a sandwich with lettuce and tomatoes
two hotdogs with peppers and onions
trays of meat and vegetables
a piece of meat on a cutting board
the meat being cooked in the oven
26. Reuben
Italian Beef
The front dining area.
In back.
Turkey pastrami Reuben
The New York Sub entrance with a couple kiddie rides and picnic tables and 4 or 5 dedicated parking spaces.
Counter ordering; but they bring you your order when ready.
menu
Half Turkey sub made to order
26. Reuben
Best turkey Reuben ever!!
Texas Sub
The Grilled Palm Beach is Pimento Cheese. The Every Stop is all of the Meats!
Photo after this happened.
Hot Dog menu.
Gonna try out these subs
Full Texas Sub ATW
25. Pizza Sub
Mango flavor Joe Tea
John C.
Nov 15, 2024
....... READ THIS REVIEW ......D Magazine best subs in Dallas for a good reason! I've been eating them since 1974. Meats cooked in back - fresh and awesome. Many specials on the board too. Incredible secret recipe oil-vinegar sauce is their claim to fame as well. No other place comes close!!!! This is what a sub shop should be. GO!Family owned - support your local business!
Read More
Reyn M.
Feb 19, 2025
I've enjoyed NY Subs for years. Andrew makes a good sandwich with fresh meats, some of which he prepares in a smoker out back. But today, I went for a sub and was informed I had to order through their "robot." I do not order from machines. To say I dislike that would be an understatement; this is the third place I have walked out of recently because the order must be placed with a machine. There are too many other choices for me to tolerate that.I guess it's a drive over to Jimmy's now...
Read More
Bridget B.
Oct 10, 2024
You need a good quality lunch option? You found the right place!Upon entering, you take a small jump back in time to slower times with arcade games and ice cream parlor style seating that is clean and well maintained.I had heard multiple people rave about New York Sub and frequently responded with "can a sandwich really be THAT good?" And IT IS! I have tried The Italian, Every Stop On The New York Subway, and Turkey Pastrami Reuben. Each sandwich had distinct flavors and notably fresh ingredients. They also have a bbq company connected to them that always has amazing aromas coming from the meat smoker and they sell some of their items in the restaurant.I will highlight, this is a "no BS" type environment where the staff will make sure your order is taken and everything is correct, but don't expect a chatty bunch (not rude, but very to the point). GO CHECK THEM OUT!
Read More
Bob K.
Aug 17, 2024
UPDATED REVIEW 8-17-24I had been a fan of this place, drove a long way hoping to enjoy the pastrami sub yesterday, but the meat simply didn't taste good and was fatty. It was one of those surprises you don't like -- especially when you believe you finally found a sandwich with the best pastrami in the area. Pastrami is difficult to prepare. If a restaurant cuts back on the quality of the meat and the steps to prepare it once on site, it loses alot of taste.I don't want to judge New York Sub based on one new experience -- especially given the tasty sandwiches in previous years. It was as though ownership changed hands. Whether or not that's the case, I hope the owner will see the more critical reviews as an opportunity to learn how to improve, at least in my case, starting with the pastrami.
Read More
Daniel M.
Jan 16, 2025
Decided to head over for lunch today after seeing rave reviews. I was about 12 minutes away but didn't have too much time so decided to call ahead and place my order. When I arrived there wasn't much parking but luckily I was in and out so I just pulled into the neighboring 711. The place has a very unpretentious feel. Very welcoming to all. I am glad I ordered ahead because my lunch hour seemed to be going by pretty fast. Staff was friendly. I had ordered the Italian Beef with peppers and a mango flavored tea by a company called Joe Tea. This came out to 21$ which is a little pricy compared to the other Italian Beefs I've had recently. The sandwich I had was very big in size and definitely had amazing flavor. From the first bite you know this place cares about the quality of their food. It was phenomenal. The heat from the peppers was a little delayed. The bread was very nice and held together well after I poured some au jus over it. Very nice place with a great tasting Italian Beef sandwich. The tea paired very well and was very much needed after the heat from peppers started to come on.
Read More
Ashly H.
Aug 14, 2024
Wow! These subs are so good. Only get the Whole sandwich off you haven't eaten for a couple days lol. That thing is massive! Hubby got the Texas sub and devoured it and I got the half plain turkey and it's the least plain turkey sub I've ever had! Meaning it's mouth watering and so worth the wait. The line can get pretty hectic. The employees are swamped with in store and online to-go orders but they have a well oiled system you can tell. Nice and hard working. Worth the visit!
Read More
Brenden K.
Jun 30, 2024
I would give this place 3.5/5 but rounded up. I ordered the pizza sub and the roast beef sub. The roast beef sub was good, but the beef wasn't rare, its was more med well. But I'm glad I found a place with the style of roast beef that I like. I just hope if I try it again, it's the right temperature. Also, the sub roll was strangely sweet. Not terrible but just not the kind of sub roll I'm used to. The pizza sub was good, exactly what it sounds like. I'd definitely try and come back, just hoping the roast beef is cooked better.
Read More
Tom S.
Jun 17, 2024
My review may be a little biased because my work pay for the catering here so I spent no money myself. The meal that they got came with sandwich, cookies, and chips . I got the roast beef with pretzel bun and chocolate chip cookie. The cookie and sub really good. Normally I don't order subs but I could see my self coming back here on my own dime.
Read More
Scott F.
Nov 21, 2024
This place is so great, from the food to the ppl. Tucked away on a side street across from SMU, if you don't know about it, you could miss it. The owners have so much passion for bringing the best quality food at a price that can compete. It does give off like a sidewalk store in a big city and the stuff for kids is great. They give back to the community all the time. They also run a bbq bulk meats name and do catering I believe. Please give them a shot and you will be hooked.
Read More
GA M.
Mar 1, 2025
Loved this place for a long time but its popularity has sunk it. The sandwiches are good but the service sucks and the prices are now ridiculous. Since I had nothing to do for 30 mins while I waited on my $18 sandwich, I thought I'd warn you: if you didn't order online, you better not walk in here hungry. Oh...looks like they got my order wrong too!
Read More