All Star Coney Island Restaurant

Love stopping by this place in my work travels. Coneys are some of the best outside of Detroit. Friendly family owned feel!

Ham and cheese hoagie was not good, very fatty piece of hamNoodle soup broth was good but noodles meh Incredibly friendly staff, quick service too!! I would stick with breakfast food here thoigh

Not the best. Had the fried mushrooms that were rock hard and probably frozen. Got a gyro and the meat was burnt and overdone. Service was excellent but the food was lacking.

All Star is amazing! They've courageously served excellent food on sunny days, rainy days, snowed-out days ... days when I'm sick they've got soup. Days when friends are sick they've got soup. Thanks All Star for SHOWING UP. You rock! We love diners and we love All Star wait staff, All Star's owners. Everyone gets 5 stars at All Star!!

I see a lot of whining on reviews for this place. My coworker and I stopped here on our way through town. We read the reviews but decided to give it a chance anyway.We were greeted right away and welcomed to sit where we like. Our waitress came right away and was very nice. Having never been here before, we had questions about the menu and she was very helpful. I ordered the "Coney Special" and changed the coneys to "All Star" coneys which have ground beef loaded onto a traditional coney. [Side note here: one reviewer complained about paying $8.45 for one coney, fries, and a drink but the special is $8.99 so that is on the reviewer not the restaurant.]The snap! If you know, you know! A good hot dog is all about the snap and these had a great snap. My first bite had me hooked. The chili is terrific, the ground beef was nicely seasoned and added a nice layer to the coney, and the snap of the dog sealed the deal. The coneys were so smothered that I couldn't pick them up and had to use a fork. While I prefer to pick my coney up and make a mess, it wasn't happening...and it was a work lunch. My coworker got a Greek salad and it was huge! He loved it. It had meat on it and he kept raving about it all. Our waitress convinced him (rather easily) to get a coney too and he agreed that the snap was perfect and the coney was delicious. Food was delicious. Service was fantastic. We talked about how good the food was all the way home. Don't let bad reviewers steer you away from this great place. Not sure when/if I will be in this town again, but I've bookmarked this location just in case.

We have a cottage up there, this is a go to spot for great coney dining choices & delicious breakfast foods at a fair price for the quality...which is fantastic. The staff & owners are very friendly & hard working & it is a staple for every Howell visit we make!They have a driver through if you're in a hurry which is also super convenient! The chili cheese onion fries go well with their Hanna chicken pita. Treat yourself to one of the better coney dealerships in the area!

Ugh! Give what customers pay for! Paid extra $.50 fir cheese, but where is it??? I even pointed it out before I left with carry out.

The stuffed cabbage was the worst I ever had. Couldn't even finish the dish. The waitress was nice but the service was mediocre at best. Too many restaurants out there to give them another try.

Terrible service, ordered pancakes that didn't come with syrup. Coffee is nasty . Menu shows large pieces of Shrimp but these are not but tiny shrimp and came with a very minimal cocktail sauce. We will never order from here again.

Don't ever order the oatmeal...Ordered twice now for kids, both times it was like concrete and uneditable.Most of the time there food is decent and both times it did come from door dash. Would of been nicer if they included a small portion of milk to add to it.