New Haven Coney Island

Breakfast Menu

1X1

1 egg any style, 1 sausage or 1 bacon, 1/2 potatoes or pancakes with your choice of toast.
$3.75
2X2

2 eggs any style, 2 sausages or 2 bacon or 1/2 ham, potatoes or pancakes with your choice of toast.
$4.75
Truckers Special

3 eggs any style, 3 bacon, 3 sausages, 1/2 ham, potatoes or pancakes with your choice of toast, and coffee or soft drink.
$7.50

Breakfast Eggs

2 Eggs and Toast

2 eggs any style with a side of your choice of Toast
$3.15
2 Eggs with 2 Bacon and Toast

2 eggs any style, 2 bacon and your choice of toast
$3.75
2 Eggs with 2 Sausage and Toast

2 eggs any style, 2 sausage and your choice of toast
$3.75
2 Eggs with 1/2 Ham and Toast

2 eggs any style, 1/2 ham and your choice of toast
$3.75
2 Eggs with 4 Sausage and Toast

2 eggs any style, 4 sausage and your choice of toast
$4.75
2 Eggs with 4 Bacon and Toast

2 eggs any style, 4 Bacon and your choice of toast
$4.75
2 Eggs with Ham and Toast

2 eggs any style, ham and your choice of toast
$4.75
2 Eggs with Biscuits & Gravy

2 eggs any style and Biscuits & Gravy
$6.25
2 Eggs with Italian Sausage, Potatoes and Toast

2 eggs any style. Italian Sausage and your choice of Potato and Toast
$6.25
2 Eggs with Corned Beef Hash, Potatoes and Toast

2 eggs any style with your choice of Potato and Toast
$6.50
2 Eggs with Pork Chop, Potatoes and Toast

2 eggs any style, Pork Chop and your choice of Potato and Toast
$7.95
2 Eggs with 5 oz. NY Strip Steak, Potatoes and Toast

2 eggs any style, 5 oz. NY Strip Steak and your choice of Potato and Toast
$7.95
2 Eggs with 10 oz. NY Strip Steak, Potatoes and Toast

2 eggs any style, 10 oz. NY Strip Steak and your choice of Potato and Toast
$10.25

Breakfast Omelettes

Cheese Omelet

Swiss, American, or cheddar.
$5.25
Ham & Cheese Omelet
$6.95
Sausage & Cheese Omelette
$6.95
Bacon & Cheese Omelette
$6.95
Mushroom & Cheese Omelette
$6.75
Broccoli & Cheese Omelette
$6.75
Chicken & Cheese Omelette
$7.95
Feta Omelette

Feta cheese, spinach, tomato, and onion.
$7.25
Veggie Omelette

Cheese, mushroom, green pepper, tomato, and onion.
$7.25
Gyro Omelette

Cheese, tomato, and onion.
$7.25
Western Omelette

Cheese, ham, green pepper, and onion.
$7.25
Southern Omelette

Cheese, sausage, onion, and gravy.
$7.65
Farmers Omelette

Cheese, ham, green pepper, onion, tomato, and sausage.
$7.65
Mexican Omelette

Cheese, ham, green pepper, onion, and chili.
$7.65
Meat Lovers

Cheese, bacon, sausage, and ham.
$7.65

Early Bird Favorites

1. 2 Pancakes with 1 Egg
$3.25
2a. 2 Eggs with Potatoes

Comes with toast.
$3.95
2b. 2 Eggs with 2 Pancakes

Comes with toast.
$3.95
3a. 2 Eggs with 4 Bacon

Comes with potatoes and toast.
$5.95
3b. Two Eggs with 4 Sausage

Comes with potatoes and toast.
$5.95
3c. Two Eggs with Ham

Comes with potatoes and toast.
$5.95
4. 2 Eggs with 2 Bacon, 2 Sausage, Ham

Comes with potatoes and toast.
$6.50

Breakfast From the Griddle

1/2 French Toast

With 2 piece bacon, 2 sausages or 1/2 ham.
$4.50
Pancakes

With 2 piece bacon, 2 sausages, or 1/2 ham.
$4.50
French Toast
$4.95
French Toast with 2 Eggs
$5.25
French Toast with Bacon
$6.25
French Toast with Sausage
$6.25
French Toast with Ham
$6.25
French Toast with Bacon & 2 Eggs
$6.75
French Toast with Sausage & 2 Eggs
$6.75
French Toast with Ham & 2 Eggs
$6.75
4 Pancakes
$4.95
4 Pancakes with 2 Eggs
$5.25
4 Pancakes with Bacon
$6.25
4 Pancakes with Sausage
$6.25
4 Pancakes with Ham
$6.25
4 Pancakes with Bacon & 2 Eggs
$6.75
4 Pancakes with Sausage & 2 Eggs
$6.75
4 Pancakes with Ham & 2 Eggs
$6.75
3 Blueberry Pancakes
$5.25
3 Blueberry Pancakes with Bacon
$6.50
3 Blueberry Pancakes with Sausage
$6.50
3 Blueberry Pancakes with Ham
$6.50
Waffles

Til at 2 pm.
$5.50
Waffles with Fruit

Til at 2 pm.
$6.50
Waffles with Bacon

Til at 2 pm.
$6.50
Waffles with Sausage

Til at 2 pm.
$6.50
Waffle with Ham

Til at 2 pm.
$6.50

Breakfast Sides

1 Pancake
$1.50
Peanut Butter
$0.50
Cream Cheese
$0.50
Toast & Jelly
$1.50
Muffin
$1.55
Biscuit Gravy
$1.50
Oatmeal
$3.05
Grits
$3.05
Sausage
$2.95
Bacon
$2.95
Ham
$2.95
Corned Beef Hash
$3.25
Bagel
$1.95
Bagel with Cream Cheese
$2.25
1 Egg
$0.95
Potatoes
$2.25
Grits Instead of Potatoes
$0.50
Oats Instead of Potatoes
$0.50
Extra Side Sauces
$0.50
Strawberry
$1.00
Blueberry
$1.00

Salads

Tossed Salad

Tomato and cucumber.
$3.15
Greek Salad

Tomato, beets, cucumber, peppercinos, feta cheese, and onion with pita. Add chicken for an additional charge.
$7.25
Chef Salad

Ham, turkey, Swiss and American cheese with egg.
$7.25
Tuna Plate Salad

On a bed of lettuce with cottage cheese, tomato, and cucumber with egg.
$7.25
Grilled Chicken Salad

Cheddar, tomato, and cucumber.
$7.25
Cobb Salad

Grilled chicken, bacon, onion, tomato, and cucumber with egg.
$7.50
Taco Salad

Lettuce, tomato, onion, green pepper, olives, cheddar, and taco meat. Substitute chicken for an additional charge.
$7.50

Coneydogs

Hot Dog
$2.25
Coney Dog

Topped with chili and onions.
$2.50
Slaw Dog

Topped with chili and coleslaw.
$2.95
Loose Burger

Topped with chili and onions.
$3.25
Footlong

Plain.
$3.50
Coney Footlong
$4.25
New York Coney

Sauerkraut and chili.
$3.50
Coney Special

Add chili, cheese, and onions for an additional charge.
$4.25

Burgers

Rocket Burger

1/6 lb. with grilled onions.
$2.35
Hamburger

1/3 lb.
$4.25
Cheese Burger
$4.50
Mushroom Swiss Burger
$5.50
Double Cheese Burger
$6.25
Bacon Cheese Burger
$5.75
Patty Melt Burger

On grilled rye, onion, and Swiss.
$5.50
Double Bacon Cheese Burger
$7.25

Sandwiches

BLT Sandwich

Bacon, lettuce, tomato, and mayo.
$4.95
Tuna Fish Sandwich

Tomato, lettuce, and mayo.
$5.25
Chicken Sandwich
$5.50
Tuna Melt Sandwich

On grilled rye with Swiss.
$5.50
Turkey Sandwich

Lettuce, tomato, and mayo.
$5.50
Corned Beef Sandwich

On grilled rye with Swiss.
$6.25
Reuben Sandwich

On grilled rye, sauerkraut, corned beef, and Swiss cheese.
$6.95
Turkey Reuben Sandwich

On grilled rye, sauerkraut, and Swiss cheese.
$6.50
Club Sandwich

Ham or turkey, with Swiss and American cheese, bacon, lettuce, tomato, and mayo.
$6.50
Veal Cutlet Sandwich

Lettuce, tomato, and mayo.
$5.50
Stacked Ham & Cheese Sandwich

On an onion roll.
$5.50
Egg Salad Sandwich

Lettuce and mayo.
$3.95
Breakfast Sandwich

With eggs, cheese, and ham, bacon or sausage.
$5.25
Fried Egg Sandwich
$2.95
Grilled Ham & Cheese Sandwich
$5.25
Grilled Cheese Sandwich
$3.50
Slim Jim Sandwich

Grilled on rye with ham, lettuce, tomato, and mayo.
$6.95
New Haven Delight Sandwich

On grilled rye with corned beef, coleslaw, and 1000 island dressing.
$7.25
Fish Sandwich

Tomato and lettuce on a burger bun. Extra pickles for an additional charge.
$5.75

Tacos

Single Fish Taco
$2.95
Dinner Fish Taco
$8.25
Single Beef Taco
$2.95
Dinner Beef Taco
$8.25
Single Chicken Taco
$2.95
Dinner Chicken Taco
$8.25

Pitas & Wraps

Veggie

An assortment of grilled vegetable.
$5.50
B.L.T.

Bacon, lettuce, tomato, and mayo.
$5.25
Chicken Gyro

Tomato, lettuce, and cucumber sauce.
$5.75
Gyro

Lettuce, tomato, onion, and cucumber sauce.
$5.75
Grilled Turkey

Lettuce, tomato, and mayo.
$5.50
Grilled Chicken

Lettuce, tomato, and Swiss.
$5.75
Tuna

Lettuce, tomato, and mayo.
$5.95
Reuben

Sauerkraut, corned beef, and Swiss cheese.
$6.95
Hani

Chicken strips, Swiss and American cheese, lettuce, tomato, and mayo.
$6.50
Chicken Quesadilla

Lettuce, tomato, onion, Swiss, and cheddar cheese.
$7.25

Traditional Favorites

Fish & Chips
$8.50
Shrimp Basket

With potato.
$7.95
Perch Dinner

Lightly battered served with potato.
$9.75
Baked Cod

Potato and vegetable.
$8.75
Smothered Chicken

Grilled chicken breast with mushrooms, onions, and Swiss cheese served with potato and vegetables.
$8.25
Spring Chicken

Grilled chicken breast with bacon, mushrooms, onions, and Swiss cheese, served with potato and vegetables.
$8.75
Veal Cutlet Dinner

Potato, vegetable, and topped with gravy.
$7.95
Chopped Sirloin

Topped with gravy, mushrooms, onions, potato, and vegetable.
$8.25
Ham Steak

Potato and vegetable.
$7.50
Liver & Onions

Potato and vegetable. Add bacon for an additional charge.
$8.25
Chicken Strips

With potato.
$7.25
Wing Ding Dinner

6 wing dings served with potato.
$7.95
Pork Chops

Broiled pork chops, potato, and vegetable.
$9.50
New York Strip Steak

10 oz steak with potato and vegetable.
$10.95

Childrens Menu Under 12

Kids Hot Dog & Fries
$4.75
Kids Hamburger & Fries

1/6 lb.
$4.75
Kids Grilled Cheese & Fries
$4.75
Kids Fish & Chips
$5.50
Kids Chicken Strips & Fries
$5.50

Sides

Cup of Pickles
$1.25
Chili
$1.25
Cheese
$1.25
Feta Cheese
$1.35
Pita
$1.65
Coleslaw
$1.65
French Fries
$2.65
Cottage Cheese
$2.50
Onion Rings
$3.85
Chili Fries
$3.95
Cheese Fries
$3.95
Chili Cheese Fries
$4.25
Sweet Potato Fries
$3.85
Mushrooms

Deep-fried.
$4.25
Wings Dings

6 pieces.
$5.25
Jalapeno Poppers

6 pieces.
$4.95
Mozzarella Stix

6 pieces.
$5.25

Desserts

Ice Cream

Chocolate and vanilla.
$2.00
Pies
$3.25
Cakes
$3.25
Rice Pudding
$2.35
Ala Mode
$4.75

Beverages

Juice
$1.85
Milk
$1.85
Hot Chocolate
$2.05
Cappuccino
$2.05
Soft Drink
$2.05
Coffee
$4.75
Hot Tea
$1.75
Iced Tea
$2.05

Mark G.

★★★★★

Feb 17, 2018

I love eating here. The place is small but that's okay because the atmosphere is pretty cool for a small town restaurant surrounded by larger establishments. The food is good, I haven't had anything that I don't like.

Bob N.

★★☆☆☆

Aug 18, 2024

Probably the worst hot dog in a coney I've ever had. The skinless dog itself was pure mush, like it had been boiled for a couple of hours. Also a coney comes w mustard on it, otherwise it's a chili dog. The chili fries however were very good, crispy fries w the perfect amount of chili on them.

Sandie Y.

★★☆☆☆

Sep 12, 2021

Stopped in for the first time. Got here about 11:30-ish am and the little place is full, so we sat at the counter. Customers seem happy. staff are busy and moving, seem to help others and work together well!!! Phone orders are pouring in! We are still in COVID times, so I wish staff would wear masks, but no staff are. They aren't sanitizing hands (lots of touching things). One staff member wiped her face down (including mouth area) and then grabbed the coffee filter and grabbing plates/bowls for soup and she just put her finger in her mouth and then picked up plates to deliver. ‍. We told another waitress about this - we'll see what happens. Okay, heard the waitress calling the offender back and clearly spoke with her because she just washed her hands (for about five seconds). This would be gross- even before. Im so glad this NOT my waitress, cause I would have walked out. I don't know if this is common practice, it cooks are placing the paper checks ON the food. ‍ Also, wait staff is bussing tables, clearing DIRTY plates, and NOT washing hands before handling clean plates/ serving customers. If wasn't for the fact that I'm traveling with a diabetic who HAD to eat, I would have left this establishment. It seems the locals like this place and the food was good, but there seems to be importance in hygiene - and for that reason, I will not come back. And that's a shame. I would have given this place 5 stars for the food and atmosphere- but hygiene is critical.Our waitress was Becky and she was great.

Dayna W.

★★★★★

Jul 23, 2022

Pretty great place to go when you just need a bite to eat on the road or when you just want some good old fashioned breakfast

Michael R.

★★★★★

Apr 4, 2022

Best breakfast around. Tasty and large portions. This is a breakfast and lunch place, and closes before dinner. The homemade soups are great, as well as the sandwiches. Daily specials are generally lunch and dinner fare...and tasty, as well. The place is clean, and the servers are friendly with personalities. This isn't a "burger place". It's more of an old-school "Americana" type diner. Lots of regulars, as well as small groups and truckers stopping in. Give it a try...

Mark H.

★★★★★

Jun 9, 2021

Nice stop for a quick breakfast or lunch/dinner. Their hours can vary so I'd recommend calling before you visit. Otherwise the owners and staff are always friendly and welcoming and I'm happy to continue to support this local to me establishment.

Kennedie R S.

★★★★☆

Feb 11, 2025

Small Town diner atmosphere. Always inhabited with regulars. Never have to wait long for your food to be served. Staff is very attentive and friendly.

Lisa C.

★★★★★

Apr 3, 2024

We love us some down home coney breakfast. Try deep fried American fries. The best!! It's quick and convenient!

Debbie G.

★★★★★

Sep 10, 2022

Found this little gem and it's the ONLY place we go to for breakfast. Food is spot on, staff works hard. They are pretty busy all morning and you'd never kmow it. They are friendly and down to earth. I feel like I'm up north where people know one another.

Steve D.

★★★★☆

Feb 22, 2022

It's good but the onions used on coneys are can microscopic onions it ruins the whole taste ...Put 99cent aspect to shame.

New Haven Coney Island

Menu

Breakfast Menu

1X1

2X2

Truckers Special

Breakfast Eggs

2 Eggs and Toast

2 Eggs with 2 Bacon and Toast

2 Eggs with 2 Sausage and Toast

2 Eggs with 1/2 Ham and Toast

2 Eggs with 4 Sausage and Toast

2 Eggs with 4 Bacon and Toast

2 Eggs with Ham and Toast

2 Eggs with Biscuits & Gravy

2 Eggs with Italian Sausage, Potatoes and Toast

2 Eggs with Corned Beef Hash, Potatoes and Toast

2 Eggs with Pork Chop, Potatoes and Toast

2 Eggs with 5 oz. NY Strip Steak, Potatoes and Toast

2 Eggs with 10 oz. NY Strip Steak, Potatoes and Toast

Breakfast Omelettes

Cheese Omelet

Ham & Cheese Omelet

Sausage & Cheese Omelette

Bacon & Cheese Omelette

Mushroom & Cheese Omelette

Broccoli & Cheese Omelette

Chicken & Cheese Omelette

Feta Omelette

Veggie Omelette

Gyro Omelette

Western Omelette

Southern Omelette

Farmers Omelette

Mexican Omelette

Meat Lovers

Breakfast Biscuits & Gravy

Breakfast Biscuits & Gravy

Breakfast Burrito

Breakfast Burrito

Early Bird Favorites

1. 2 Pancakes with 1 Egg

2a. 2 Eggs with Potatoes

2b. 2 Eggs with 2 Pancakes

3a. 2 Eggs with 4 Bacon

3b. Two Eggs with 4 Sausage

3c. Two Eggs with Ham

4. 2 Eggs with 2 Bacon, 2 Sausage, Ham

Breakfast From the Griddle

1/2 French Toast

Pancakes

French Toast

French Toast with 2 Eggs

French Toast with Bacon

French Toast with Sausage

French Toast with Ham

French Toast with Bacon & 2 Eggs

French Toast with Sausage & 2 Eggs

French Toast with Ham & 2 Eggs

4 Pancakes

4 Pancakes with 2 Eggs

4 Pancakes with Bacon

4 Pancakes with Sausage

4 Pancakes with Ham

4 Pancakes with Bacon & 2 Eggs

4 Pancakes with Sausage & 2 Eggs

4 Pancakes with Ham & 2 Eggs

3 Blueberry Pancakes

3 Blueberry Pancakes with Bacon

3 Blueberry Pancakes with Sausage

3 Blueberry Pancakes with Ham

Waffles

Waffles with Fruit

Waffles with Bacon

Waffles with Sausage

Waffle with Ham

Breakfast Children under 12

Kids French Toast

Kids Pancakes

Kids 1 Egg