Goodfella's Pizza
Goodfella's Pizza
Fluids. Soggy
a piece of pizza on a foil plate
the entrance to the restaurant
a variety of pies
a tray of food
a sign for goodfella's
Snoop Craigy Craig the owner with that savory cheese pie= you can't go wrong with that I tell ya
Raw pizza
Yummy garlic bread in buttery seasoned garlic sauce on a long hard roll.
Raw dough
Dry and tough
Under cooked
Almost ate it all before I remembered to take a pic!
Ordered the Philly cheesesteak pizza with the sauce on it. It was perfect because normally cheesesteak pizza does not come with sauce.
Doughy
Love it, Specialty Pizza Never disappointed when I come here
menu
food
food
dessert, food
restaurant
Meat Calzone
food, pizza
Sajmir A.
Feb 23, 2025
The best restaurant for eating Italian food and getting a free drinks. The owner is really friendly. I go up there all the time. I hope to go up there for a longer period of time for many many years to come Craig is the Apple absolute awesome guy that I will have ever met over there. Thank you for being in my area and in my neighborhood you guys are the best of the best pizza restaurant in town.
Read More
Lily H.
Jul 24, 2023
Great Italian place here in Wylie! I have not gotten a chance to eat inside the restaurant, but I did take a look around when I went to pick up my to go order this time. It was quaint and the staff was friendly... felt very personable and family oriented. All the dishes we ordered were good. I would say my favorite I ordered was the fettuccine Alfredo with grilled chicken. I like how the sauce wasn't too thick... the right texture and taste. Their prices are great... as well as their portions. Another visit I had a whole ago, we ordered a pizza here and I don't think we cared much for it, but maybe ordered the wrong one? I'd be willing to try their pizza again... because I did enjoy their pasta dishes this time.
Read More
Samantha C.
Dec 17, 2023
[Take Out Review]The people that work here are so nice! We ordered online for pick up. Super convenient, and the pizza was ready within 25 minutes! The restaurant itself is small, but can fit some bigger groups if some of the tables were combined. Pick up was super convenient and done at the counter. There were only 2 pizza sizes for order (at least on the online portal): large and extra large.We ordered a large pizza between the 2 of us and had plenty of leftovers to share! The garlic knots were great.
Read More
Adam F.
May 24, 2024
For a small pizzeria they always provide a 5 star experience from the food to the hospitality. I love Goodfellas still my favorite and first pizzeria I've had in Texas. I went for the cheese pie which you can never go wrong but as I was reuniting with Craig the owner as he always is working hard and listens too he was preparing an order of garlic bread. I instantly wish I had ordered one at least. It looked so good buttery seasoned garlic sauce on that long hard roll plus the melted mozzarella= yummy looking indeed. Check out my pics
Read More
Amy K.
Jan 10, 2024
Service outstanding. Very friendly staff. Fresh pizza and the Stromboli was amazing. Will definitely be back to take a pizza pie home next time.
Read More
Brendan R.
Apr 3, 2024
Owner and staff are very friendly! The Alfredo pizza makes me hungry just thinking about it!
Read More
Adrian B.
Mar 5, 2024
Never liked this restaurant. Pizza never has enough sauce and the crust is really doughy. I've had it in different settings and situations, and each time it gets worse. That's the best I can say about it.
Read More
Justin K.
Feb 7, 2025
Im a OTR truck driver they delivered right to my truck. the peperoni pizza was great and they definitely know how to make a Philly cheese steak highly recommended can't go wrong with this place
Read More
Jonathan R.
Aug 25, 2024
HORRIBLE. Took 2.5hrs to get the pizza and came raw. Box was soggy and leaked fluid down my arm when I received it and trailed through the house into the kitchen. Incorrect toppings on pizza. Calamari as a side tasted like old oil. The time wouldn't of mattered if the pizza was good but unfortunately we had to throw it in the oven to finish cooking and just did not taste good.
Read More
Trenton H.
Jul 28, 2024
Love there food it is really good. I would recommend the pasta combo. Staff is super freindly and the owner is super nice. The restaurant is super clean and tidy. I would recommend going here.
Read More
Rated: 4.1 (147 reviews) · $
Pizza, Italian, Breakfast & Brunch
