Mama Mary's Pizza - Toledo
Mama Mary's Pizza - Toledo
Chicken bacon ranch sub with Cajun ranch dressing on the side.
A-Team Member
Margherita Pizza
Ultimate Pizza
Colossal Pizza
A-Team Member
Tyna D.
Jul 3, 2022
Mama Mary's is terrific! We've been longtime customers of the location on Airport Hwy. and are so happy that another location opened closer to our home. This is located in the small plaza on the southwest corner of McCord and Central. The food is fantastic and is made with care with quality, fresh ingredients. We always get the boardwalk pizza either plain cheese, with pepperoni, or with green olives and we're never disappointed. My husband is from Jersey and we are really critical of most pizza since nothing compares to Jersey and NYC, but we found Mama Mary's on Airport years ago and were shocked at how close it comes to a real NYC/Jersey pie! Today was the first time I've gotten a sub from them myself and I felt the need to leave a review because it was so fantastic! The chicken bacon ranch is made with juicy house baked chicken breast that is seasoned perfectly and cut by hand, the bacon is delicious and plentiful, the provolone was delicious and perfectly melty, the lettuce, tomatoes, and onions are all very fresh and again, plentiful, and the in-house made Cajun ranch dressing (which I asked for on the side) was so flavorful! You have a choice of regular ranch dressing, Cajun ranch, or cheddar bacon ranch and your choice of cheddar, provolone, or Swiss cheese. The sub buns they use are very reminiscent of East Coast bread as well and really make the sandwich stand out. Do yourself a favor and stop at this Mama Mary's sometime soon. You will not be disappointed! The food is terrific and the service is excellent .... such friendly, helpful, and knowledgeable staff who go out of their way to answer questions and even went to the trouble of looking for a coupon for our order since we didn't have one. Five stars for sure for this wonderful place!!Sorry, but I only photographed the sub this time. We'll need to order again soon to get a shot of the pizza.
Read More
Jeremy W.
Oct 23, 2022
The last two times I've come to this place I've ordered online and it told me 30 minutes. Then I show up after 30 minutes and they just start making my order. Both times made excuses about their online ordering. Pizza is good but I would definitely call to place the order.
Read More
Alex M.
Aug 15, 2023
First time ordering Mama Mary's and it was a hit with the whole family. We got several options and all were great. The NY style crust margherita pizza reminded me of Mancys Italian - and that is a compliment. Looking forward to ordering again
Read More
Marilen P.
Jun 4, 2023
Excellent pizza!We order often when visiting Toledo. Always consistent. By far the best pizza around
Read More
Caitlyn R.
Oct 13, 2022
Best pizza I've ever had!! Fresh ingredients staff is super friendly and the food is seriously so good
Read More
