Cinco De Mayo: Mexican Pizza and Blue Margerita
Brooklyn Pizza - 16"
Menu July 2021
Bar area
outside
Sangria!
Sam the pizza man is the friendliest, sweetest owner!
Bar
Cheese Pizza sub vegan cheese - 10"
Greek Salad - Large
a slice of cheese pizza in a box
Inside
Pepperoni Pizza - 10"
Watermelon Mint Mule
Patio
Pizza
M43 Hazy IPA
Location
Pepperoni Pizza - 16"
Cheese slices
Pretty deep line at 5:30 on Friday
Draft beer & wine menu
Large Brooklyn pizza cold and soggy
Gabi S.
Jan 10, 2025
I have been coming here ever since I was a child and I have seen the evolution of this restaurant.This has always been my favorite spot for a New York style pizza - especially the margarita pizza! I have yet to find another pizza place that will top their margarita pizza. I love that with the new renovation they added a bar and made the place feel much more open. The service is super quick if you are coming to grab a slice - but if you are ordering a whole pizza -expect a bit of a wait. This is a place where you sit down and have a slice or take it to go. There's not too much seating and no reservations as you order at the counter. 10/10 pizza though and that's all that matters!
Read More
Becky L.
Oct 11, 2024
HORRIBLE PIZZA AND NOT CREDIBLE WITH THEIR WORDGO TO TOMATOES or BUDDY's. They have consistently good pizza and service. #brooklynpizza #tomatoes #buddys #pizza #birminghammichiganbrooklynpizza I had ordered a pizza on July 1 approx 4PM in person.When I brought home, it was dry, hard, with hardly any cheese. It was supposed to be very cheesy and the crust should not be hard. I offered to bring it back as I wasn't able to eat it. The Manager on duty told me not to bring it back and apologized; She gave me a store credit verbally over the phone and told me that I could use it the next time I ordered from them.I tried to redeem it today and the gentleman that said that he was the Owner, Sam, said that there was no record of the credit and that he couldn't keep her word. He retracted at end of conversation and said he was not the Owner. NOT CREDIBLE WITH THEIR WORD
Read More
Karl L.
Mar 1, 2025
A staple for years. Expanded location is nice and clean and great for families. Flavorful NY crust, dig the shrooms. Garlic knots are a must. Service has always been fast and courteous. I like to stop in for a slice and some knots.
Read More
Karolina K.
Jul 7, 2024
I wanted to try this place for years and finally got a chance. I'm very happy they do offer vegan cheese as an option. We ordered standard pizza, one small pepperoni, and one cheese with vegan cheese instead of cow cheese. Both in size small. They came out pretty quickly and were just enough size for one person. Both were quite tasty. The dough was good and quite thin but not as much as we would like and was more "bready". Crispellis prze is far superior and cheaper, too. Don't get me wrong, it was good, but if I had to choose, I'll stay with Crispellis.The staff was friendly, but the place was kinda mess, not the cleanest, and it was a little confusing where to get things, how to order. Nobody pays much attention to you. They are all busy talking to each other.Nice that they offer beer and wine. Cold Modelo was a perfect pizza pair on a hot day like today.
Read More
Andrea D.
Jun 10, 2024
Was hangry for pizza. Luckily found a parking spot & slipped in with 14 minutes on the meter. Love a slice that I can fold over & devour. The pepperoni was that for me. Got my friend a 4-cheese & margarita slice. If the latter was mine, I would have wanted MORE tomato AND basil.
Read More
Dalia A.
Nov 8, 2023
One of my favorite pizza places in Michigan! It truly is NY style pizza. I love their pepperoni pizza (which is beef pepperoni) and it is always my go to! They have a lot of seating inside since they expanded with some outdoor seating as well. Service is always fast and great. Highly recommend coming here!
Read More
Zainab M.
Apr 25, 2024
pizza is always delicious! highly recommend ordering ahead when possible because they get busy quick, and often! sometimes the service can be a little eh but otherwise great!
Read More
Hasan I.
Oct 3, 2023
Overall a great slice of pizza for a great price. The dough gets a very thin, crispy face with extravagant tasting sauce and a perfect layer of toppings that's not overwhelming for the crust to maintain but very good undercarriage. All slices come out of the oven piping hot and it served to you as soon as it's completed I would definitely recommend this for an after the bar stop or even for a midday treat wire out exploring Birmingham.
Read More
Lisa M.
Aug 12, 2023
We got takeout pizza and salad! The pizzas were delicious!! I love the thin crust. We ordered the hell boy and a cheese pizza. I was hoping /expecting for the hell boy to be spicier based on the name. It had a tiny bit of spice but I would've liked more!! Other than that, it was a great dinner!
Read More
Merve D.
Jul 21, 2024
Please don't be cheap ... this isn't deserving $24 something dollars ...margaritas pizza needs more tomatoes ( slices) and tomatoes sauce. Pizza dough is good I can't complain other than tomato and sauce
Read More