Watt Street Tavern

Staff very nice and timely. Interior is cozy. I like the small town feel. Pizza is good

Came here for a friend's birthday so there was about 12 of us. Atmosphere looks fine. Pretty clean environment. The potato skins were good, they had this cheese beer dip that went well with the potato.I ordered their 12oz. Ribeye with Side Salad and Steak Fries. And another friend of my friend got a steak as well.I'm putting this politely, but... DO. NOT. ORDER. A STEAK. HERE. EVER.The taste was so bland, it almost like it was cooked in a microwave. The fat almost had a gamey taste to it that I almost threw up. The steak honestly might be bad. The friend that has the same meal as I did, had the same exact experience, but he was too nice to say something, he only took a couple bites.Mind you, I have not eaten at all, I could probably ate the thing even if it's below average. But the steak was honestly the worst one I've had.The steak fries look like it was taken from the very bottom of the barrel cause they look like lil baby fries and it was cold. When I said something about my steak to the waitress, it almost as if she knew it was going to happen. Like this is a common occurring scenario. By the way, this steak was $29. No clue where that $29 came from. I tried my fiancés cod fish and those were good.If you decide to go here, go for hand food, not their main entree's.

Stopped in for lunch while visiting with a friend from Seattle. At first glance all.ools well and clean. There was a stronger small of cleaner in the air than I prefer at a restaurant, very noticeable. That said, I ordered a Manhattan to start the meal. A few minutes later our server returned and informed me that couldn't make a cocktail as they didn't have a bartender! Disappointing! They were able to accommodate a draft IPA. For a starter we ordered their fried pickles. They arrived piping hot with a side of their Southwest Ranch. The breading looked delicious but someone miss measured the salt! The same person also miss measured the Tobacco in the Southwest Ranch as well. They were a big disappointment as well. The bisque was fairly good as was the meatball sub. Not sure when/if we'll ever get back to Circleville.

What do they have going good for them? The meatballs are excellent. IF they have food and beer in stock, it can be a solid place. Unfortunately, it's the nicest restaurant in Circleville. We really need a better option. Again, food is decent if they have it. As far as management is concerned, ugh... the owner doesn't live in Ohio. When he's in town, everyone is on their best behavior. But when the cat's away...I'll be back again, because I have few options. There's not much to choose from in Circleville. There are a couple solid bartenders who I love. Sit at the bar and order the meatballs. The patio is nice and they have a great party room but again, the service is hard when not sitting at the bar. I find myself having to go to the bar to ask for help. Do with this what you will.

Good and bad with this restaurant. Good is the pizza and service. Pizza is hands down the best thing they have there. It never disappoints. The service is good and the people that work there are always incredibly friendly and helpful. It's a great addition to Circleville and I'm so happy this is an option. Now the bad. Prices, alcohol and quality of other food. The prices are extremely high for the area and the food quality. I feel like they are trying to be a high end restaurant and it's just not that. Sometimes the menu just doesn't make sense and is all over the place. And with the alcohol, you have to use a QR reader to view it. Not a single paper list of drinks in the whole restaurant and the bartender has no idea what they have. Like I said, I'm thrilled that this restaurant is here. It gives everyone another option in the short list of restaurants in the city. The pizza is definitely the shining star for this place! I just wish they would rein in the menu and make things stellar instead of just simply okay. And maybe give more food for the very high prices.

Love this hometown restaurant! Always great food and drinks! Service is great too. They have a nice patio area too.

Have been here twice. The steak ribeye was pretty good. The cod is to DIE FOR!! I just got back from vacation if florida and the cod here was better than most places I visited. Absolutely a stop when in town. Ps the bathrooms are a nice touch!

A filet please?"Nope we're out"Ok, a Ribeye then."Nope we're out of those too."Hmmm, let me have the Ravioli but I'd like a small bowl of marinara and a small bowl of alfredo sauce."The chef won't do that."Another glass of lemonade please?"You got the last glass."I couldn't make this up!Wednesday, 6pm

Eaten here twice while in town. Enjoyed the food both times. Pizza is good and has good selection. Ordered off the normal menu for lunch and had the chicken sandwich. It was good. Service for lunch was not great. An upscale place in a farming community, kind of interesting.....

They used to be good when we first moved down here. Sort of like all other restaurants, their food quality has gone very down hill and their prices have gone way higher. We used to love their fresh fries. The last two times they were in old nasty tasting grease making them dark brown. And seemed to be the end of the barrel crumbs.Their menu selection has dwindled down to VERY few things. Causing me to pay $28 for a steak. None of the meal was very warm We have started to go elsewhere. Not really worth the money anymore.