Don's NY Pizza

Only been getting pizzas here a few times. I have to say it's delicious! Comes to the house hot and fresh. It's officially our new pizza place.

Having just finished a long, hot morning working outside, I was hungry for some comfort food. Looked on my Yelp app and found this place, and I am glad I did. Ordered the slice and wings lunch combo, with a soda, plus added a side salad. If you're looking for good NY style pizza, their name and food deliver 100%. Chicken wings were perfectly cooked with a great sauce. Don't expect something gourmet here. Expect something delicious and served quick. What was unexpected was the super friendly young woman at the counter. She took my order, brought me my food, asked me if I needed anything, etc. Very attentive, great service, above and beyond your typical fast-casual spot.

I go to Dons often. It used to be pretty good but lately the quality has gone down hill. I ordered two slices and they were raw. Mushy dough under the cheese and the bottom was floppy. Mozzarella seemed cheap. No stretch to it, it just kind of disintegrates in your mouth.

Still amazing The crust is perfect, I could be back home on L.I. Don & Co make their dough daily adjusting it to the weather then let it rest, When we call they hand toss it, and put it in a real pizza oven.

I'm from east coast and this is by far the best pizza I have had in Arizona!!! If you are looking for pizza that is like NY to Boston this is it! I love the supreme pizza so good!

Pizza good . Got to pizza by the slice and there were good . The only thing is I got a side of jalapeño and they were $3.50 ... lol yeah that was right . Service was super good and fast . I was here early so it was quiet.

everything about it is amazing. The food, the employees (super friendly), the environment, and overall the best pizza on peoria.

Well, fourth time ordering from Don's and it will unfortunately be our last, even though my husband and I love the food. We love it so much in fact that we have already recommended many friends and family. Tonight, I thought I would use their online feature to order dinner for delivery. My husband and I ordered the two pizza special for $30.99. I wanted a cheese pizza with jalapeños and my husband wanted a pepperoni. The online order system says: 1st Pizza Toppings. I selected jalapeños. It adds $4 to the total. (Note, while this is pricey, we know that they change $4 for every topping and don't mind). It allows you to select as many topping as you want for the first pizza, but as said above, I just wanted jalapeños. So I moved to the next section, second pizza toppings: I selected pepperoni. While ordering I was concerned that it would add both topping to both pizzas, but when I selected both toppings for both pizzas it added $16 to the total. So I was confident we were only getting one topping per pizza as our total was $38 (it would be $47 with both toppings on both pizzas). Well, our order arrived an it had both toppings on both pizzas. I was so bummed because I don't eat meat. Please know that I am 26 years old and my least favorite thing to do in the world is complain about food. I NEVER send food back. But I mustered up the courage to call. The woman on the phone was nice as I told her about the issue, but when I concluded telling her what was wrong she said, oh I'm so sorry that happened....we'll have a good night. I think she realized the awkward pause on the phone because she then sheepishly asked if we wanted one of the pizzas to be remade. I apologized profusely (again, even thought it wasn't my fault) but asked if they could both be remade because we wouldn't be able to eat either one. She said she would have to check and came back on the phone and said, "the cook said he would remake them but he told me to tell you not to use the online ordering system ever again". I apologized and thanked her. I then got off the phone and cried from feeling so embarrassed. My husband and I gathered up some money to give the delivery driver a tip again.When the food arrived about an hour later (which is not problem) I met the delivery driver outside, thanked her, gave her the $7, and grabbed the pizzas. As I was walking away she told me they needed the old pizzas back. I told her okay, and went a grabbed the uneaten pizzas (Don's, they were uneaten because we COULDN'T eat them like we said). I handed her the uneaten and cold pizzas feeling completely embarrassed once again.Coming from someone who has ordered four times in a month, and left a 5 star review, let me say you lost a costumer. Thanks for remaking the pizzas you made wrong, but we won't ever be back. Also, fix your website.

Don't waste your time or money. The pizza tasted worse than a frozen pizza box uncooked. I should have seen the sign when there was no one there.Note I spread love where it's deserved.

Great service and the food was delicious! Will definitely be back. Veggie pizza was best I ever had and the wings were perfect!