Pennington's Cakes

They were really nice. It was reasonable, a little under $500 for a wedding cake. Unfortunately, one of the more memorable things that my guests still joke to me about is that I fed them stale wedding cake. Luckily, I only had to take the one bite for a picture, but it was stale. We saved the top tier for our one year anniversary. Even grosser. Yuck.

Delicious, beautiful cake! My husband's coworkers threw us a baby shower and got the cake from here. I believe the flavor was almond and holy moly it's one of the best cakes I think I've had! I'm usually not a huge icing fan, but the icing was delicious- not too sweet!I definitely recommend this place!

I had very specific request for my wedding cake I provided them several photos as examples. I talked with the owner and I was told 6 months before my wedding that what I wanted was easy and "totally doable" the cake that showed up at our wedding looked like a child made it! DO NOT GO TO THIS PLACE ABSOLUTE GARBAGE!

I really don't like to post a negative review of a local business but they have got to know so hopefully, they can turn things around. I ordered a cake for a family's party and unfortunately I was so disappointed at first sight because it didn't really look like the picture I had sent. The drawings looked really amateur. Second of all, the taste was absolutely not good. Nobody at the party liked it. It wasn't bad, but it tasted just like those package cakes you buy at the grocery store. Neither kids nor adults enjoyed it. Probably only 1/10th of the cake was eaten and it will got entirely to the trash. Waste of money and unfortunately I won't be ordering from there again unless they change a lot.

Ordered a speciality cake for my wife's birthday. I showed them a few pictures of cakes she liked off of the internet. They asked me to email them the pics and they attached them to my order. I came back on the date they promised and it was ready for pick up. It was very impressive and looked like the picture only better. Good attention to detail on a special made cake. Every phone interaction was professional and I would definitely recommend them!!

We had to postpone our daughter's wedding from May until October. Pennington Cakes held fast to our plans. We altered the cake slightly, but as usual, the cake was delicious and beautiful and was delivered to our location in New Braunfels on time ! Thank you again Stephen and Penningtons for doing such a great job on our second daughter's wedding cake!

Unfortunately I had to give one star, they don't deserve it. My sisters first baby shower cake was overly priced and a mess. $150 and it was UGLY. Then it tasted bad like it was frozen for a week. We have reached out to them and they have not responded. Walmart bakery is better than them. Dont be duped.

Friendly, very nice people stopped in to buy cupcakes and they were delicious. Small gem of a place that's been in business since the 1960's. Give them a try!

Came after I was told owner would stay to take my custom order even though I stated I could take my business elsewhere. Lady that answered phone was condescending and said to come on in. I get here and owner is also condescending. I will take my business elsewhere.

Came to them last minute in Oct. they were able to make me a cake in 2 days to get me out of a jamb. Thank you!