Bay34th St Pizzeria
Bay34th St Pizzeria
Sauce and Mozzarella Cheese
Sauce, Mozzarella Cheese and Pepperoni.
Canadian Bacon and sweet pineapple tidbits.
Buffalo sauce, Ranch, Mozzarella Cheese and Chicken.
Oven baked eggplant, basil, extra virgin olive oil, sauce and Mozzarella cheese.
Spinach, tomatoes, extra virgin olive oil, Ricotta and Mozzarella.
Ricotta, Mozzarella and Bolognese meat sauce.
A Healthy blend of Mushrooms, Green Bell Peppers, Onions, Black Olives and Spinach.
Pepperoni, Hamburger, Canadian Bacon Pizza Sauce and Mozzarella Cheese.
A combination of all our meats and veggies. Pepperoni, Hamburger, Canadian Baconand Onions, Green Bell Peppers, Mushrooms andBlack Olives.
Thin Sliced Beef Steak, Bell Peppers, Mushrooms, Onions and Mozzarella Cheese.
Perfect blend of Ricotta, Mozzarella.
Sauce and Mozzarella Cheese
Sauce, Mozzarella Cheese and Pepperoni.
Bacon and sweet pineapple tidbits.
Buffalo sauce, Ranch, Mozzarella Cheese and Chicken.
Oven baked eggplant, basil, extra virgin olive oil, sauce and Mozzarella cheese.
Spinach, tomatoes, extra virgin olive oil, Ricotta and Mozzarella.
Ricotta, Mozzarella and Bolognese meat sauce.
A Healthy blend of Mushrooms, Green Bell Peppers, Onions, Black Olives and Spinach.
Pepperoni, Hamburger, Canadian Bacon Pizza Sauce and Mozzarella Cheese.
A Combination of all our Meats and Veggies.Pepperoni, Hamburger, Canadian Baconand Onions, Green Bell Peppers, Mushrooms andBlack Olives.
Thin Sliced Beef Steak, Green Bell Peppers, Mushrooms, Onions and Mozzarella Cheese.
Perfect blend of Ricotta, Mozzarella.
Double layer of Pizza dough top and bottom all ingredients in the middle. Hamburger, Pepperoni, Mushrooms, Onions, Green Bell Peppers, Pizza sauce and Mozzarella Cheese.
Double layer of Pizza dough top and bottom all ingredients in the middle. Pepperoni, Hamburger, Canadian Bacon Pizza Sauce and Mozzarella Cheese.
Double layer of Pizza dough top and bottom all ingredients in the middle. Pepperoni, Pizza Sauce and Mozzarella Cheese.
Fresh Mozzarella Fresh Basil Pizza sauce.
Comes with side garden salad and garlic roll.
Comes with side garden salad, garlic roll and your choice of style.
Comes with side garden salad and garlic roll.
Comes with side garden salad and garlic roll.
Comes with side garden salad, garlic roll and your choice of sauce.
Comes with side garden salad, garlic roll and your choice of sauce.
Served over spaghetti. Comes with side garden salad and garlic roll.
Comes with side garden salad and garlic roll.
Linguine in a pesto sauce with a variety of mixed vegetables. Comes with side garden salad and garlic roll.
Comes with side garden salad and garlic roll.
Comes with side garden salad and garlic roll.
Comes with side garden salad and garlic roll.
Chicken on a bed of ziti in a pink sauce. Comes with side garden salad and garlic roll.
Sauteed chicken breast with spinach and mushrooms in Alfredo sauce and served over spaghetti. Comes with side garden salad and garlic roll.
Chicken sauteed with fresh garlic, onion, jalapenos, green peppers and mushrooms in a creamy pink sauce and served with spaghetti. Comes with side garden salad and garlic roll.
Mushrooms, bell peppers and onions sauteed in a homemade tomato sauce. Comes with side garden salad and garlic roll.
Chicken, eggplant and mozzarella cheese in a pink sauce. Comes with side garden salad and garlic roll.
Fried Chicken Breast marinated- with marinara sauce, mozzarella cheesebaked in oven.
Slice Chicken Breast- onions, fresh mushrooms, Green BellPeppers all sauted with mozzarella cheese baked in oven.
Fried EggPlant with marinara sauce, mozzarella cheesebaked in oven.
Meatballs covered with Marinara Sauce and Mozzarella cheese baked in oven.
Thin Beef Steak onions, fresh mushrooms, Green BellPeppers all sauted with mozzarella cheese baked in oven.
Pepperoni, Hamburger(beef) and Turkey Bacon.
A Combination of all our Meats and Veggies.Pepperoni, Hamburger, Canadian Baconand Onions, Green Bell Peppers, Mushrooms andBlack Olives.
A Healthy blend of Mushrooms, Green Bell Peppers, Onions, Black Olives and Spinach.
Beef Pepperoni.
Pepperoni, Hamburger(beef) and Turkey Bacon.
A Combination of all our Meats and Veggies.Pepperoni, Hamburger, Canadian Baconand Onions, Green Bell Peppers, Mushrooms andBlack Olives.
A Healthy blend of Mushrooms, Green Bell Peppers, Onions, Black Olives and Spinach.
Fresh crisp lettuce, beef pepperoni, turkey ham, shredded mozzarella cheese, tomatoes and black olives.
Lettuce, mushrooms, black olives and shredded mozzarella cheese.
Romaine lettuce, croutons, parmesan, cheese and Caesar dressing on the side.
Lettuce, tomatoes, black olives and red onions.
Fresh lettuce, black olives, tomatoes, red onions, cucumbers and feta cheese.
Fresh mozzarella, sliced tomatoes and fresh basil topped with a balsamic glaze.
4 pieces
Crabmeat, minced clams, roasted peppers in a pink sauce and topped with mozzarella.
Served with your choice of sauce.Buffalo Hot or Sweet BBQ
Pizza dough wrapped with pepperoni and fresh shredded mozzarella cheese.
Served with 3 meatballs.
Pizza dough wrapped with sauteed garlic, spinach and fresh shredded mozzarella cheese.
Served with your choice of pasta.
Same as plain has chocolate drizzle.
2oz size
4oz size
Caprese salad
Mighty supreme pizza
the front of the restaurant
Printed blurred menu 2 of 2 (July 2022)
a pizza in a box
the rules of life
a closed sign in the window
We customize your catering needs!
Printed blurred menu 1 of 2 (July 2022)
Pick up by the slice!
XL Cheese
Some great rules to live by!
food, crepes
Medium Buffalo Chicken pizza - too much hot sauce and chicken was kinda rubbery (July 2022)
Inside (July 2022)
Inside
Spinach and cheese pinwheel
Menu
Margarita slice and XL Buffalo Chicken slice.
Yum!
More mushrooms than pizza
Dylan O.
Feb 20, 2025
Really, really mid pizza.I got a cheese pizza and garlic bread for delivery, which came reasonably fast, but the food was not good. The pizza had very little sauce, and not a ton of cheese, then the crust was pretty plain boring crust. Not a pleasure to eat. The garlic bread was just a small loaf of bread that seemed to have a small amount of butter (maybe garlic butter) on top but could hardly taste garlic. The tiny cup of tomato sauce it came with did not help much.All of this and it wasn't a good price either. Won't be going back.
Read More
Anj L.
Oct 6, 2024
I ordered takeout for dinner as I was solo and was too lazy to cook. I opted for the mozzarella sticks and veggie calzone.The mozzarella sticks were quite average- as in I could buy these at the grocery store and heat them up in the air fryer. A little bummed.The calzone was large and full of mozzarella and ricotta, along with vegetables. What I really appreciated was that the veggies were stick crisp, so they were very fresh. This was a nice calzone and I was only able to eat half because it was so filling.I plan on trying their pizza and other meals in the future.
Read More
Aaron D.
Aug 27, 2024
This place has the feel of a NY pizzeria. Lots of ready to heat slices, calzones, strombolis and more laid out for view with a crew bustling behind the glass making food to order. I had a craving for a good baked sub and I had somehow found a photo of a philly cheesesteak on their Yelp page that looked like what I was looking for. Unfortunately, what I received did not match what I saw in the photo, as the bread was not very toasted, the meat largely lacked much flavor, and it was noticeably smaller than the photo I saw. I also bought a pepperoni roll which appeard to have been made yesterday, reheated today, and had dried out. The cheese wasn't melty and the dough was tough.I will definitely give them another shot and update this review if my second experience is better.
Read More
Carissa L.
Nov 8, 2024
Bay34's pizza is fresh and delicious every time, whether I dine in or take the pizza home. The service is quick and friendly. I highly recommend that you try this place out!
Read More
Chris K.
Dec 24, 2024
If you are looking for a good NY style slice in the DFW area you should do yourself a huge favor and check out Bay34th St. The slices are pretty close to what you get in NYC, they are sauced and cheesed excellently and the dough has the wonderful blend of crispy and chewy. They offer specialty pies if you're into that sort of thing, but you can't go wrong with the classic cheese or pepperoni. Ordered a few pies for a party and they arrived right on time. Excellent service and delicious pizza, what more can you ask for.
Read More
Shelley F.
May 29, 2023
The pizza here pales in comparison (quite literally) to pizza I've had in Brooklyn. The hallmark of New York style pizza is the thinner, chewy, and blistered crust from a wood fire brick oven. Unfortunately, this pizzeria's crust was pale and soggy from all the moisture from the vegetables. Perhaps the other pizzas are better, but the Mighty Supreme pizza was a miss for me.
Read More
Ashley R.
Nov 23, 2024
This is my go to pizza joint! Pizza is always good and people are friendly. No complaints!
Read More
Julie D.
May 15, 2024
I LOVE this place!! I go everytime i can go late into work so I'm the first customer when they are still prepping to open. The team is always so nice and friendly. I always get a slice of supreme and a soda. Not once have i had a bad slice and i can't say that about the other places i go for a slice. The slice has perfect crunch cheet with perfect cheese
Read More
L Minton R.
Oct 8, 2024
Live their pizza and unique varieties.Generational ownership who are always there and friendly.This is one of our favorite venues for pizza and great and friendly atmosphere.
Read More
Jan G.
Jan 26, 2025
Ok, so first I want to say I wanted to love this pizza given the reviews, but I didn't find this to be a good "NY" pizza. Personally, I want to bite into something that is so cheesy, with a bit of olive oil...this pizza doesn't come close. I also ordered the "garlic" rolls after reading a good review on the garlic "knots." They were doughy without a hint of garlic. Sorry, but I'll keep trying to find some authentic pizza. I'm hopeful but this was a major disappointment.Delivery guy was great! Thanks!
Read More
