Bagel menu - located inside NYP Slice House Pizza
Bacon, egg and cheese on green chile bagel
Green Chile & Cheese Sandwich on a sesame bagel!
The bagel.
Sesame seed Bagle, Bacon, Fig Jam, Asiago Cheese Blend.
Lisa K.
Mar 1, 2023
I mean fresh baked bagels in Cruces aren't on every corner. So the fact that they are making them is great. Is it a true NY bagel - no. Is the $10 (w/ tax) price tag for a bagel sand a little high - maybe. Does the bacon need to be cooked (so not so raw-ish and flaccid) - yes. This place in located inside NYP Slice House. And they have bagels from 8 AM until they run out. They have only been making bagels for a few months, so hopefully they only get better.They definitely need to add bagels and shmear (cream cheese) to the menu.
Read MoreJ L.
Apr 30, 2024
These bagels look disgusting. Wherever they learned to make them, they actually didn't. If you want a raw blistery bagel, then this is your place. They've been open for a couple of years now, so I'm surprised they're still open.
Read MoreRaquel B.
Jan 15, 2024
Change my life! I send people to this place! Never ever in my little ole lifetime have I had a bagel so dang fresh and good! That green chili bagel they all are! This place is a hidden gem! THE BAGELS ARE and when we travel the USA I hunt down bagel joints. Thank you for existing! You are knocking it out of the park your bagels make my mouth water just thinking about them! We will be back always and remain loyal customers always this place is !!! ~ the Boyd's
Read MoreTerri B.
Mar 4, 2024
Bagels are good but the sales gal was not very personable. I have purchased on two occassions. They were hot, fresh and are wonderful breakfast with Avocado!
Read MoreXanthe P.
Apr 1, 2023
Thank you Green chile bagel!! I had your 3 cheese, green chile on a sesame bagel...omg! So frickin delicious! People better get there early on the weekend because they sell out. Such fantastic bagels!
Read MoreYvette C.
Nov 19, 2024
These are the Best bagels and fillings in the area! There is abundant lox and cream cheese. Just delicious and a great way to start the day.
Read MoreDominique P.
Mar 5, 2025
Very good bagels, but it shouldn't take 20 minutes to warm and butter a bagel. Gave this bagel shop a second chance, to see if they would improve their timing. Same thing! I got there at opening time. Only 1 other person there both times I went who had already ordered. I could've went to Walmart, got a bagel, butter, and a toaster, and been off to work in better timing! No urgency. Land of mañana bagel shop.
Read MoreSandra T.
Nov 13, 2024
We are from NJ and we know authentic NY bagels! They know what they're doing here, so boiled and then baked! Service is always friendly and the restaurant is plush and inviting!
Read MoreDon H.
Jan 3, 2024
Let me say it was the worst bagel I have ever had. I had to throw them all away. I should have known when the paper bag was soaked in oil. I didn't dare put it on the car seat. I even tried drying one with a paper towel to no avail. I did put cream cheese on one but one bite and it was like biting into a soggy, oily, soaked in oil bagel. I had to spit it out and trashed them all. DON"T EVEN THINK OF GOING THERE
Read MoreDave B.
Apr 20, 2024
It's not an actual bagel shop. It's a door dash pop up, which is fine. Cashier, hostess, waitress rolled her eyes when I walked in with my 3 kids. Was very curt. After paying $40 for 4 bagels she let me know it would take 15-20 min....... I downloaded the app and created an account to post this review. In 2024. That was how bad my experience was. Oh and they got my order wrong.
Read More