Mayas Deli of Plymouth

Service was fairly friendly. My turkey reuben was made quickly and piled fairly high with turkey and they didn't skimp on sauerkraut. I wasn't fond of the soft rye bread they used--I prefer traditional rye that most delis use. Overall the sandwich tasted great despite the texture of the toasted rye. The potato salad is quite sweet, so if you prefer it that way, you'll be happy. I arrived at 3:44, and the sign on their door says they close at 4. Yelp says they close at 4. Google says they close at 4. Why then did they turn off their electronic menu boards and put the closed sign in the window at 3:50? As a person who often drives to a place at the last minute, I wouldn't come back if I drove somewhere for lunch and they decided to close early. Thankfully that didn't happen, and if I'm in Plymouth before 4 again, I'm interested in trying another sandwich or a soup. Enjoy!

Nice little deli in the heart of downtown Plymouth! If you're looking for a quick and casual bite to eat this deli is a good option. The options aren't huge but definitely shareable if you aren't starving. We spilt a Ruben and salad and were satisfied. The servers were pretty nice and the indoor dining is small but was clean.

Never been disappointed eating here. Great soups. The turkey chili is my favorite. A huge variety of sandwiches. Lots of smiles on the associates. It can be a little expensive. But in my opinion it one of the the few delis that is worth it. This is a go to place in my book.

Just found Maya's on a whim looking for a good to-go sandwich while in Plymouth for an event. Friendly staff, custom sandwiches made to order. Taco Soup and 1/2 roast beef sandwich was perfect for me. Chicken salad on rye for another and a custom turkey wrap for our third. Very fresh ingredients for sure! Everyone was full and happy. Ambiance was very simple but also was very clean. Not a lot of seating (maybe 20 chairs?) but we were ordering lunch to go anyway. I just remember noting the small sized space but offered an impressive variety of offerings. Definitely would return if we are in the area again.

This is a hidden gem, if you know you know. Great deli sandwiches, hot soup and fast service. We ordered the special of the day(deluxe grilled cheese and soup) and the turkey Rueben with sauerkraut on rye. Know that the bacon is the quick cook kind so it's super thin. We enjoyed our first experience here, we will be back.

The deli sandwiches and service are okay. The corned beef sandwich I ordered for takeout was nearly $10 with additional ingredients. I thought it was overpriced. The line starts at the end of the deli counter, not by the front door where the cash register is located. It was my first time there and I believed I could order my sandwich at the cash register. A decent lunch option if you are in downtown Plymouth.

The sandwiches are always great. I especially like the "Rachael" and their Reuben is fantastic. My wife always gets the ham/turkey club sandwich. Today I ordered a bowl of beef chili, they also have turkey and vegetarian chili. The sandwiches are made to order however you want it. Service is fast.

10/10. Would highly recommend. :) Ordered catering from Mayas for a party (approximately 50 people). So happy with everything! It was delicious and convenient. Everyone at the party commented on how good the food was. We ordered 3 trays each of Ruben and Italian sliders, 2 trays of assorted deli sandwiches, 2 large salads, a cheese tray, and a veggie tray. The sliders pop into the oven for a few minutes to get warm. Plenty of sauce and dressings on the side to go around. Everything was great! Thank you! (Forgot to take pics before everything was eaten)

Great menu and deli sandwiches were great! In town for a wedding and we wanted to grab a bite before. We were happy with our choices.

We were in Plymouth looking for a spot that eat and found Maya's in Yelp. What an absolutely great find!!! It's a small place but don't let that deter you from trying. My husband had the turkey swiss melt , and I had a BLT on rye toast. Both sandwiches were so tasty. My husband's turkey was so generous anhe said he wished he would have gone with the 1/2 sandwich. Orders are placed at the counter and the service was fast. We thought the prices were fair for the food quality. There are several tables for inside dining and an outdoor patio when the weather permits. We don't hesitate to recommend and will definitely return.