Sister Pie

We came in for a treat after some serious Christmas shopping. I had to try the pecan pie which I had to go. The pecan pie was mouthwatering delicious. It is very sweet as it should be, but the perfect amount. We also like the sea salt shortbread and of course the cinnamon rolls. The cashier was very friendly and patient as I made up my mind on what treats I wanted. I even added some cookies as a last min gift to give for the holidays. The bakery is small with a few indoor seats but there's some cute outside seating as well. There is parking on both Kerchaval and Parker. We will be back as we live dangerously close. Definitely stop in and try what all the hype is about. You won't regret it.

Super cute bakery! The staff were kind & helpful. The bakery items were delicious & I still think about the cinnamon roll! They have lots of options, it was so hard to choose from! A little pricey though. Such a cute spot with lots of street parking. Definitely worth a visit!

Sister Pie is an absolute gem in the West Village area. It's 10 minutes away from my abode and the self control it takes to not stop in at least once a week is far too much. Everyone is always very nice and there are options for gluten free friends at all times. Most recently I got the a slice of Maple Pie and vegan Brownie. The Maple Pie was so maplely sweet with a nice bite of delicious crust. The vegan brownie was just okay, it tasted vegan but not in a bad way just in a "I'm not a vegan so I rather be having a cream milky brownie" way. Will of course be back and happy to learn they started seving salads too!

Awesome little bakery with a big heart! I love their unique spin on traditional favorites and honestly have never hated anything I've tried! Some of my favorites are the black cheddar pepper scones for something savory- they freeze wonderfully, too! The honey lemon meringue and the cherry bourbon pies are knockouts. The pie crust is dynamite- it's flaky and buttery and reminds me of a croissant. Their Robert Redford cookies are a perfect balance of sweet and salty!Be sure to get there early on the weekends- they tend to sell out! Also, make sure to check out one of their classes. My friends and I loved the pie dough making class and learned a lot!

Came in on a Thursday morning and had a slice of the strawberry rhubarb lavender pie. The pie was amazing and the little dollop of whipped cream they offer is a must. However, I didn't feel very welcomed here. The cashier was a bit curt with me and seemed to just want me out as soon as possible. I had never been so I wanted to look around a bit. After I bought the pie, she mumbled something to me and after a few seconds, I realized she was offering me a starter. It was a nice offer.Though the pie was incredible, the 3 stars is really just a reflection of the sour service.

I have always wanted to try Sister Pie , and happened to visit a friend in the neighborhood. They had a spread of Sister pie goodies including the Pferffernuse pie, cranberry rhubarb pie, and a bean and egg galette. Wow! All were delicious . The crust and ingredients throughout were perfect. I will def find my way back when I'm in the area.

Holiday cookie box picked up! Sooo good with 6 types and 6 of each; orange drops, malted molasses, fig and honey shortbread, cocoa-mint sandwich, buckwheat choco chip, buttered rum shortbread!! Look forward to sharing these with family and friends!! Thank You Ladies!!

Lisa, Anji and the rest of the staff are absolute gems!Years ago (pre-pandemic) a friend and I attended the All-Butter Pie Dough Class and the experience was just lovely. Back then the class included a light meal of hand pies and salad and then we learned how to make their amazing crust. We got to take home a bag of treats with a rolling pin along with the recipe. We also got to take home the dough we made (which was enough dough to make two pies or one double crust pie). Everything I have tasted here has been just the best possible version of a thing. The bakery has been a huge part of breathing new life into the West Village and my only wish is that they were able to be open later each day so I could pick up a pie to take home after work.

Sister Pie is a cute little spot and we stopped by on Saturday morning. They have a couple of savory things but the majority of their stuff is sweet. There is one larger table inside to sit at and a few small tables outside.We got our baked goods and they were all delicious. The corn scone was unique and the pie slice we got was tart but balanced nicely. I also really enjoyed my hand pie and my mini pie sandwich.

I've been dreaming of going to Sister Pie for months, and have finally been able to visit on a Saturday morning! We came here around ten minutes before open, and there was already a line. I do suggest if it's your first time (and there's a line) to not be one of the first people as it's a bit stressful being unable to look around first.We got the cranberry pie, curry hand pie, and peanut butter paprika cookie. They were all so delicious, they even exceeded my already high expectations. The cranberry pie had a beautiful tartness, smooth texture, with a lemon base on the bottom, and the CRUST!!! The hand pie was also flavorful, warm, and filling. The cookie was moist and had a great chew. Overall, can't wait to come back. Sister pie has such a welcoming atmosphere, I hope to have the chance to look more around the shop! Also, just to try more of their pastries. The pie dough really is fantastic. As a home baker, I hope to get my crust skills to that level.