott Bay Pizza, I am sure you are better than this, and I hope you can prove it.
Read More
